| Toolbox |
|---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I am planning to submit it as a Featured Article candidate and would like to get suggestions for getting it to meet the criteria for Featured Articles.
Thanks, Pseudo-Richard (talk) 07:58, 14 June 2012 (UTC)
Comments
- "...of the most anti-Semitic films ..." why the capital S and hyphen? Opening sentence used "antisemitic", be internally consistent.
- I would link Terra Filmkunst because it's not clear to non-experts that this is a company, not an individual.
- Consider linking Reichsmark.
- "Susan Tegel[who?]" needs to be resolved, I'm guessing it's a case of "who is she and why should her opinion be important?"
- Consider linking Diet (assembly).
- "As his carriage gets into an accident" not particularly elegant. "As his carriage is involved in an accident" perhaps?
- "Duke's bodyguard, opera and ballet as well" the Duke's opera? the Duke's ballet?
- "but also causing " -> "but causes"
- "of Duke Karl Alexander of Württemberg in Stuttgart. As a financial advisor for Duke Karl Alexander, Duke of Württemberg, he " repetitive and overlinked.
- "Court Jew" or "court Jew", and link only the first instance.
- "which he refused to do" just "which he refused" is sufficient.
- "the Nazi takeover" of where?
- "Goebbels was insisting in" Goebbels insisted in.
- Link pogrom.
- "against the Jews. [21][22] " remove the space before the refs.
- No link for Central Rio?
- "the lead role of Joseph Süß Oppenheimer included the title role " lead role... title role...
- René Deltgen has a diacritic.
- Why are Final solution and Jewish question in italics?
- If possible, try to avoid squashing text between images.
- Several short paragraphs, try merging them for a more appealing appearance and flow.
- "The film is available for sale on VHS from Facets" presumably not everywhere though.
- Whitespace before the Analysis section.
- "List of German films 1933-1945" needs an en-dash in that year range.
- Avoid SHOUTING in the ref titles.
- If you use a source more than twice, make it a general reference and then you can just cite the author name and page number rather than repeat the title, ISBN etc etc each and every time.
- Ref 111 has no access date, publisher etc.
- New York Times is The New York Times. Also that ref has different date format.
- Ref 115 is Spiegelonline but has no link, and has different format date from other refs.