Valabh Committee

The Valabh Committee, named after its Chair Arthur Valabh, was a New Zealand government appointed committee tasked with reviewing various aspects of the income tax system in the late 1980s and early 1990s.

Although originally convened to review proposals for a capital gains tax, the Committee ended up making a number of recommendations for fundamental reform of the scheme and structure of the New Zealand tax legislation, most of which ^[1] were implemented.

The committee had a lasting impact on the direction of tax reform, including the style and drafting of the income tax legislation, as well as numerous specific recommendations for the tax treatment of, for example, depreciation and partnerships.

Committee members

The formal name of the Valabh Committee was the “Consultative Committee on the Taxation of Income from Capital”.^[2] The Committee comprised:

Arthur Valabh, OBE (chair)
Dr Robin Congreve
Lindsay McKay
Rob McLeod
Tim Robinson

It was supported by a secretary (Greg Cole) as well as by officials from both the Inland Revenue Department and the Treasury.

Background

The 1980s were a period of considerable economic and tax reform in New Zealand. New Zealand had never had a formal capital gains tax system (unlike virtually every other OECD nation. The government was considering implementing a capital gains tax and issued a consultative document ^[2] as part of the (then) process of tax reform.^[3]

The Committee appointed to review submissions, in response to the Consultative Document, instead reported to government that it did not consider the state of the tax system at that time sufficiently robust enough to support additional reform of this nature. The government accepted this recommendation and re-tasked the committee to advise it on the structural reforms required.

Key proposals

The Committee subsequently published 5 discussion papers:^[3]

The Core Provisions of the Income Tax Act 1976 (Core Provisions Paper) ^[4]
The Taxation of Distributions from Companies (Company Distribution Paper)
Tax Accounting Issues
Key Reforms to the Scheme of Tax Legislation (Key Reforms Paper) ^[5]
Operational Aspects of the Accrual Rules

In addition the Committee separately reported to government on the reform of the tax depreciation rules.^[6]

Core provisions and scheme

The thrust of the Core Provisions and Key Reforms Papers was to ensure that the income tax legislation was appropriately structured and ordered to facilitate the understanding of the rules as well as to allow for further reform to be implemented effectively.

This work lead directly to the Working Party on the Reorganisation of the Income Tax Act 1976 and the complete rewrite of the legislation.^[7]^[8]

Company taxation and dividends

The proposals made in the Company Distribution Paper led to a revised definition of what constituted a dividend under New Zealand tax law as well as the introduction of a small company taxation regime (“qualifying company” regime).^[9]

Depreciation

The committee's recommendations resulted in a new tax depreciation regime introduced in 1993.^[9]

Interest deductibility

The government accepted the committee's recommendation for a significantly more liberal regime for the deduction of interest for tax purposes.^[10]

Partnerships

Recommendations for the reform of the tax treatment of partnerships was finally implemented by government in 2007 ^[11]^[12]

References

^ "Appendix 10 Recommendations of the final report of the consultative committee on the taxation of income from capital (Valabh Committee)". Archived from the original on 2006-10-01. Retrieved 2024-01-14.
^ ^a ^b D Caygill, Consultative Document on the Taxation of Income From Capital, Wellington, Government Printer, 1989
^ ^a ^b "Appendix 9 List of reports on the tax system". Archived from the original on 2006-10-01. Retrieved 2024-01-14.
^ The Valabh Committee, Discussion Paper on the Core Provisions of the Income Tax Act 1976, Wellington, Government Printer, September 1990
^ The Valabh Committee, Key Reforms to the Scheme of Tax Legislation, Wellington, Government Printer, October 1991
^ Valabh Committee letter to Hon Ruth Richardson and Hon Wyatt Creech dated 14 November 1991
^ "CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION - Background". Archived from the original on 2008-10-14.
^ "Hansard record".
^ ^a ^b "IRD information bulletin" (PDF).
^ "Chapter 3 - Need for Clarification of the Present Law". taxpolicy.ird.govt.nz. Archived from the original on 2002-03-07.
^ "IRD Commentary at page 8" (PDF).
^ "Tax change welcome, but long overdue | Scoop News". www.scoop.co.nz.

[1] "Appendix 10 Recommendations of the final report of the consultative committee on the taxation of income from capital (Valabh Committee)". Archived from the original on 2006-10-01. Retrieved 2024-01-14.

[auto1-2] D Caygill, Consultative Document on the Taxation of Income From Capital, Wellington, Government Printer, 1989

[auto-3] "Appendix 9 List of reports on the tax system". Archived from the original on 2006-10-01. Retrieved 2024-01-14.

[4] The Valabh Committee, Discussion Paper on the Core Provisions of the Income Tax Act 1976, Wellington, Government Printer, September 1990

[5] The Valabh Committee, Key Reforms to the Scheme of Tax Legislation, Wellington, Government Printer, October 1991

[6] Valabh Committee letter to Hon Ruth Richardson and Hon Wyatt Creech dated 14 November 1991

[7] "CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION - Background". Archived from the original on 2008-10-14.

[8] "Hansard record".

[auto2-9] "IRD information bulletin" (PDF).

[10] "Chapter 3 - Need for Clarification of the Present Law". taxpolicy.ird.govt.nz. Archived from the original on 2002-03-07.

[11] "IRD Commentary at page 8" (PDF).

[12] "Tax change welcome, but long overdue | Scoop News". www.scoop.co.nz.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]