Note: In this second round of analysis, I will analyze all speedy deletions performed on January 16th (UTC) that fall under CSD A7 or G11. I will exclude any of my own deletions performed on that date, any deletions that refer to any criteria other than CSD A7 or G11, and any deletions that don't specifically refer to either "A7" or "G11" in the deletion summary (just to save myself the time).
Ones numbered as "E" are excluded, as other criteria than A7 or G11 apply. The only exception are G7 deletions, unless this is marked in a way that would be clear. Some articles may be numbered twice, since they were deleted more than once on the 16th. Since the 16th is more than 5 days ago, articles that "would survive Prod" are those that were recreated, or for which the speedy tag was removed, or for which "hangon" was put up.
Keep in mind, many times for
Number | Article | Deleting admin | Meets criterion (1-5) | Would survive PROD | Would survive AFD | Description |
E | Www.s7.invisionfree.com/zanessa forever | Steel359 | - | No | No | A1 applies |
1 | LEE MOYLE | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Buddy or self |
2 | Innovatex | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No | No | Company, unspecified type |
3 | Imaginative Cinema Society | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | Yes[1] | No | NN Film appreciation club |
4 | Idiots Gone Mad | Steel359 | A7 - 1[2] | Yes | No | NN amateur, unreleased film |
E | Fullenkamp | Steel359 | - | No | No | A1 applies |
5 | Fastfude | Steel359 | A7 - 4 | Yes[3] | No | NN web forum with a specific topic. |
6 | Edward "Ted" Flinter | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No | No | Soldier. |
7 | Edward B Blunt | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No | No | Website creator |
8 | Chuck cipione | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No | No | Student |
E | Catharsis (band) | Steel359 | - | Yes | No | G4 deletion; deleted at AfD |
9 | Brian Folland | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Self/buddy |
10 | Brendan Purcell | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN HS athlete |
11 | Barrington family | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No[4] | No | NN family |
12 | Arham Karim | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN athlete |
E | Affinity Group For Minority Students | Steel359 | - | No | No | A1 also applies, NN club |
E | Scout.com | Steel359 | - | No | No | A3 applies, basically just a link |
13 | Fadead | Steel359 | A7 - 4, G11 - 4 | Yes[3] | No | Clothing line, A7 corp[5] |
E | Brett chauncey | Steel359 | - | No | No | A1 applies |
14 | Irianan | Steel359 | A7 - 1[6] | No | Depends | Nigerian politician |
15 | Dirtcheapware | Essjay | A7 - 4, G11 - 5 | Yes | No | Software seller, type unspecified |
16 | Down Burns October | Rama's Arrow | A7 - 5 | No | No | Band. Claim = "I creamed my pants" |
17 | Legs on earth | Rama's Arrow | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Band.[7] |
E | Mario Gallo | Rama's Arrow | - | No | No | Professor, college unstated[8] |
19 | La Excelencia | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 5 | Yes | No | Glowing review of a band |
20 | [[1]] | Steel359 | G11 - 5, A7 - 4 | No | No | Website with tagline & link |
21 | Solarcentury | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | No | No | Corp press release |
22 | SolarAid | Steel359 | G11 - 4, A7 - 5 | No | No | Charity w/brief pitch |
23 | Rock Creek, British Columbia | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | No | No | Link & tagline |
24 | QStar Technologies Inc | Steel359 | G11 - 5, A7 - 3 | No | No | Ad, computer storage company |
25 | PCI Geomatics | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | Yes[3] | No | Blatant ad |
26 | Lotus Eye Care Hospital | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | No | No | Publicity |
27 | In cup plus | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | No | No | Ad |
28 | Geomatica | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | No | No | Blatant ad, related to #25 |
29 | "coast dispatch" | Steel359 | G11 - 4 | No | No | Publicity statement |
30 | OrthoEngine | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 5 | No | No | Blatant ad, related to #25 |
31 | Optimized Computer Solutions, Inc. | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 3 | No | No | Ad, boasts are a bit interesting |
32 | Artbeats | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 2 | Yes | No | Promotional language |
33 | Big Brother PE | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 5 | No | No | Blatant ad |
34 | DEULA | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 5 | No | No | Ad excuse, related to #15 |
35 | Bohica Associates Corporation | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 3, A7 - 3[9] | Yes | No | Adspeak, product highlighting |
