.gif){kind=small}
Question regarding declined article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:ChallavaripallieditHi, I saw that you have declined the article that I published because of references. I created this article about a rural village which doesn't have many references over internet, so I added the most reliable reference I can find on internet, which is about a school in this village. If this reference doesn't work I can't think of any other references that I can add. So can I publish this article without any references?. Thank you for reviewing this article. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Pch0807 (talk • contribs) 15:40, 6 January 2022 (UTC) Draft: compop softwareeditHi, I would like to know which part of my article has against the wikipedia rules and got into speedy deletion? Thank you KimK Ng (talk) 09:45, 18 January 2022 (UTC)
Draft: Ciel (musician)editHi there! My AfC on Ciel (musician) was rejected as there was not significant coverage of the subject. But there are several complete features from RS on her: a massive piece from Resident Advisor, a profile from Now Toronto, as well as several articles on her label, from MixMag, and two independent biographies from Mutek and RA. There's also a profile of her promotion and activism work as Diskwoman from TO Now. There are also several reviews of her music: from Pitchfork and RA. The only citations she's mentioned in passing are best-of lists, but, that makes sense as it's a list of many artists -- but still worthwhile to demonstrate notability. To me, these citations demonstrate
Hello! I wanted to drop a quick note for all of our AFC participants; nothing huge and fancy like a newsletter, but a few points of interest.
Short and sweet, but there's always more to discuss at WT:AFC. Stop on by, maybe review a draft on the way? Whether you're one of our top reviewers, or haven't reviewed in a while, I want to thank you for helping out in the past and in the future. Cheers, Primefac, via MediaWiki message delivery (talk) 16:00, 16 February 2022 (UTC) drafting changes to European School of OncologyeditI have redrafted this entry in a more academic and neutral style and sorted incorrect external links. I hope this reflects what you were looking for. Thanks very much Anna Wagstaff (talk) 17:38, 16 February 2022 (UTC) Wan Adi Rafuan Bin Dato' Wan Abdul RashideditHi. Thank you so much on reveiwing the Bio. The reference in here mostly are from a book and it cant be found Online. How should i proof it? — Preceding unsigned comment added by Eddy Dato' Rashid (talk • contribs) 07:13, 26 February 2022 (UTC)
Medical articles.editPlease read Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources (medicine). An article you just approved [1] not only fails to comply with the guideline, but makes claims regarding survival rates which are grossly misleading and potentially dangerous. AndyTheGrump (talk) 13:03, 26 February 2022 (UTC)
Dsp13 (talk) 16:04, 26 February 2022 (UTC)
Draft:Peter MesoeditHello Hitro, I tried to fix the required corrections in the Draft:Peter Meso [[2]] according to your demands. 1. I deleted the names that weren't covered by relevant sources. 2. I removed all the references to Spotify. I would like to kindly ask you, if you can look at it again. Please let me know, if now the article is formally acceptable. If not, please let me know, what further changes specifically can I do to correct the article. Thank you much. Kindest regards, Efron Efron Moshe (talk) 12:34, 27 February 2022 (UTC)
Request for secondary revieweditHi there! I'm a fellow reviewer over at WP:AfC. I left a review on Draft:Uganda Internet Exchange Point and some follow-up commentary with the page creator (who has a COI) on its corresponding talk page. Reaching out to you to see if you'd be willing to offer a follow-up review or commentary, I am not sure whether the article should be accepted in its current state (I'm relatively new to the process of article review and this feels like a tough call). Totally understand if other works take priority or you'd prefer not to! Cheers, and thanks for your work in AfC -- great seeing your reviews there! SiliconRed (talk) 12:41, 27 February 2022 (UTC)
Changes DoneeditHey as per your reviews I have changed my content and also added some news references which is independent source of media. Hope now my article will get live URL : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Pericent Thanks in advance — Preceding unsigned comment added by 122.160.153.168 (talk) 10:04, 28 February 2022 (UTC)
Hi Hitro, Hope all is well. I was able to make a few changes and located a few more reliable links for the article, as requested. Can you please take a look to see, I need anything else? Good day!
Thanks for the information. I did add a notability link for the artist. In the year 2019 he had a Top 40 Chart song and a Top 100 Chart video, according to what you asked me to read on the guidelines for notability of people that is all I need to get approve and start off. As you know I'm fairly new to Wikipedia, please let me know if there, is something else I should add?
