Wikipedia:Peer review/List of number-one Christian singles of 2004 (U.S.)/archive1
| Toolbox |
|---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I want to see the opinion of the community in regards to what needs to be improved in this list before a FL review. I believe the only section needing attention is the lede.
Thanks, Toa Nidhiki05 00:09, 18 October 2011 (UTC)
Doing... Brianboulton (talk) 18:02, 30 October 2011 (UTC)
Preliminary note: The title of the article at peer review needs to change to the actual title, which was moved to "List of number-one Christian singles of 2004 (U.S.)" on 27 October. Brianboulton (talk) 18:08, 30 October 2011 (UTC)
A few more comments
- What is a "Christian single" – or, more specifically, what are the criteria that determine whether a song is eligible for this list?
- According to Billboard, the chart is all-format and is airplay-based. Further articles note that it is calculated from radio airplay audience impressions from about 150 Christian stations.
- What does "audience impression" mean, and how is this measurement determined?
- 'Audience impression' means the chart is judged based on the approximate number of audience plays a song received over the weekend.
- Rather than the half-apologetic sentence "Although "You Are My King (Amazing Love)" began its stint at No. 1 in 2003, it is included here for full statistical benefit" I would simply say; ""You Are My King (Amazing Love)" was also No. 1 for x weeks in 2003"
- Alright, I will correct this.
- "Two other singles, "More" by Matthew West and "Who Am I" by Casting Crowns, spent six weeks atop the chart." "Here with Me", as a song title, needs to be in quotes. Not sure about "other"; there is no unifying relationship between these two songs and "Here with Me". Is there any special significance about a run of six weeks, as against, say, five? Also, "atop", though not incorrect, sounds slightly quaint.
- I tried to note the longest-running song of the year as well as the second longest. I evidently did not do a good job. :P
- The information in the chart seems somewhat limited (date, title, artist). Using the link, I discovered that the songwriters of "Word of God Speak" are Bart Millard and Pete Kipely. Why not credit the writers of each song?
- Good idea, I'll see if I can implement that. However, I did not find the credit you list anywhere on Billboard.
- Images: Possible problems:-
- File:Bart Millard and Robin Shaffer in concert.JPG: The image description gives the author as User:WordyGirl90, but the file was uploaded, and the licence selected, by JamieS93 without apparent reference to the author.
- File:Matt West concert.jpg: The image source appears to be another Wikipedia page, and again the supposed author is not the uploader.
