Ubtrbelizeit68

Brandi Carlile

Thanks for letting me know that the source cited was not one you think credible. I have asked for additional input on the Wikipedia talk:WikiProject LGBT studies page. Feel free to contribute to the discussion there. I think I will bring this up on her article's talkpage as well to gather even more input. ZueJay (talk) 01:37, 23 May 2007 (UTC)

Indeed. I'm not sure what the "FA" comment is about, but I agree that a quality article is important. I also agree with Satyr that I could care less whether she is or isn't...but ultimately, tracking this down and finding truth with a credible source is a goal of the wikiproject, especially when asked by another editor to help out in this goal. I honestly figured the chosen article had already been put through the credibility determination by another editor as it is used in the List of gay, lesbian or bisexual people. Your concerns are justified, warranted, I just wished you had approached with a little more tact. If you'll notice, the information has not been reintroduced to the article at this juncture, and personally, until we come to a consensus, I don't think it should be reintroduced. And if a Wikipedia article seems thin to you, I would encourage you to keep adding more referenced info to it. That Medleyville Q&A has some great information about her musically-formative years. ZueJay (talk) 19:08, 24 May 2007 (UTC)