Wikipedia:WikiProject California/Carmel cleanup task force
This page in a nutshell: Centralized venue for coordinating cleanup of Carmel and related walled gardens |
Background reading (site-wide community discussions)
editMembers
editArticles written by Greg Henderson
editHenderson family
editPeople
editHighly recommended to have source assessment table ready before sending Henderson family members to AfD, see talk. |
- Emile Kellogg Boisot - a non-notable banker (bankers do not have inherent notability). WP:MILL. Sourcing is extremely weak: 1) primary source written by the bank; 2) Obit in NYT (obviously family submitted not a comprehensive, independent obit); 3) Biography in the Illinois Enc. of Biography (not a NATIONAL one, per BASIC or ANYBIO); 4) Who's Who in Chicago (user-submitted content); 5) short obit in a banking trade journal; 6) same as #3; 7) wedding announcement; 8) obit in LATimes (same as #2) family submitted. I think this should be AfD'd unless someone can find a viable redirect.
- Jean-Baptiste Boisot
- Byington Ford
- Tirey L. Ford
- Alexander D. Henderson Jr.
- Girard B. Henderson
- David H. McConnell
Previously kept at AfD
edit- Ellwood Walter (businessman) (per 2020 AfD)
- Joseph Henderson (pilot) (per 2020 AfD) — AfD's once and kept. All the Keep voters except two are ARS members. ARS was canvassed for several AfD's around this time.
- Lewis Francis Byington (per 2021 AfD)
Homes and businesses
editCarmel
editThis version of the Carmel buildings navbox template contains many (possibly most) of the articles created by Henderson. Several have since been redirected.
Buildings and homes
edit- Harrison Memorial Library – Resolved
- AfD or redirect Driftwood Cottage, a non-notable house on Carmel Point. — Redirected twice, un-redirected twiceUnresolved
- Now being discussed Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Driftwood_Cottage courtesy pings to @Somebodyidkfkdt, Netherzone, and GreenC: Graywalls (talk) 03:55, 6 September 2024 (UTC)
People
edit
Carmel Valley
editPeople
edit- AfD candidate Guy O. Koepp Talk:Guy_O._Koepp#c-Netherzone-20240818202700-Notability_is_questionable — Resolved by redirecting
Places and buildings
edit- Carmel Valley Airfield - see article talk page. Possible redirect targets: List of defunct airports in the United States or Carmel Valley, California
Pilot boats and captains
editNote: Melcous has opened a discussion at Template talk:List of sea captains and pilots#NE US centric template regarding an issue with the title of that template.
- Joseph Henderson (pilot) - AfD's once and kept. All the Keep voters except two are ARS members. ARS was canvassed for several AfD's around this time.
- James D. M. Beebe - questionable notability, AfD closed as no consensus
- Augustus Van Pelt - questionable notability
- Frank P. Van Pelt - questionable notability
- Abel F. Hayden - questionable notability
- Bruce Boutlier McLean - questionable notability
- James H. Reid - questionable notability, potential claim to notability made around the yacht America
- John C. Fawcett - questionable notability
- Andrew J. Comstock - claim to notability re America's Cup
- Pilots' Monument
- Franklin Osgood - notable as winner of America's cup and in Hall of Fame
- Thomas Freeborn - potential claim to notability re Pilots' Monument but could be redirected to that article
- Richard Brown - notable - won the America's Cup