Wikipedia:WikiProject Guild of Copy Editors/Membership/News/2020 Annual Report

Guild of Copy Editors 2020 End of Year Report

Report by Jonesey95, Baffle gab1978, Puddleglum2.0, Reidgreg, Tdslk, and Twofingered Typist. | Publication date.

Introduction

Welcome to the Guild of Copy Editors' (GOCE) annual report for 2020, a summary of membership activity, progress on the copy-editing backlog, and throughput of our Requests page.

Introduction text goes here.

Membership

GOCE membership is open to all editors in good standing who are interested in copy editing. Please see our membership page for information about signing up and remember to add your username to our mailing list to receive Guild news. Guild membership is voluntary and informal, and editors do not have to be members of the Guild to participate in its activities. Many editors perform copy editing outside of our organized events but we have no means of tracking such efforts.

At the end of 2020 there were 1928 pages populating the Guild's membership category, 1429 names on the Guild's membership list, and 651 names on the mailing list. This is a growth of 123, 117, and 38, respectively, from the end of 2019.

Of the approximately 127 editors who are listed as having joined the Guild in 2020:

• 30 completed a copy edit with a Guild-organized activity during 2020, including:
  • 16 who participated in one or more Drives
  • 13 who participated in one or more Blitzes
  • 13 who completed Requests
  • 2 who participated in all three activities

If you were one of these new editors, thank you, and welcome!

Coordinators

The GOCE coordinators are responsible for coordinating Guild activities, maintaining our pages, organizing Drives and Blitzes, looking after the Requests page, and performing other maintenance tasks that keep the Guild running smoothly. They are chosen twice a year through consensus voting.

The coordinator team remained largely unchanged at the beginning of 2020. Reidgreg stepped down as lead coordinator and served alongside returning coordinators Baffle gab1978, Tdslk, and Twofingered Typist. Coming back from a brief wikisabbatical, Jonesey95 served as lead coordinator throughout 2020. Miniapolis retired as an active coordinator and was named a coordinator emeretus – a distinction last bestowed six years previously.

Into the second term, Reidgreg stepped down and was replaced by first-time coordinator Puddleglum2.0. However, Puddleglum2.0 became inactive on Wikipedia partway through the term.

The December 2020 elections saw a bigger turnover. Dhtwiki and Tenryuu were elected as first-time coordinators. Dhtwiki has been a long-time member of the guild, while Tenryuu is a relative newcomer but among the most active members in 2020. Miniapolis returned to serve as an active coordinator, while Tdslk stepped down after serving nine consecutive terms.

Tdslk became the eighth editor inducted into the GOCE Hall of Fame, for long-time service and keeping the GOCE running smoothly.

Thanks to everyone who took the time to participate in the elections and thanks to our coordinators for their diligent, drama-free volunteer labor. Elections are scheduled for June and December each year; links to the election pages are posted in the Guild's message box (add it to your Watchlist). All Wikipedians in good standing are welcome to nominate themselves or others. Please consider helping out if you can.

Term	2020		2021
	January 1 – June 30	July 1 – December 31	January 1 – June 30
Election	December 2019	June 2020	December 2020
Lead coordinator	Jonesey95	Jonesey95	Jonesey95
Coordinators	Baffle gab1978 Reidgreg Tdslk Twofingered Typist	Baffle gab1978 Puddleglum 2.0 Tdslk Twofingered Typist	Dhtwiki Miniapolis Tenryuu Twofingered Typist

For the GOCE's 10th anniversary, here is a table of everyone who has served as a coordinator or earned a place in the GOCE hall of fame.

Username	Term
	2011		2012		2013		2014		2015		2016		2017		2018		2019		2020		2021
	1	2	1	2	1	2	1	2	1	2	1	2	1	2	1	2	1	2	1	2	1
SMasters (talk)		E
Diannaa (talk)			H	E
The Utahraptor
Tea with toast (talk)
Chaosdruid (talk)
Torchiest (talk)							E
Slon02 (talk)
Stfg (talk)					E
Sp33dyphil (talk)
Dank (talk)
Allens (talk)
BDD (talk)
Miniapolis (talk)										H									E
Baffle gab1978 (talk)				H
Jonesey95 (talk)													H
Philg88 (talk)
Biblioworm (talk)
Keira1996 (talk)
Pax85 (talk)
Corinne (talk)															H
Tdslk (talk)																					H
Reidgreg (talk)
Twofingered Typist (talk)																H
Puddleglum2.0 (talk)
Dhtwiki (talk)
Tenryuu (talk)

