Wikipedia

Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Act 2011

The Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Act 2011 is an Act of Parliament passed in New Zealand in 2011. The law is a response to the Supreme Court's ruling in Hamed & Ors v. R,[1] and is intended to legalise surveillance ruled unlawful by the courts.

Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Act 2011
New Zealand Parliament
Royal assent17 October 2011
Commenced18 October 2011
Legislative history
Introduced byChris Finlayson
Passed6 October 2011
Status: Current legislation

Background

edit

On 2 September 2011 the Supreme Court of New Zealand issued its ruling in the case of Hamed & Ors v. R, ruling that some evidence obtained by video surveillance of suspects in the 2007 New Zealand anti-terror raids was gathered unlawfully and was inadmissible. Following the ruling, the Crown dropped charges against thirteen of the seventeen remaining suspects.[2] On 19 September the New Zealand government announced that it had been advised that the decision meant that almost all covert video surveillance by police was unlawful and that it intended to legislate to reverse the decision.[3]

The following week the government began to negotiate with other parties in an effort to gain backing for the bill. During the negotiation process a draft copy of the bill[4] was leaked by the Labour Party via its blog Red Alert.[5]

The proposed bill was criticised by lawyers,[6][7] civil libertarians, and the media,[8] and by the Mana,[9] Māori[10] and Green[11] parties. The Labour[12] and ACT[13] parties agreed to support the bill only to select committee. This was sufficient for the bill to be introduced. An attempt by the Labour Party to compromise by using clauses from the Search and Surveillance Bill was rejected by the government as "legislative field surgery".[14]

Legislative history

edit

The bill was introduced to the House under urgency on 27 September 2011.[15] As introduced, the bill was retrospective, and declared video surveillance lawful no matter when it had occurred. This was intended to apply to "current prosecutions before the courts, convictions entered as the result of past prosecutions, and existing investigations involving the gathering of evidence for potential future prosecutions".[16] The sole exception was the Hamed case.[16] The bill would have effect for 12 months, allowing Parliament time to progress the Search and Surveillance Act.[16]

The bill passed its first reading 106-15 and was sent to the Justice and Electoral Select Committee for an abbreviated select committee process.[17][18] The bill was heavily criticised by submitters, with the Criminal Bar Association calling it "legal magic dust", and constitutional lawyer Andrew Geddis an "overreaction".[19] The New Zealand Human Rights Commission expressed concerns that it would damage New Zealand's international image,[20] while former Prime Minister and architect of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 Geoffrey Palmer labelled it "oppressive".[21]

The bill was reported back on 3 October 2011,[15] and substantially amended.[22][23] The retrospective aspect of the bill was removed. Past surveillance would not be made lawful, but convictions obtained using evidence from such surveillance would not be able to be challenged.[23]

The bill passed through its remaining stages under urgency on 6 October,[15] passing its third reading 105–14, with the Greens, Māori Party, and Mana opposing.[24] It was granted the Royal Assent on 17 October,[15] and became law the following day.[25]

The effect of the Act was limited to covert video surveillance connected to searches conducted within six months of it becoming law.[26]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ Hamed & Ors v. R (2011) NZSC 101
  2. ^ Steward, Ian; Watkins, Tracy (6 September 2011). "Gun charges against Urewera accused dropped". Fairfax New Zealand. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  3. ^ Claire Trevett (19 September 2011). "Urgent new law after Urewera case". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  4. ^ "Letter from Chris Finlayson to party leaders" (PDF). 21 September 2011. Retrieved 6 October 2011.
  5. ^ Charles Chauvel (23 September 2011). "Supreme Court Update: Labour's response to Government Bill". New Zealand Labour Party. Retrieved 6 October 2011.
  6. ^ "Video Surveillance Bill: Police incompetent or contemptuous?". scoop.co.nz. 2011. Retrieved 5 October 2011.
  7. ^ "NZLS opposes proposed surveillance law change". scoop.co.nz. 2011. Retrieved 5 October 2011. The New Zealand Law Society (NZLS) opposes enactment of the bill which would retrospectively amend the law relating to video camera surveillance.
  8. ^ "Editorial: No grounds for knee-jerk law change". The New Zealand Herald. 21 September 2011. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  9. ^ "Mana Outraged at Retrospective Legislation". Scoop. 20 September 2011. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  10. ^ "Flavell condemns National's actions in making the unlawful". Scoop. 20 September 2011. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  11. ^ "Green Party won't support Video Surveillance Bill". Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand. 22 September 2011. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  12. ^ "Labour unhappy with surveillancebill". TVNZ. 20 September 2011. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  13. ^ Derek Cheng (21 September 2011). "Govt has the numbers to push through surveillance bill". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  14. ^ Derek Cheng (28 September 2011). "Labour's plan on secret police cameras gets boot – twice". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  15. ^ a b c d "Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Bill". Parliament of New Zealand. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  16. ^ a b c "Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Bill: 333-1" (PDF). Parliament of New Zealand. Retrieved 6 October 2011.
  17. ^ "Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Bill – First Reading". Parliament of New Zealand. 27 September 2011. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  18. ^ "Media statement – Justice and Electoral Committee: Public hearing of evidence on the Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Bill". Parliament of New Zealand. 28 September 2011. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  19. ^ Andrea Vance (28 September 2011). "Secret filming fix 'legal magic dust'". Dominion-Post. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  20. ^ Danya Levy (29 September 2011). "Concerns 'fixit' law could damage NZ's image". Stuff. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  21. ^ Derek Cheng (29 September 2011). "Ex PM: 'Fix it' bill oppressive". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 3 October 2011.
  22. ^ "Report of the Justice and Electoral Committee on the Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Bill" (PDF). Parliament of New Zealand. 3 October 2011. Retrieved 6 October 2011.
  23. ^ a b Derek Cheng (5 October 2011). "Govt waters down hidden camera bill". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 6 October 2011.
  24. ^ "Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Bill – Third Reading". Parliament of New Zealand. 6 October 2011. Retrieved 18 October 2011.
  25. ^ Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Act 2011, Section 2.
  26. ^ Video Camera Surveillance (Temporary Measures) Act 2011, Section 5.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Video_Camera_Surveillance_(Temporary_Measures)_Act_2011&oldid=1221237902"