Wikipedia:WikiProject United States Public Policy/Assessment/Jyrejoice

Jyrejoice's PPI Assessment Page

Jyrejoice is classified as a Wikipedia expert.

Assessment 1, part 1

The purpose of this evaluation in not to gauge variability in article quality, but to look at the metric itself. How consistent is this assessment tool? and Is there a difference in scores between subject area expert assessment and Wikipedian article assessment?

Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness - 4/10(Introduction to the Act needs a little more info)
• Sourcing - 1/6( Sources are limited)
• Neutrality -1/3(More critical views are required)
• Readability -2/3 ( Content to be re-structured)
• Illustrations - 1/2
• Formatting - 1/2
• Total - 10/26

Homeland Security Act (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness - 3/10( More information is to be retrieved and expanded to the article
• Sourcing - 0/6( There are no references to external links to be verified)
• Neutrality - 1/3
• Readability - 2/3 (There are some grammatical mistakes to be corrected. eg: Law's language is not a suitable term)
• Illustrations - 0/2
• Formatting - 1/2
• Total - 7/26

James Q Wilson (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness -3/10
• Sourcing -1/6(More sources to be added)
• Neutrality - 1/3
• Readability - 2/3
• Illustrations -0/2( No illustrations)
• Formatting -2/2(Structure is good)
• Total - 9/26

Drug policy of the United States (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness - 3/10( There is not much introduction to the Topic Content)
• Sourcing - 4/6 (Some of the content in the end has no sources to verify)
• Neutrality - 0/3( There is no reference to any positive results of the Legislation laws)
• Readability - 1/3( There is no flow in general for the content. Info is just loosely laid out)
• Illustrations - 1/2
• Formatting - 0/2
• Total - 9/26

Medicare (United States) (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness - 7/10( Latest Developments of Restrictions to Patients not mentioned)
• Sourcing - 4/6( External References are used more than norms)
• Neutrality - 3/3
• Readability - 3/3
• Illustrations - 3/3
• Formatting - 2/2
• Total - 22/26

Operation Green Sweep (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness -4/10
• Sourcing - 4/6
• Neutrality -1/3
• Readability -1/3(Content can be divided into different sections)
• Illustrations - 0/2
• Formatting - 1/2
• Total - 11/26

Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness -7/10
• Sourcing -4/6
• Neutrality - 1/3(Not enough content on any shortfalls of the program)
• Readability - 2/3
• Illustrations -2/2
• Formatting -1/2( Restructuring into different headings will help)
• Total -17/26

Universal health care (1 July 2010)

• Comprehensiveness -7/10(well detailed comparing different countries, but need to develop more on the civilian feedback)
• Sourcing - 4/6
• Neutrality - 1/3
• Readability 2/3(Article is quite long and the comparison if tabular or graphical will be more easy to comprehend)
• Illustrations - 1/2(Requires more charts and graphs to illustrate the comparisons)
• Formatting - 1/2 ( To be restructured to avoid long pages)
• Total -16/26

Assessment 1, Part 2

Assessment request 2, please use article version from 1 October 2010. There are a couple of rereviews, hopefully those will go fast for you. This set will tie up the first assessment, which tests the quantitative metric and compares Wikipedian assessment to expert assessment. Sorry the article titles don't link to the correct article version, I will do this in the future.

Equal Access to COBRA Act link

• Comprehensiveness -1/10
• Sourcing - 0/6
• Neutrality - 0/3
• Readability - 0/3
• Illustrations - 0/2
• Formatting - 0/2
• Total - 1/26

Reorganization Plan No. 3 link

• Comprehensiveness -1/10
• Sourcing -1/6
• Neutrality -0/3
• Readability - 0/3
• Illustrations -0/2
• Formatting -0/2
• Total -2/26

Brown v. Board of Education link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Government Accountability Office link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Illegal immigrant population of the United States link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

State school link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Homeland Security Act link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total

Medicare (United States) link

• Comprehensiveness
• Sourcing
• Neutrality
• Readability
• Illustrations
• Formatting
• Total