Ihendley

Muslim Students' Association

Hi, I saw your comment on Talk:Muslim Students' Association.

• You said that there is "no single group called the 'Muslim Students Association'," but there is, and their website is www.msa-natl.org.
  • No, this is "Muslim Students Association National", not "Muslim Students Association". It is misleading to call the former the latter.
• You said that "If the article is trying to describe Muslim Students Association National, then the title should reflect that." The current title of the page is what MSA officially calls itself.
  • See above.
• You said that "In this case it would not be relevent to mention actions of individual Muslim student groups that may or may not be affiliated with MSA National." I agree with that, but the individual Muslim student groups mentioned in the article are affiliated with MSA.
  • Please cite your source. I am not sure a full list of individual college MSA's that are affiliated with MSA National exists. MSA National has compiled a list of websites for Muslims Students' Associations around the country as a resource, but these MSA's are not necessarily affiliated.
• You said that "As of now, the article inaccurately attributes the actions of various Muslim student groups in the United States to 'The MSA'." This article is sourced. If you have sources that dispute the accuracy of the article, please provide them.
  • Previous edits have already addressed this.
• You said that the "article is also clearly biased." Please provide specifics of POV.
  • I said this because the version of the article I was discussing launched into commentary on MSA National and individual MSA's before providing even a basic overview of the purpose, structure, history, major projects, etc. of MSA National.
• You suggested deleting the article... -> to nominate an article for deletion, see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion which describes the deletion process. Thanks for your time, DRK 20:06, 30 September 2006 (UTC)
  • Thank you. Actually now I think the current version of the article should be retitled "Muslim Students Association National" and it should be expanded. --Imran 20:46, 9 October 2006 (UTC)