36 | HBA Pass | Rama's Arrow | A7 - 1 | No | No | FF program of Hewa Bora Airways, redir would be better. |
37 | ACE Rent A Car | Rama's Arrow | G11 - 1 | No | Maybe | Rent-A-Car chain, fairly neutral |
38 | D money | FreplySpang | A7 - 5 | No | No | "up & coming" rapper |
39 | Social CRM | Kinu | G11 - 5 | No | No | Blatant ad |
40 | Jesustown | Kinu | G11 - 5 | No | No | Flyer |
41,42 | Audrey Teschini | Kinu, Edgar181 | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Student |
43 | Don Wielogroch | Kinu | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN drummer |
44 | Kevin bird | Kinu | A7 - 4 | No | No | NN athlete (amateur, seems) |
45 | Rustygames.com | Kinu | A7 - 5 | No | No | Flash game site |
46 | Skull tag | Kinu | A7 - 2[10] | No | No | NN Doom mod |
47 | Andrew farkas | Kinu | A7 - 5 | Yes[3] | No | HS athlete |
48, 49, 50 | Kyle Harris | Edgar181, NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Self |
E | Doug Cutting | Edgar181 | - | No | Maybe | Undeleted on request |
E | Mrs butler | Edgar181 | - | No | No | A1 applies. NN teacher |
51 | Jherret ward | Edgar181 | A7 - 5 | No | No | Almost G1. Self/buddy |
52 | Burgess Roughton | Edgar181 | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN Consulting company |
53 | Acharya Kishore Kunal | Edgar181 | A7 - 3 | No | No | Vaguely locally prominent, but no good claims of significance |
54 | Sachin Patel | Edgar181 | A7 - 5 | No | No | Person who lives in Florida. |
55 | Sherry veal | Kinu | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Student |
E | Soadquake981 | Edgar181 | - | No | No | A1 applies. Screenname. |
E | Blake kelley | Kinu | - | No | No | G1/A1 apply. |
56 | U-18 Movement | Kinu | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN group, purpose given but that's it. |
57 | Jay Webb | Kinu | A7 - 2 | No | No | Local news meteorologist |
58 | James Robert John McDougall | Kinu | A7 - 5 | No | No | Self |
59 | Beers on the Lawn | Steel359 | A7 - 3 | No | No | NN club / outing. |
60 | How to makeup Vampire Fangs | Tonywalton | G11 - 5 | No | No | NN product with full instructions |
61, 62 | Constitution Society | Steel359 | G11 - 4 | Yes[1] | No | NN website |
E | Jon Roland | Steel359 | - | Yes[1] | No | G4 candidate |
63 | Hawk Ownly | Steel359 | A7 - 4 | No | No | Record company, 2 total cds. |
64 | Doug Skrzyniarz | NawlinWiki | G11 - 5 | Yes | No | Campaign ad |
65, 66 | Chrisak | Steel359, Merope | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | WebForum member |
67 | Carl Poole | Steel359 | A7 - 5 | No | No | Student |
E | Haydn Alexandros Carolus Boyce | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7, A1, G1 all apply |
68 | Bricktown station | Steel359 | A7 - 3, G11 - 5 | No | No | Glowing band profile, 1 album |
69 | Bridget Frances Moss | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | "Child star" no roles. |
70 | Sean stacey | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | Student |
71 | MGE UPS Systems | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | No | No | Blatant (very) ad |
72 | Curtin Engineers Club | Steel359 | A7 - 4 | No | No | College club, related to #59 |
73 | Ancient Roots Translinear Table | Steel359 | G11 - 5 | No | No | Software ad |
E | Ryo fakaura | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7/A1/G1 candidate |
74 | Bk jr bk | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | unsigned rapper |
75 | Andy richards | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | Random guy |
E | Taylor morris | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | Also attack page |
E | Michael T Plater Findlay | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7/A1 |
76 | Dzio | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5, G11 - 5 | No | No | Student photographer |
77 | Anton 'Fabulous' Drexler | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | WTF? G1 may also apply |
78, 79 | AcnEase | NawlinWiki | G11 - 4, G11 - 3 | Yes | No | Herbal remedy spam |
80 | 4FrontMedia | NawlinWiki | G11 - 3, A7 - 5 | No | No | Web design company |
81 | Alain Rassi | NawlinWiki | A7 - 3[11] | No | No | Self/buddy |
E | Michael Lerche | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | G3 applies, Obvious hoax. Claims to be a lawyer and in the NBA. |
82 | Wisetrend | NawlinWiki | G11 - 5 | Yes[3] | No | Blatant cut & paste ad |
E | Roly meates | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | Self-reversed, moved to Roly Meates |
83 | Pee wee gonzalez | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | Appears to be buddy; in spanish |
84,85 | Muckway | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Self. Stated "This is notable" second time. |
86 | Punjana | NawlinWiki | G11 - 4 | No | No | Tea commercial |
87 | Riverview Ramblers | NawlinWiki | A7 - 3 | No | No | Obv. local interest band, 1 album |