  Coordinator   Lead coordinator  E  Inducted as a coordinator emeretus  H  Inducted into the Hall of Fame

Requests page

Requests for copy editing are one of the Guild's main focal points. In 2020, our Requests page (REQ) had its busiest year since its inception; 752 requests were received, 720 were processed and 684 were completed.¹

February was our quietest month for received requests; 47 requests were received and 66 were processed, and by 3 March there were just four requests awaiting attention (diff). The early-to-mid-year period saw a dramatic increase in the number of new requests, probably due to the COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns and restrictions in many countries. This increase is reflected in the processing times; requests waited an average of 5.2 days in March and 37.1 days in August, and the average processing time remained at just under 30 days for the rest of the year.

Any editor can accept requests but because articles posted to the Requests page are often being held to a higher standard of compliance with Wikipedia's guidelines, we prefer editors who are new to or inexperienced with copy editing to gain experience with articles in the backlog before handling requests.

Among the 752 requests received in 2020 were:²

• 326 for GAN
• 3 for GAR
• 95 for FAC
• 2 for FAR
• 7 for FLC
• 15 for PR
• 6 for ACN
• 1 for ACR
• 2 for BCN
• 4 for CCN
• 68 for DYK
• 1 for OTD
• 1 for section-only copyedit
• 27 declined
• 14 withdrawn
• 233 unspecified

Monthly breakdown

2020 Month	Requests			Mean days to complete
	Received	Processed	Completed
January	82	73	71	9.9
February	47	66	66	12.7
March	80	56	56	5.2
April	93	68	64	15.3
May	90	83	77	18.6
June	64	69	63	29.2
July	51	48	42	32.2
August	44	57	53	37.1
September	40	49	47	32.7
October	59	49	47	29.3
November	47	39	38	28.9
December	55	63	60	29.5
Totals	752	720	684	280.6
Average	62.7	60.0	57.0	23.4

Note that because some requests are declined or withdrawn, there will always be more requests received than completed.

Some analysis and comparison to previous years:

• 684 requests were completed³ in 2020 (including 18 from 2019), compared with 607 in 2019, 668 in 2018, 571 in 2017, 665 in 2016, 537 in 2015, and 486 in 2014.
• 752 requests were received in 2020, compared with 616 in 2019, 690 in 2018, 588 in 2017, 690 in 2016, 543 in 2015, and 489 in 2014.
• The mean completion time was 23.3 days. The median was 26 days and the mode was 34 and 35 days. Previous averages were 19 days in 2019, 15 days in 2018, 26 days in 2017, 17 days in 2016, 30 days in 2015, and 41 days in 2013.
• Fewer than 34% of requests waited more than 30 days, and 8% of requests waited longer than 40 days.

Distribution of time-to-completion of requests (in days) from 2017 (light green) to 2020 (dark green)

2020 began with 18 copy-edit requests remaining from December 2019. The number of pending requests fluctuated from the mid-teens to the mid-twenties for the first half of January, rose to the mid-thirties in the following week, then declined to single-digit figures at the end of February and beginning of March. Figures then rose again and peaked in the mid-sixties by the end of April (that month's blitz had a non-request theme). The request backlog then held in the mid-fifties to mid-sixties through the northern summer, briefly peaking in the seventies in June. The backlog saw reductions in August and held in the thirties and forties throughout September, revisiting the fifties in late October and the mid-sixties in early December before closing the year with 51 pending requests.

Of the 752 requests submitted in 2020, 41 were declined or withdrawn. Fifty-one copy editors completed the remaining 710 requests, which were submitted by 276 editors.

• Top five request copy editors:
  • Twofingered Typist (273 & 7 assists)
  • Baffle gab1978 (156 & 5 assists)
  • Tenryuu (41)
  • Miniapolis (38 & 2 assists)
  • Tdslk (22)

• Top five request submitters:
  • Another Believer (35)
  • Doug Coldwell (28)
  • Gazal world (24) / Yeepsi (24)
  • Tintor2 (22)
  • West Virginian (14)

Notes

^1 Figures were arrived at by exporting tables from the 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, and 2013 request archives into a spreadsheet for analysis, particularly for completion periods.

^2 Some requests were made for multiple reasons; these were listed in each applicable category.

^3 Figures for completed requests discount any that were declined or withdrawn. Figures for requests submitted, received, processed or addressed include requests that were ultimately declined or withdrawn.