Citation bomb on new article drafteditHello, Thanks for the advise, as part of your comment below: :-) Symbol opinion vote.svg Comment: Classic example of WP:REFBOMB. Hitro talk 18:55, 2 March 2022 (UTC) Draft: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:GANSER_CRS_AG May you please let me know how can I improve the draft? The reason for the high number of citations: I endeavoured to avoid the following :-), but I also wanted to substantiate my article, in order to avoid any controversy (possible when dealing with technological inventions) or bias (possible when dealing with private companies' allegations): - Citations to work that the article's subject produced - Citations that name drop reliable sources - Citations lacking significant coverage - Citations that verify random facts However, as the research and development path of internal combustion engines and fuel injection is scattered with controversies (several inventors claiming that they are pioneers, sometimes in good faith, as they developed the same technology completely independently (without talking to each other), but simultaneously), therefore I tried to justify as much as I could when bringing about strong statements for example : "is the pioneer in common rail fuel injection systems, with the development from 1987 until 1992 of the very first diesel common rail fuel injection system in the world". Indeed, if you start calling someone a pioneer, you better prove and justify this allegation very well with independent and external sources. My sample of citations which I would qualify as most important : [1] https://ethz.ch/en/news-and-events/eth-news/news/2013/11/a-piece-of-eth-accompanies-diesel-cars.html => independent source + mention Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich (ETH Zurich) as cradle for the common rail technology + justifying other specifics: car model, field tests of 1993 at the conducted by the ETH Zurich. [2] https://www.nzz.ch/article9QM0G-ld.310566?reduced=true => independent source + justifying the inventors of common rail being: Dr. Marco Ganser & Pr. Max Berchtold, as alumni and faculty of the ETH Zurich. [3] https://www.ganser-crs.ch/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Auf-der-gleichen-Schiene.pdf => independent source + justifying the history of common rail + justifying the inventor oc common rail being: Dr. Marco Ganser/the Swiss company Ganser-Hydromag + justifying Alfa Romeo as first car with common rail + mention of the ETH Zurich as cradle for the common rail technology + mention of the first field tests carried out by the ETH Zurich in 1993. [4] https://www.mtu-solutions.com/eu/en/stories/technology/research-development/how-does-common-rail-injection-work.html => independent source + justifying the use of an Engine model 4000 of the German company MTU, as first marine diesel large engine in the world to receive a common rail as fuel injection system (in series / mass production) => That's a confirmation from the engine manufacturer-side too. [6] "Common Rail: Beiträge auch aus der Schweiz". Eurotax Auto-Information. No. 1270. 1997. p. 13. => independent source + justifying the inventor of common rail being: Dr. Marco Ganser. [7] Common Rail Einspritzsysteme - Gegenwart und Zukunftspotential (in German). ETH Zurich, Reprozentrale Höngg: Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich | Institute for Energetics | Laboratory of Internal Combustion Engines and Combustion Technology (LVV) | Dr. Konstantinos Boulouchos. 1997. p. 26. => independent source + justifying that the patent right of use regarding the first common rail injector invented by Dr. Marco GANSER was ceded to the German company L'Orange GmbH, in order to equip the first marine large engine in the world with common rail technology (an Engine from the German company: MTU). Along these citations, I used the two following sources as background canvas for the two first sections: Contribution to Common Rail and History, but strived to justify them with citations to avoid any bias, and also in order to check if what is being said on this website is reliable. https://www.ganser-crs.ch/ganser-crs/geschichte/ https://www.ganser-crs.ch/values/common-rail-history/ If a citation was also cited on the website of the company Ganser, I always tried to find another independent source to avoid any bias (patents, article in the press, research articles, conference papers, etc.) Hope that it helps. Please let me know. :-) Thank you. Pseudo-Welscher (talk) 08:37, 3 March 2022 (UTC)
Awesome! Thank you so much Hitro! :-) Pseudo-Welscher (talk) 07:27, 4 March 2022 (UTC) /* Draft:Peter Meso */ changes done, request for re-revieweditHello Hitro, I re-drafted the article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Peter_Meso again. I would like to kindly ask you again for re-review. I deleted first three references, that were not part of the subject. I read your further instructions and tried to focus on notability together with adding relevant sources and references to each of the sections. I hope this version looks better now. Please, let me know, if this version is acceptable or if I can improve something. Thank you much! Kind regards, EfronEfron Moshe (talk) 09:25, 3 March 2022 (UTC)