E | Asadhafeez | Sandstein | - | Yes | No | G4, reposted 7 times, G3 at that point... |
E | Christina-Tichuu | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7/A1/G1 |
E | Stephanie-Tichuu | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7/A1/G1 |
88 | John alexander frank | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | Student |
89 | Adri-Pop | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | NN girlfriend |
90 | Ryan Bratley | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | student |
E | Cindy-sama | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7/A1/G1 |
91 | The Michael Thomas Nichols | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | "badass" |
92 | Jake prante | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | "best person ever" |
93 | Alexander kupchak | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | random guy |
94 | Saul Hudson "Slash" Fan Page | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | personal website |
95 | Unclaimed Recordings | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | nn recording studio |
E | Camron | NawlinWiki | - | n/a | n/a | Vandalized revision, reverted to redirect to Cam'ron. |
96 | Patrick Truhler | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN student actor |
97 | Ade lunsec | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes[12] | No | NN film venture |
98, 99 | Beaulieu cuzos | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | nn cousins |
100 | Michael Cox (disambiguation) | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | nn blogger. |
E | The Mike Nichols | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A1/A7, "Mike is a badass" (related to #91). |
101 | Sudan Liberal Party | NawlinWiki | A7 - 2 | Yes[3] | Unlikely | Political party in Sudan, no claims. |
102 | Iconcrash | NawlinWiki | A7 - 2 | Yes[3] | No | NN band, 1 ep & 1 album, no info |
103 | Christian Smizzle | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | student |
104 | Rob Powell | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes[13] | No | Student |
105 | Carlos Castro Henriques | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | Student |
106, 107, 108 | The Parselmouths | NawlinWiki | A7 - 3 | Yes[1] | No | NN band, obviously local interest, 1 album |
109, 110 | The Wizards of Daggordale | NawlinWiki | A7 - 3, G11 - 5 | Yes[1] | No | NN band, obv. local, promo |
111 | The Mitch | JoJan | A7 - 5 | Yes[3] | No | NN dude |
112 | Arconia | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | nn band |
E | Mr.Geach | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7/G10 |
113 | Byron Gill | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | "Just an ordinary boy" |
E | Degoncire | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A7/A1, person, name only |
114 | David duhamel | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | NN badass |
E | Arnie the toad | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | G1/A1, NN fictional toad |
115 | The kimwipes | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | NN band/group |
116 | Animus3 | NawlinWiki | G11 - 4, A7 - 4 | Yes | No | Photo/blog, nn, ad |
117 | Droppedthebomb.com | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5, G11 - 4 | No | No | nn website ad |
118 | Droppedthebomb | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5, G11 - 4 | No | No | nn website ad, same as #117 |
119 | Lil Lankan | NawlinWiki | A7 - 4 | No | No | nn rapper |
120 | Kyle Oney | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | self/buddy |
121 | Josh khries | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | Self/buddy |
122 | Tyler Auten | Wwwwolf | A7 - 5 | No | No | name only |
E | INOSCI | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | G11/A7/A3 |
123 | ITITEM | NawlinWiki | G11 - 3 | No | No | IT company in Thailand |
124 | Gabriel Parada | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | G10 applies? Student |
125 | Richard Jeffrey Davis | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes[14] | No | Name & place |
126, 127 | Flosy the pig | NawlinWiki | A7 - 4 | Yes | No | nn webcomic |
E | Joe Broadbent | NawlinWiki | - | Yes | No | A7/G10 |
128 | Linda Bamford | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | HS teacher |
129 | IdentaKey | Wwwwolf | G11 - 5 | No | No | Computer product spam |
130 | Hans armknecht | Wwwwolf | A7 - 5 | No | No | Name & birthplace |
131 | Jet Black (band) | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN cover band |
132 | Martin James Ditmar Jenssen | NawlinWiki | A7 - 2, G11 - 2 | No | No | Misplaced user page, both boastful and attackish, see User:Meditmar for text. |
133 | Matthew Wood from Stoke on trent | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | seriously. |
