User talk:Dep. Garcia/Complaints Department/Archive

Complaints Department Archive for Resolved Complaints

Complaint against Dep. Garcia by Jesse Viviano (talk · contribs)

Resolved

 – At 19:57, May 26, 2007

Confirmed here

Complaint

Thank you for trying to get rid of nonsense, but Okane ga nai is verifiable. Please be more careful before you tag articles as nonsense. There was a remote chance that this was plausible, so {{Db-nonsense}} did not apply. It would apply to articles that stated that John Doe owns the world or other ridiculousness like that, or articles that contradict themselves too many times for anyone to understand them.

Examples

1. google:Okane ga nai
2. Your diff
3. Some evidence of existence

Third Parties

NO THIRD PARTY

Addition Comments by Jesse Viviano

If you run across something that looks like a hoax, please follow the procedure in Wikipedia:Don't create hoaxes#Dealing with hoaxes and take it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion. However, if the hoax is riduculous enough (e.g. it claims that John Doe owns the moon or contradicts basic scientific fact), it can be taken to speedy deletion with the {{Db-vandalism}} tag.

Jesse Viviano 18:45, 26 May 2007 (UTC)

Dep. Garcia's Reply

Sorry for what has happened but at first glance it seemed to be nonsense but now I have realised that the article was legitimate. Im very sorry and it wont happen again! Dep. Garcia ( Talk + | Help Desk | Complaints ) 18:50, 26 May 2007 (UTC)

Resolved?

Jesse Viviano are you happy with the action that was took after this complaint? YES

If YES, Dep. Garcia thanks you for making this complaint.

If NO, please talk to Dep. Garcia on his talk page or make another complaint

Complaint against Dep. Garcia by DRosenbach (talk · contribs)

Resolved

 – 19:40, June 17, 2007

Confirmed here

Complaint

Undue harrassment of User:Halaby.

Examples

1. You placed the following on his talk page:

...but your recent additions (such as Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans) are considered nonsense.

This was neither nonsense nor an attempt at vandalism. Seeing that you were the first individual to post on his talk page, and he hadn't even received a post from the welcoming committee yet, I feel that he might have taken your post as overly offensive, despite your opening civilities. And then you give him a warning!?! I didn't receive a warning until I had been on wikipedia for over a year, and even then I was worried as to what exactly such a thing would mean for my editing privilages. Your overexuberance, while perhaps committed without intent, can be overly chiding, and especially when placing a warning on someones page, you are representing Wikipedia and should attempt to be a bit more classy. I'd say that you bit this guy's head off.

Third Parties

I am a third party.

Addition Comments by DRosenbach ^{(Talk | Contribs)}

DRosenbach ^{(Talk | Contribs)} 18:26, 17 June 2007 (UTC)

Dep. Garcia's Reply

Hi, DRosenbach thank you for making a complaint, regarding Halaby I reverted what i thought was vandalism, but now it appears that i was wrong and that I have been to harsh on him. I will issue an apology to him immediately stating that i was in the wrong and that it will not happen again. Thanks again for bringing this matter to my attention! I do not mean to bite newcomers as we were all new once, but i was a bit heavy handed so too speak.

If you are happy with the response, please change the yes or no feature to represent what you feel, under the Resolved? section.

Regards

Dep. Garcia ( Talk + | Help Desk | Complaints ) 18:46, 17 June 2007 (UTC)

Resolved?

DRosenbach ^{(Talk | Contribs)} are you happy with the action that was took after this complaint? YES

If YES, Dep. Garcia thanks you for making this complaint.

If NO, please talk to Dep. Garcia on his talk page or make another complaint