This peer review discussion has been closed.
Well, I was a bit rash and got a bit jumpy when I nominated History of the Han Dynasty as a FAC. Since June, I've been compiling a huge mountain of scholarly notes for it, and four other branch articles (society and culture, economy, government, science and technology) which I will create for the Chinese Han Dynasty. I put the finishing touches on the article in my private sandbox this week, created the actual wiki article, then submitted it as a FAC. Lo and behold, it's newness as an article apparently violates the FAC criteria for stability, since it has not had time for potential edit warring or for other Wiki editors to provide their input. I was wondering if you guys could take a look, so that even if it fails the FAC this time around, it will have been properly peer-reviewed.