134 | Matthew bond | NawlinWiki | A7 - 4 | No | No | student, full of BS claims |
E | Steven s | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | G3 hoax[15] |
135 | "Fox Valley Citizens for Legal Immigration" | NawlinWiki | G11 - 5 | No | No | Flyer with mission statement |
136 | Death By Munkees | Wwwwolf | A7 - 5 | Yes[3] | No | Band, name & genre only |
E | Hanna Farrell | Wwwwolf | - | No | No | A1/A3/A7. text: "A bad ass!" |
137 | F1Play.com | Wwwwolf | G11 - 5 | No | No | Clear ad |
E | Channing averill | Wwwwolf | - | Yes | No | A1/A7/G1 |
E | Antonio porcelli | ReyBrujo | - | No | ? | A7. Can't evaluate, in Italian |
138 | Justyn Marchese | Metros232 | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Innkeeper |
139 | Chris Doi | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | Ad representative |
140 | Red line ring | NawlinWiki | G11 - 5 | No | No | Flyer |
141 | Blue line ring | NawlinWiki | G11 - 5 | No | No | Flyer, related to #140 |
142 | Daniel Aldred | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | Name & birthplace |
143 | Nada que perder | J.smith | A7 - 4 | No | No | Unreleased band |
144 | Sidarth "Sid" Janwa | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN person, almost A1 |
145 | Skillground | NawlinWiki | G11 - 3, A7 - 4 | Yes | No | NN games website |
146 | DJ Hellraiser | NawlinWiki | G11 - 5 | No | No | Blatant band ad |
147 | Sir George Potter | NawlinWiki | A7 - 4[16] | No | No | Navy member |
148 | LiveZone | Metros232 | A7 - 5 | No | No | nn Video production company |
E | Dylan Nelson | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A1/A7 |
E | Ashton hanisch | NawlinWiki | - | No | No | A1/A7 |
149 | Angel Phantom | NawlinWiki | A7 - 4, G11 - 5 | No | No | NN webcomic |
150 | The Avenger (band) | Metros232 | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | NN band, no albums |
151 | LadyLeaMarie | NawlinWiki | A7 - 4, G11 - 5 | No | No | blogger, promo |
152 | William Vial | Edgar181 | A7 - 2[17] | No | No | settler |
153 | Mario de los Morales | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes[3] | No | nn writer/panhandler |
154 | Unofficialfan | Edgar181 | G11 - 4, A7 - 4 | No | No | nn forum/blog website |
155 | Israel Galan | Edgar181 | A7 - 5 | No | No | NN engineer |
156 | Roxstar crew famous | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | HS "crew" |
157, 158 | Livia Anthes | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes | No | NN student or something |
159 | Alina francisco | NawlinWiki[18] | A7 - 5 | No | No | student |
160 | Moe's implosion | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | Yes[3] | No | NN band, unsigned, unreleased |
161 | Audrey clinton | NawlinWiki | A7 - 5 | No | No | nn student |
Notes
edit- ^ a b c d e Currently protected from recreation
- ^ A7 currently doesn't apply to products, although it has in the past, so this one (a film) is a loophole. Still, no question that no notability is claimed.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k This deletion was of a recreation, but no recreations came after the 16th
- ^ Recreation, but apparently unrelated to the first deleted version
- ^ Weird. Spammy but somehow all that doesn't claim significance.
- ^ Lots of text, no paragraph breaks, probably text dump. At first, reads like NN educator, but there are very valid claims later on. Not undeleting, but will if contributor wants me to (and I've offered). Depending on the level of help the author contributes, this may end up kept, but the person gets 0 ghits, so I'm not hopeful.
- ^ Turns out the members are notable for a later project, but no claim in the deleted version. Currently redirects to Hella (band).
- ^ Written in Spanish, so I cut slack -- not sure if it's reasonable to expect admins to evaluate claims of significance in other languages, can't really evaluate the claim myself.
- ^ To someone who realizes it, handling data for the government including the DOD and DHS is not actually a claim of significance, there are lots of this kind of company, and of COURSE they work with the big government agencies.
- ^ Being tough here - deleter cited "website," and it is an online thing.
- ^ Claimed to be "prominent figure of the London social life" but it's obviously made-up.
- ^ Reposted 3 other times; G12 deletions twice
- ^ Recreation, may be on the same person but unclear.
- ^ Recreated with only {{hangon}}, deleted G6.
- ^ A very bad A7 (claims he invented the internet) but works as a G3 since it's so obviously false
- ^ Only possible claim.. he was supposedly born in 1845, which makes me think there might be more to this one. But nothing given.
- ^ An "original settler of New Brunswick," but that's all that's given as a claim, and apparently all that's known.
- ^ At this point, on the 87th time, I finally noticed it's "NawlinWiki" not "NailinWiki". Woah.