Wikipedia:Featured article review/Boogeyman 2/archive1
Boogeyman 2 (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)
| Toolbox |
|---|
I am not sure this article meets the WP:FACRITERIA as raised by multiple users in the talk page (thread 1; thread 2; FAC, notice given).
Regarding the following specific criteria:
- well-written: the prose is informative but somewhat unpolished in some places, and could be rewritten to be more engaging
- comprehensive: Production, release, and sequel may benefit from expansion
- well-researched: the article would benefit from additional sources and is missing citations, for instance, no citation for the Cast and for "Evolution of the killer's mask, dubbed Boogie Mask". NB: I wasn't sure if Cast needs citations in general but I have seen that many good articles have it, e.g. The Thing (1982 film)#Cast.
- media: lacks significant use of images and other media, where appropriate, as required for FA.
N.B.: the talk page has not addressed these changes (the previous thread is also from 7 years ago) so I suspect the original authors may be inactive. Caleb Stanford (talk) 23:08, 16 November 2024 (UTC)