Garywbush

I'm refering you to WP:RFAr for socketpuppetry. I suspect that you are related to user:alibadawi. Evidence is [here] I'll provide a link soon to the request soon. __earth 04:22, August 29, 2005 (UTC)

Your claim I engaged in socketpuppetry and is a violation of Wikipedia policy. I reserve the right to take appropriate action against you for slander (for instance I can complain to the Wikipedia administrators). I am not in any way related to user:alibadawi and I do not even who is he. But since, you, Earth are a Muslim, your religion typically encourages slander. As for that evidence, I did not say that so there are two options, one is someone else said it in my name (a case of forgery) or two, perhaps my account was hacked. Anyway, I have since changed my password just in any case. I suspect Earth hacked my account and then decided to slander me. Garywbush 23:11, 11 September 2005 (UTC)

Then how do you explain this? And please, no personal attack. And cmon, hacked? Perhaps you may want to learn a little about techical details and check upon a admin about your account? Maybe, check up on alibadawi too, just in case there is something suspicious. __earth 04:53, September 12, 2005 (UTC)

It is easy to explain as you Earth logged into my account as you knew my password was my username. I have changed it after I discovered my account was abused and now you will not be able to repeat your disgusting jokes. In fact, if we follow your logic it is so ridiculous! After all, why should I apologise for something I did not do? You answer that, Earth! I am waiting for your response. I am not making personal attacks but you began it as you being an Islamist dislike the term Kafirphobia to be included in the Kafir article. I am quite happy it has been included by Dbachmann finally so I won and you lost. Remember, on your blog you backed the Islamist insurgency on Southern Thailand. Don't pretend to talk about human rights as Muslims advocate Islamism (like your PULO friends) have no reason to demand seperatism to ensure supremeacy of Syariah and murder of murtads. They can live in peace with Buddhists, Christians, and Jews in Southern Thailand. Garywbush 01:36, 15 September 2005 (UTC)

Your password was your username? Heavens, you are naive.

And don't forget about you accusing me of hacking your account without proof. At the same time, I've never asked you to apologize. What you are talking about?

And no, I didn't start the personal attack. I merely presenting a case of socketpuppetry. It's you that start saying Muslims are liars and such. Surely you can check the history of the talk page of Kafir I haven't response to any of your insult save one, I called you religious nut. Moreoever, search on the net does show that you have a deep prejudice against Islam.

Nope, I don't support the insurgency. I said the Malaysian government NEED to aid the Thai authority. for heavens sake, do read properly.

And you see, you miss one point. I prefer a secular society with rights equality regardless of belief or skin etc. You on the other are in love your religion supremacy idea. As such, you are similar to those Islamist albeit from a different standing.

Regardless if I were an Islamist or your supremacist belief, this is all irrelevent to you case. You still haven't provide a clear defense. Please, just provide a clear and relevent defense instead of name calling. __earth 18:08, 15 September 2005 (UTC)

Garywbush, your actions against Earth have been discourteous to say the least; his suspicions about sockpuppetry are well founded and I know he has been careful in checking his evidence and correct wikipedia procedure before making his claims. If you are infact not a sockpuppet, then he I'm sure will be the first to aplogise, but at the moment the evidence suggests that you are. At the moment, you have offered no defence for your actions, only completed personal attacks and responded with threats. Robdurbar 08:18, 12 September 2005 (UTC)

Why are you suddenly so "pro-Earth"? Are you his stooge? Or his socketpuppet? Why should he apologise when he dislikes me as I am one of his rivals in blogosphere? I have exposed his hypocrisy there and here but he still does not want to apologise to me for hacking me account. ONLY HE COULD HAVE DONE IT AS HE KEPT ON CALLING ME A SOCKETPUPPET.

Also, you are plain wrong. There is no evidence suggesting I am a socketpuppet and I warn you to stop this libel. I ALREADY clearly said what was posted using my account was not by me but by a third party illegally using my account (who I auspect to be Earth). Garywbush 01:36, 15 September 2005 (UTC)

Actually, looking into this further, I am so convicned that I will put the 'suspected sockpuppet tag' on your user page; clearly, you can remove this if you wish, but I feel that the evidence warrents it. Robdurbar 10:19, 12 September 2005 (UTC)

You must be a Muslim otherwise you cannot say you are 'so convinced' when my position is someone (who I suspect to be Earth) hacked my account as he knew my password then was same as my username. Also, I have existed longer on Wikipedia than User:Alibadawi who is a new comer so I definitely cannot be related to him.

Also, you have no rights to libel me by placing the socketpuppet tag on my User page, which I have removed. Personal attacks are already bad but libel is totally against Wikipedia or any ISP AUP. Garywbush 01:36, 15 September 2005 (UTC)

You are talking about personal attacks and libel but you yourself are doing it.

About Islamist (of which you are name calling me), my tongue-in-the-cheek blog entry (of which you claim to be Islamist in nature), you being my rival in the blogosphere (I did't even know you before I spot several suspicious socket puppets while you don't even own a blog) and, Robdurbar is a Muslim just because he too believes you're committing socketpuppetry (of which illogical), they're all are irrelevent to your defense.

Again, how do you explain this. If I had hacked into your account, why didn't you tell an admin earlier before I found out about your edit on user:alibadawi? In fact, your accusation of me hacking into your account is without proof.

Lastly, you existing longer than Alibadawi doesn't explain a thing. Any user with malicious intent or otherwise could easily make a new account and engage in sockpuppetry, of which, the evidence suggests. __earth 04:09, 15 September 2005 (UTC)

 'Also, I have existed longer on Wikipedia than User:Alibadawi who is a new comer so I definitely cannot be related to 
  him.'

Actually, that is a good point. But then, looking at User:Alibadawi's contributions, I see his first on Wikipedia is on a talk page, a typical sign of sockpuppetry, so it is possible that he is your sockpuppet, and not the other way round. Again, i do not mean to libel and if I am proved wrong, I will be more than happy to apologise Robdurbar 09:57, 15 September 2005 (UTC)

Very clever, but your actions still don't convivnce that you are not a sockpuppet. In 24 hours time I will put a Request for comment on this, unless you can provide a defence for yourself. If you maintain that the evidence can be expalined by Earth hacking into your account, then I suggest we go to RfC anyway as this to is a serious allegation that should be followed up Robdurbar 09:10, 16 September 2005 (UTC)

Request for Comment

Please be aware that I have made a request for comment about your user conduct. Should you wish to defend yourself, please go to Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Garywbush Robdurbar