| Toolbox |
|---|
 | This peer review discussion has been closed. |
I've listed this article for peer review because the article is at GA right now and is in the process of FAC right now [1]. Some editors recommended a peer review for the article. Any advice is welcome!
Thanks a lot, DarklyShadows (talk) 01:46, 6 July 2020 (UTC)
Lead
- Finneas full name does not need to be mentioned here, since you explain the difference between his real and stage names in the body
- On the second mention, do not reintroduce him as her brother
- "It was described as a" → "It is a" since this is the lead after all
- "It has been certified by several" → "It has received several"
Background and release
- Mention that Finneas reported she was working on new music
- Instead of "in December 2019", write "the following month" since you used a month already in that sentence by putting November
- Split the Beats by Dre and cover art statements into two separate sentences, plus swap the order of the Golden Gate Bridge description and mentioning of who made the cover
- The word "back" is unnecessary, as September 2018 is that sentence's only date
Composition and lyrics
- "is moderately fast at 120 beats per minute (BPM)." → "has a moderately fast tempo of 120 beats per minute (BPM)."
- "minimalist production that consists of" → "minimalist production, consisting of"
- "Eilish feels about fame. Though" → "Eilish feels about fame; though"
- "the song is about how" → "the song discusses how"
- "over and over again;" → "over and over again,"
Reception
- "tribute to her brother, Finneas"." → "tribute" from Eilish to Finneas."
- "displayed the message" → "displays the message"
- "She furthermetioned that" → "She further mentioned that"
- "Brent Furdyk writing for" → "Brent Furdyk, writing for"
- "However, not all reviews were positive. Writing for" → "In a mixed review for" as the previous sentence is not needed since that is not a new paragraph
- "second top ten hit" → "second top 10 hit"
- "It has been awarded several" → "The song has been awarded several"
Music video
- Incorrect speech marks are used to open the first quote here
- "The two's stares are blank," → "The stares of the two are blank,"
- "a dreamscape she imagined." → "a dreamscape that she imagined."
- Add a new para for the reception
- Fix the punctuation that is inside quotes at points here, not counting full sentences of course
- Nylon → Nylon
Live performances and other usages
- Retitle to Live performances and other usage
- Mention that the Steve Jobs performance was that same month
- "on her setlist" → "included on her setlist"
- "In April that year, Eilish and Finneas" → "In April of that year, the two"
- "Cooper played with" → "Cooper played alongside"
- "saying Cooper and his band slowly" → "saying they slowly"
- "but he felt drawn to the track" → "but felt drawn to the track"
I remembered passing this for GA a few months ago, but thought I would take on the peer review since it has been some time since then. Overall, the article is mostly fine but I pointed out some issues that stood out to me; did not go in as much detail as I would have for reviewing a FA candidate, but good luck with that nomination in the future! --K. Peake 07:32, 6 August 2020 (UTC)