Regarding sourceseditHitro hi, I'm Mariam the author of Softr's article on Wiki. First of all thanks for giving great feedback with sources. I've already checked them but would you be able to provide some examples, like websites, articles, magazines that Wikipedia defines as reliable Thanks in advacne — Preceding unsigned comment added by 195.250.69.250 (talk) 11:52, 3 March 2022 (UTC)
Request Re-review of the page after correctionseditHi, I have done the corrections as you have highlighted and included more reference material available with regard to the subject matter. Further I have included more details taken from those references. I am doing this creation of the page as a partial fulfilment of my college assignment this particular Military Leader. Hence I urge you to be kind enough to guide me for completing this task before dealing. Thank you very much. Niroshwanasinghe (talk) 11:43, 4 March 2022 (UTC)
Wiki Page CreationeditHello, @HitroMilanese I need a Wikipedia expert for page creation and management contracts Pyretheplug (talk) 20:45, 13 March 2022 (UTC)
Samuel Kutcheredit1. Submission is improperly sourced a) Can you please explain this ? b) If you mean that the sources are mainly from the website http://www.samuelkutcher.co.uk/. then you will find that the pages contain the sources i.e. original material - posters, leaflets, newspaper entries etc. If this is not sufficient can you please clarify what would be sufficient ? Submission is about a musician or musical work not yet shown to meet notability guidelines I am not sure what you want here as proof. This is an accompanying page to [[3]] Other Wikipedia pages that mention Samuel Albert Sammons Royal College of Music. His pupils included Alan Loveday, Hugh Bean and Samuel Kutcher. He became a Fellow (FRCM) in 1944. He composed many short pieces for 15 KB (1,903 words) - 08:10, 5 December 2021 Cedric Sharpe magazine, June 1932, p. 35 Website detailing the life of violinist Samuel Kutcher. Accessed 06 Jun 2012 The Royal Academy of Music – Museum & Collections 12 KB (1,391 words) - 13:48, 12 February 2022 John Barbirolli cellist: the Kutcher Quartet, led by his former fellow student at Trinity, Samuel Kutcher, and the Music Society Quartet (later called the International Quartet) 56 KB (6,878 words) - 22:18, 18 February 2022 British Symphony Orchestra Hall the quartet consisted on 2 February of: Holding (1st violin), Samuel Kutcher (2nd violin), E. Tomlinson (viola) and Giovanni Barbirolli (cello). 96 KB (11,117 words) - 16:21, 7 December 2021 Current formatting is not acceptable. Can you explain more what is wrong ? Thanks — Preceding unsigned comment added by JSKutcher (talk • contribs) 11:36, 19 March 2022 (UTC)
KURV ArchitectureeditAdded more specific citations. Referencesedit"Karim Rashid launches design and development firm Kurv Architecture" Dezeen.com January, 11 2017. Retrieved 2017-01-11. "Karim Rashid launches Kurv Architecture, a new design and investment firm" Curbed.com January, 10 2017. Retrieved 2017-01-10. "Uptown Harlem Projects From Karim Rashid’s Just-Launched Firm, Kurv Architecture" Harlem World Magazine January, 11 2017. Retrieved 2017-01-11. "DC’s Most Eye-Catching Rendering in 2019" "Urbanico Realty Group enlisted industrial designer Karim Rashid and his firm Kurv Architecture to design a 37-unit building slated for 1200 Bladensburg Road NE" dc.urbanturf.com December, 20 2019. Retrieved 2019-12-20. Draft:Indian Ports AssociationeditHi HitroMilanese. Thanks for reviewing this article and sharing your opinion. The organisation is autonomous body working under Government of India. Request you to kindly check the revised draft and approve for the main space. Thanks in advance. Gardenkur (talk) 05:19, 25 March 2022 (UTC)
Hi HitroMilanese. Thanks for your suggestion. Made changes as you suggested in the article and kept it at draft for approving before moving to main space. Kindly share your opinion. Thanks in advance. Gardenkur (talk) 07:04, 26 March 2022 (UTC) Draft:Postcard (2014 film)editIf you want to make it an article, that is fine. But please retain the year as Postcard (2013 film), that is when it was first released as shown by the Hollywood Reporter review. DareshMohan (talk) 06:49, 27 March 2022 (UTC) Draft:Flores SecaseditHello, I created an article for the movie 'Flores Secas', which was rejected for lack of references. I added several new references. Could you verify? Thanks for listening. Movieinfosbr (talk) 19:57, 31 March 2022 (UTC) Draft:Brian W. FostereditHi Hitro! Thanks very much for the quick turnaround. What sources are you considering unreliable? I have 16 references listed, some of which are accepted references on Ashley Johnson. I'm happy to adjust but it will help if I can separate the wheat from the chaff...Thank you! 3shoggoth (talk) 20:01, 1 April 2022 (UTC)
