User:Fixer1234/sandbox

Exist "x" of the mind

• 615 for exist independently of the mind

• Christopher Janaway in Self and world in Schopenhauer's philosophy
• George Bealer in the Blackwell Companion to Metaphysics edited by Jaegwon Kim, et al
• William James in Psychology, briefer course

• 235 for "exist independent of the mind"

• Here's a little gem that uses both constructions in the same paragraph! [1]

Exists "x" of the mind

• 492 for "exists independently of the mind"

• Richard Schacht in Classical modern philosophers: Descartes to Kant
• Linguistic semantics: an introduction By John Lyons
• the three critiques By Andrew Ward

• 163 for "exists independent of the mind"

• John Searle in Mind, language and society and The construction of social reality,

• Maudemarie Clark in on truth and philosophy,

• Bertrand Russell uses both independent and indepedenently in The Problems of Philosophy.

Charlotte Witt,

• CUP's translations of Kant's First and Second Critique's

Problems from Kant By James Van Cleve (uses both)

• "that exist independent"

• "that exist independently"

Freedom and moral sentiment: Hume's way of naturalizing responsibility by Paul Russell

This author uses both independant and independently:

"exists independent of the mind"

[http://books.google.com/books?id=Q0mlCyKa1PQC&pg=PA37&dq=%22exists+independent+of+the+mind%22&lr=&client=firefox-a#v=snippet&q=exist%20independently&f=false "exist quite independently of mind"

What is cognitive science? By Barbara Von Eckardt

exist relatively independently

"exists independent of the mind"