Wikipedia

Wikipedia:WikiProject External links/Webcitebot2

< Wikipedia:WikiProject External links
Dead links
Graph of articles with dead external links over time.

The WebCiteBOT Replacement Task Force is a sub-group of Wikipedia:WikiProject External links. It is a coordinated effort to address the issue of citation templates having dead external links. The number of articles with dead tagged links went from under 10,000 to over 105,000 in 2010.

Overview

edit

Wikipedia relies on verifiable information from reliable sources to ensure that the information it carries is accurate and presented from a neutral point of view. These are very basic needs of the project. Wikipedia uses external links to reliable information to accomplish this task. Unfortunately, the Internet is not stable and links come and go. So this issue needs to be addressed if Wikipedia is to have a succesful future.

WebCiteBOT was an incredible resource that monitored the external link feed of the IRC channel #wikipedia-en-spam. It searched for these links in citation templates and then submitted them to WebCitation.org and updated the templates. Unfortunately the bot died in November 2009 and dead links have been increasing ever since. (see graph above)

Goals

edit

This is yet to be defined. At a minimum, some type of tool should be developed to assist archiving external links in citation templates.

  1. The bot or tool should be operated by at least 2 users so that when an operator leaves, we don't have this issue again.
  2. A goal of a functional equivalent of WebCiteBOT is probably worthwhile. This means an automated bot that monitors the external link feed of the IRC channel #wikipedia-en-spam and submits them to WebCitation.org and updates citation templates.
  3. Another related issue that was discussed over the last year was having the Wikimedia Foundation take over the role of WebCitation.org (for citation links) or more formally collaborate with / support webcitation.org to guarantee sustainability of the service.

Previous attempts

edit

There have been several Wikipedians that have brought this issue before the greater Wikipedian community in order to have this problem addressed. A cash reward has even been offered by one user in order to get this issue fixed. Below is a list of the attempts in chronological order.

Bots possibly in development

edit

A number of our software engineers have been working on the WebCiteBOT issue and may possibly have bots in the development stage. The current status of most of these bots is unknown at this time.

Bot Operator Status Source code Purpose
DASHBot 11 (maybe) Tim1357 Monitoring Process running Unknown External link archiving/tagging
H3llBot (maybe) H3llkn0wz Inactive No, relies on outdated framework External link archiving/tagging
NNBot II (maybe) nn123645 Unknown Source code (zip) (PHP) unrelated BRFA External link archiving
Unknown Δ script running Unknown External link archiving
edit

Several bots have been developed over the years that have dealt with external link issues. Several of these are no longer operating, but they may provide examples that software engineers can use to help develop a new bot. Please note that some/most of the source code below is not free to use. Therefore, it can only be examined to give ideas for possible solutions to different tasks.

Bot Operator Status Source code Purpose
MerlLinkBot Merlissimo     -Inactive Unknown (Java) BRFA Repairing dead weblinks
DASHBot 11 Tim1357     -Inactive Unknown (Python) BRFA Dead link archiving
DASHBot WebCite Tim1357     -Inactive Unknown (Python) Wikipedia:Bots/Requests for approval/DASHBot WebCite Check newly added URLs, archive URL at WebCite and add archive link to article
DeadLinkBOT ThaddeusB     -Inactive Source code (Perl) BRFA Update specific dead links
EchoBot Wikihermit     -Inactive Unknown (Pywikipedia) BRFA Finds and reports dead links
H3llBot H3llkn0wz     -Inactive Not available (C# .NET) BRFA Dead link archiving
JabbaTheBot I already forgot     -Inactive Unknown (PHP) BRFA Update stale links and remove linkspam
Ocobot Ocolon     -Inactive Unknown (PHP, MySQL) BRFA Finds dead links
PhuzBot Phuzion     -Inactive Unknown (Python) BRFA Find and report dead links (BRFA expired)
Polbot Quadell     -Inactive Unknown (Perl) BRFA 8 Repairs external links and references
ShakingBot ShakingSpirit     -Inactive Unknown (Python) BRFA Find and report dead links
VixDaemon KyraVixen     -Inactive Unknown (Python) BRFA 4 Finds external links
WaybackBot Tim1357     -Inactive Source code (Python) BRFA Check Wayback Machine for pages (BRFA withdrawn)
WebCiteBOT ThaddeusB     -Inactive Source code v1 Addons (Perl) BRFA 2 Storing links in WebCite service
ru:WebCite Archiver ru:Vlsergey     -Active Source code (Java, JWPF fork) Reporting dead links, storing alive links in WebCite service, only for {{cite web}} template

Bot resources

edit

Below are some resources for users wanting to build bots that work with external link issues.

WebCitation.org's position on bots

edit
I confirm that WebCite is very supportive. Ideally WebCite want to have the metadata associated with a reference handed over as well, so that statistics like "most cited author on wikipedia" can be calculated and displayed on a dashboard on the WebCite site. Please also hand over the "citing" article URL, e.g. in the refdoi field. WebCite is open source, so changes to the WebCite backend code (including a WebCitebot dashboard on the webcitation.org site) are also possible. To communication with WebCite, please use email only (I do not check my talk page on wikipedia), see http://www.webcitation.org/faq --Eysen (talk) 18:20, 9 February 2011 (UTC)[reply]

See also

edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_External_links/Webcitebot2&oldid=579319957"