A full list of 2020 requests is available at our 2020 archive page.

Human interest section (if any)

A 'human interest' section about events or happenings around the GOCE could go here. We might mention the COVID-19 effects, the march MILHIST blitz, the May 10th Anniversary Drive, the unintended June 'Leap Blitz', and the two reports at The Signpost. Who knows what else might happen this year? This is a bit rough and may be moved elsewhere...

• In March, the Guild teamed up with WikiProject Military History to copy-edit articles related to, erm, Military History. (stats etc).

• May 2020 was the tenth anniversary of the Guild's first month-long Backlog Elimination Drive.To mark the occasion, Wikipedia's internal magazine The Signpost included an interview with regular GOCE copy-editors and project coordinators. The early June edition also included a piece about our May drive.

• Our June Blitz was unexpectedly extended for a day due to a coordinator's error. To save face, this was retrospectively named a "Leap Blitz". Deep joy.

Backlog Elimination Drives

Outstanding tags at the
end of each month

	2019	2020
January	842	323
February	1,039	477
March	811	118
April	1,011	365
May	598	156
June	897	534
July	585	255
August	814	438
September	519	371
October	684	548
November	479	481
December	638	311

The Guild's main efforts toward reducing the number of articles tagged with {{copy edit}} were six backlog-elimination Drives held in alternating months, starting in January. At the beginning of the year, there were 638 articles in the backlog. A record low of 118 was reached at the end of the March Drive, and the backlog was reduced to a single month at the end of the May Drive. Self-isolation from coronavirus may have played a hand in making the March through July Drives among our most successful. While the backlog rebounded somewhat after that period, the backlog averaged at about 360 articles and three months throughout the year.

• January Drive: 215 copy edits were completed including 56 articles from the Requests page and 116 backlog articles from the target months of June to August 2019. At the conclusion of the drive there was a record low of 323 articles in the copy editing backlog. Of the 27 editors who signed up for the drive, 21 copyedited at least one article. Final results, including barnstars awarded, are available here.

• March Drive: The copy-editing backlog was reduced from 477 to a record low of 118 articles, a 75% reduction. The last four months of 2019 were cleared, reducing the backlog to three months. Fifty requests were also completed, and the total word count of copy-edited articles was 759,945. Of the 29 editors who signed up, 22 completed at least one copy edit. Final results, including barnstars awarded, are available here.

• May Drive: This event marked the 10th anniversary of the GOCE's copy-editing drives and diminished the backlog to just one month of articles – i.e.: eliminating all the tags which had been placed prior to the start of the drive. 499 copy edits were recorded totalling 832,609 words. Of the 51 editors who signed up, 43 copyedited at least one article. Final results, including barnstars awarded, are available here.

• July Drive: For the third consecutive drive, copy editing totals exceeded 750,000 words. All but three tags placed prior to the drive were addressed. Of the 38 people who signed up, 30 copyedited at least one article. Final results and awards are listed here.

• September Drive: Activity slowed dramatically this month; only 15 of the 27 editors who signed up for the event recorded a copy edit. 36 Requests were completed and 88 articles were removed from the backlog. Final results, including barnstars awarded, are available here.

• November Drive: Activity remained low for the final drive of 2020. Of the 18 editors who signed up, 15 completed at least one copy edit. They completed 39 Requests and removed 95 articles from the backlog, which was 481 articles and just over three months at the end of the drive. Final results and awards are listed here.

Drive totals for the year: 71 editors removed 1,356 articles from the backlog and completed 301 301 copy edit requests for a total of 1,657 copy edits or 2,575,027 words.

29 editors participated in two or more Drives, 17 editors participated in three or more Drives, and 8 editors participated in all six: thanks to Baffle gab1978, BlueMoonset, Dhtwiki, Gog the Mild, Jonesey95, Miniapolis, Tdslk, and Twofingered Typist. 140 barnstars were awarded for contributions to Drives.

Notes: About 300–400 articles are tagged with {{copyedit}} every month, so we need to process somewhere around 4,000 articles from the backlog each year just to break even. The number of articles formally listed as copy-edited during each Drive includes only articles for which editors took credit on the Drive page. Additional articles are removed from the backlog by editors who do a quick or minor copy edit and don't record it on the Drive page, edit during non-Drive months, remove a copyedit tag because it is no longer needed or not applicable, or nominate an article for deletion.

Blitzes

The Guild organized six one-week Blitzes in 2020, in alternating months with the backlog drives. These year saw our first "leap blitz" and the first time that the backlog was reduced during a blitz month.

