User talk:Vegan416/DiscussionPage

Welcome to the Discussion Page. This page is intended to enable lengthy and deep discussions about matters of actual content and substance. Not for administrative stuff, warnings, complaints, etc. So leave those on my main Talk page and not here.

On this page, we can discuss issues related to Wikipedia articles and policies at length without it being considered bludgeoning (as per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Don%27t_bludgeon_the_process the owner of a use talk page can allow people to bludgeon on his page).

Other rules of Wikipedia discussions still apply on this page, but this may change later based on experience and better knowledge of policies.

Response to Nishidani

Response to this Talk:Zionism#Use of term 'colonization' in opening sentence / definition

Nishidani, I never said that the Arabs should be expelled. First of all, I didn't say that I subscribe to the idea the Zionism is decolonization. In fact I don't subscribe to it, because I am not a woke who views the entire world through the lens of colonization/decolonization. I just said that this is one of the many things that some Zionists said about Zionism. And I said it partly in a tongue in cheek manner, because someone else had actually said it in the talk page of Zionism today. Second, even among those Zionists who subscribe to this idea, "decolonization" doesn't necessarily mean expulsion of anyone. It could mean just liberating a place (or part of it) from the political rule of others. But the fact that you think that the meaning of "decolonization" is necessarily "expelling" is interesting. It means that either you are against decolonization in general or in favor (or indifferent) to the expulsion of people. Which of these options is true? Vegan416 (talk) 21:00, 3 July 2024 (UTC)

I'm sorry but this is terrible argumentation.

Also please try to be concise and to the point on talk pages, avoiding statements like the one you described as: "I just said that this is one of the many things that some Zionists said about Zionism. And I said it partly in a tongue in cheek manner."

- IOHANNVSVERVS (talk) 21:19, 3 July 2024 (UTC)

What is terrible argumentation? I just stated the fact that Nishidani's claim that I think the Arabs should be expelled is false, because I don't think so. It is obvious that I know what are my opinions better than anyone else... Vegan416 (talk) 05:12, 4 July 2024 (UTC)