 | This user subpage is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference. If you want to revive discussion regarding the subject, you might try contacting the user in question or seeking broader input via a forum such as the village pump. |
This is a list of Minor League Baseball players (initially the list was made up by articles created by User:Gjr rodriguez, but it has expanded since then) that may or may not:
- Pass the general notability guidelines
- Pass an interpretation of WP:ATHLETE that Minor League Baseball players are not "fully professional" (and therefore are not inherently notable)
- Pass the guidelines at Wikipedia:WikiProject Baseball/Notability guidelines
This is a list to show the status of each article, it is not an endorsement for the articles deletion, nor is it an endorsement of its being kept.
Update: 8 December 2012. In its original format this list was made up of several sub-groups based on if the player had reached a certain level or received a certain amount of coverage. Given the fluid nature of players changing teams/leagues this is no longer feasible, so they are just broken down into "deleted or not". Also over the last 2+ years various articles on this list that were deleted were recreated on their own merits, deleted from lack thereof, or redirected because that's how Wikipedia rolls. As stated above this page is not an endorsement for keeping or deleting, it is more of a holding pen to see what the status of the articles are. More of a "why is this link blue/red". I envision revisiting this page periodically to move pages within appropriately, or nominate for deletion if warranted. The blue links will probably separate again.
Update: 16 April 2014. This list has mainly been sorted, there are a few players with articles that still have not made it to the Majors, and have been retained because consensus at AfD was they meet the General Notability Guidelines. This effectively draws to an end of this project.
Note the original comments from the original scope of this project are included beside the player's name. I would like to thank the following users who helped add to and maintain this list, including (but not limited to):
- Muboshgu (talk · contribs)
- Fabrictramp (talk · contribs)
- Giants27 (talk · contribs)
- HJ Mitchell (talk · contribs)
- Spanneraol (talk · contribs)
Current article status
editDeleted
editPlayed some higher level
editNot likely to be nominated for deletion
|
|---|
|
Now about another person
edit- David Austen → Was deleted - now about a crickter.
- Jonathan Ellis → Retargeted to DAB page
- Rex Rundgren → Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rex Rundgren - Merged and redirected to his father's page
- Chad Spann → Now a football player
- Chris Nicoll → Now about a radio station owner/operator.
Review at a later date
edit- Mitch Canham - OK - Seems like some reasonable GNG coverage (NYT Article)
At AfD
editNone
Passed AfD April 2014
editIn addition
editUsing rdcheck to review all Minor League player redirects in Major League team articles. Process:
- Check rdcheck to find invalid targeted redirects.
- Search Wikipedia to see if the name is brought up in any other team articles.
- Search for variations of the name (i.e. Tom vs. Tommy).
- Search baseball reference to see the last year in which they played, and if they are currently playing for another team.
- Nominate for RfD as requierd.
Complete
edit- San Francisco Giants minor league players
- Detroit Tigers minor league players
- Baltimore Orioles minor league players