• February Blitz: Of the 15 editors who signed up, 13 completed at least one copy edit. A total of 32 articles were copy edited, evenly split between the twin goals of requests and the oldest articles from the copy-editing backlog. Full results are here.

• April Blitz: This blitz ran from 12 to 18 April with a theme of Indian military history. Of the 18 people who signed up, 14 copyedited at least one article. Participants claimed a total of 60 copyedits. Final results, including barnstars awarded, are available here.

• June Blitz: This blitz ran from 14 to 21 June – due to an uncorrected typo (even copyeditors make mistakes) this became an eight-day "leap blitz". Of the 31 editors who signed up, 19 completed at least one copy edit. 54 articles with a total of 101,180 words were copy edited. Final results, including barnstars awarded, are available here.

• August Blitz: From 16 to 22 August, we copy edited articles tagged in June and July 2020 and requests. Of the 15 editors who signed up, 12 editors completed 37 copy edits. Final results, including barnstars awarded, are available here.

• October Blitz: This event ran from 18 to 24 October, targeting articles tagged in July and August 2020 and requests. Of the 13 editors who signed up, 11 editors completed 21 copy edits. (full results)

• December Blitz: This event ran 13 to 19 December and targeted articles tagged in August and September 2020 and requests. Of the 21 editors who signed up, 14 copyedited at least one article—including 15 requests—and removed 15 articles from the backlog. This, along with a lot of gnomish retagging, made this the only blitz month to see an overall reduction in the backlog. (full results)

Blitz totals for the year: 37 editors completed 71 requests and 114 articles from the backlog, plus 49 articles on a special theme, for a total of 234 copy edits (414,919 words).

15 editors participated in two or more Blitzes, 11 editors participated in three or more, and 5 editors participated in all six: thanks to Baffle gab1978, Dhtwiki, Jonesey95, Tdslk and Twofingered Typist! These five editors also participated in the Guild's six Drives, making them a perfect 12 for 12!

The Guild awarded 73 barnstars for contributions to Blitzes.

Annual Leaderboard

The following table records the top contributions for combined activity in the Guild's Drives and Blitzes and on the Requests page throughout 2020. We appreciate the many hours of volunteer work represented here. Will you be on this table in 2021?

	1	2	3	4	5
Total Articles	Tenryuu (353)	Twofingered Typist (350)	Tdslk (295)	Baffle gab1978 (193.5)	Reidgreg (162)
Total Requests1	Twofingered Typist (269)	Baffle gab1978 (155)	Miniapolis (45.5)	Tenryuu (41)	Tdslk (22)
Blitz and Drive Totals2	Tenryuu (319)	Tdslk (291)	Twofingered Typist (224)	Reidgreg (162)	Baffle gab1978 (100)
Oldest Articles2,3	Tenryuu (312)	Tdslk (278)	Reidgreg (146)	Miniapolis (84)	Twofingered Typist (59)
Total Words2	Twofingered Typist (650,558)	Tenryuu (647,356)	Reidgreg (322,566)	Tdslk (249,385)	Baffle gab1978 (233,119)
5k+ Articles2,4	Twofingered Typist (46)	Tenryuu (44)	Reidgreg (29)	Miniapolis (12)	Dhtwiki (11)
Longest Article2	Reidgreg (26,280)	Tenryuu (25,508)	Miniapolis (22,692)	Hiabc (20,540)	Twofingered Typist (17,028)
Leaderboard Awards5	Reidgreg (25) Tenryuu (25)	Twofingered Typist (23)	Miniapolis (22)	Tdslk (13)	Dhtwiki (8)
Gold Awards5	Tenryuu (16)	Twofingered Typist (7)	Reidgreg (4)	Tdslk (3)	Dhtwiki (1) Thatoneweirdwikier (1)

Notes

^1 Requests completed in 2020, counting a half-point when credit was split.

^2 Includes Blitzes and Drives only.

^3 Articles from the oldest or target backlog month(s) of each Drive and of Blitzes except for the April blitz (which had a theme).

^4 Number of articles of 5,000 words or more. An article of 10k+ words counts as 2, of 15k+ as 3, etc.

^5 Awards from Drive leaderboards only.

Plans for 2021

The newly elected or returning GOCE lead coordinator writes something inspiring here (hopefully).

Placeholder text:

• All-time low backlog count.
• Looking for new population of articles to edit (typo team partnership)
• Requests very popular
• Tdslk HOF induction