LaKr
Joined 30 September 2009
Latest comment: 14 years ago by WhatamIdoing in topic Hi
|
Hi
edit- Hi WLU, thank you for the welcome message. I have noticed you have deleted and edited most of my contribution on Dr Erika Schwartz. Additionally I noticed you have misspelled her name and referred to her as Schwartz or Shwartz, depending on your spelling of choice and not Dr. I also noticed you removed the articles I posted from the Medical Clinics of North America which were very significant and a highly regarded part of conventional medicine. Why would you do this? And then keep smaller, older articles? Why are you discrediting Dr Erika Schwartz by misspelling her name and editing my writing in incomplete sentences and incorrect English grammar. LaKr (talk) 15:32, 6 October 2009 (UTC)
- Notability, puffery, soapboxing, lack of reliable sources, coatracking and simple typing errors. I retained the information that was sourced, that didn't wax eloquent on unrelated topics, and didn't describe results with bioidentical hormones as "amazing". I also didn't remove the "Medical Clinics" paper, but I did format it using a {{cite journal}} template. Do you know or have any link to either the account LisaW24, or that account's former name, DrErikaTS? — Preceding unsigned comment added by WLU (talk • contribs) 18:43, 6 October 2009
- Hi WLU, thank you for the welcome message. I have noticed you have deleted and edited most of my contribution on Dr Erika Schwartz. Additionally I noticed you have misspelled her name and referred to her as Schwartz or Shwartz, depending on your spelling of choice and not Dr. I also noticed you removed the articles I posted from the Medical Clinics of North America which were very significant and a highly regarded part of conventional medicine. Why would you do this? And then keep smaller, older articles? Why are you discrediting Dr Erika Schwartz by misspelling her name and editing my writing in incomplete sentences and incorrect English grammar. LaKr (talk) 15:32, 6 October 2009 (UTC)
- LaKr, the relevant standard is WP:CREDENTIAL. Nobody is normally referred to as "Dr" or "Prof" or anything like that, although there are a few exceptions for people more widely known under a "stage name". Even Oprah and Dr Laura are referred to by their last names, sans title. WhatamIdoing (talk) 21:17, 6 October 2009 (UTC)