Article reviewed declinededitHello there, I have just seen that you have declined my article on the basis of "not reliable sources". Since this article is about an actor who is not world-famous and comes from a small country, also unknown to most part of the world, there are not many references published online about the subject. The references that I have put are the only ones available online. Will the article be accepted if I take out all the references? I mean the article without references. Thank you and God bless you.Holy Nepal (talk) 22:09, 5 April 2022 (UTC)
Draft: Dylan Bernard (Musician)editHello! I hope your week is off to a great start! Reaching out because my submission for Dylan Bernard (musician) was rejected for not significant coverage of the subject. However, Dylan has been featured in 50+ online and print media outlets including print features in the biggest teen magazines in the United States, Tiger Beat Magazine, J-14 Magazine, and Popstar! Magazine. While J-14 was a round-up feature, both Tiger Beat and Popstar fully profiled Bernard with featured interviews. At domestic radio, his single Forever for Now premiered on Radio Disney and was spun for two months. Internationally, his single "Higher" charted on WAVE 89.1FM in the Philippines for 4 weeks alongside Justin Bieber's "Yummy." Dylan has also been interviewed and profiled on digital properties like EARMILK, Live Nation's Ones To Watch, Flaunt Magazine, Lyrical Lemonade, Tiger Beat, J-14, Popstar!, Radio Disney, M, TWIST, Just Jared, Just Jared Jr., Celeb Mix, DASH Radio, and countless others. His debut EP was released through Instrumental, an indie label owned by Warner Music Group at the time, and his current releases have all been released in partnership with SoundCloud, where he is still currently releasing music. In addition, he has written for major label artists like KEY of SHINee with SM Entertainment and Chinese Megastar Jackson Yee. Both of these placements came through Roc Nation. Let me know if you have any advice on how I can articulate this better in the draft or if you have any other suggestions for revising. Either way, thank you for your time and consideration. It is greatly appreciated! — Preceding unsigned comment added by Maxneuron12 (talk • contribs) 18:05, 11 April 2022 (UTC)
thanks for the revieweditthanks for the review. will learn more — Preceding unsigned comment added by IMFocusID (talk • contribs) 08:11, 13 April 2022 (UTC) Question regarding declined article for British hip hop group 2U4UeditHi there - I hope you're well. I'm just writing regarding your decision on the article which I drafted for the group which I manage. The decision claims that the references do not show significant coverage in published, reliable and secondary sources independent of the subject i.e. the group and I. However, I've included numerous independent, secondary and respected mainstream and underground hip hop music publications not just from the UK (i.e. Wordplay, Word is Bond etc.), but globally also (Complex). Moreover, as noted in the article, the group's music has been licensed by Netflix for one of the most currently streamed programmes in the UK 'Top Boy' (reference: https://flixpatrol.com/top10/netflix/united-kingdom/). Similarly noted in the article, the group has received radio play across the UK on one of the most popular stations in the country, BBC Radio 1 (reference: https://yougov.co.uk/ratings/media/popularity/radio-stations/all). The group has also performed across the UK in major cities such as London and Birmingham. For an indie group from a small town in the UK to have received such inter/national coverage for its music is an achievement, so we'd really appreciate the opportunity to document this on Wikipedia so that future generations of listeners of the group will be able to be inspired by this. I hope this is helpful in overturning the initial decision. If not, I'd be grateful for your thoughts, and views on how I could amend the article in its current draft so that it better meets the requirements. Thank you very much! — Preceding unsigned comment added by RobAt2U4U (talk • contribs) 19:01, 15 April 2022 (UTC)
Thank you for feedbackeditHi there In line with the comment left by you I have added the sources from WP:RS and expanded the article. Please review it. Thanks. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Ziggy&moondog (talk • contribs) 09:20, 23 April 2022 (UTC) Draft:2020–21_Bahraini_Premier_LeagueeditHi, as long as I know, Soccerway is a reliable source. But why did you deciline the submission? Hhkohh (talk) 13:46, 23 April 2022 (UTC) |