Wikipedia:Wikipedia as a press source 2008
![]() | This page is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference. Either the page is no longer relevant or consensus on its purpose has become unclear. To revive discussion, seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump. Use the {{Press}} template to add press coverage of a particular Wikipedia article to that article's talk page, and use Wikipedia:Press coverage for press coverage of the Wikipedia project in general. |
Wikipedia as a press source |
---|
Wikipedia in the media |
---|
Wikipedia as a topic |
Wikipedia as a source |
- This page is not Wikipedia:Reliable sources or Wikipedia:Citing sources.
January
edit- Broadsword and the Beast was cited in a feature story in The A.V. Club titled Decorate thine façade with resplendent self-seriousness: 18 particularly ridiculous prog-rock album covers on 28 January 2008.
- "Oh, and quoth Wikipedia: 'The runic symbols around the edge of the cover are from the Cirth rune system used by J.R.R. Tolkien in The Lord Of The Rings.' Of course they are."
- Spinka (Hasidic dynasty) was cited in a report of the Jewish Journal of Greater Los Angeles which can be viewed here.
- 2007 subprime mortgage financial crisis was cited in a leader in The Guardian titled How to end a crisis on 19 January 2008.
February
edit- Derrick, Evan (2008-02-25). "REVIEW: REVIEW: [sic] U2 3D". MovieZeal.
- "According to Wikipedia, U2 is doing this for experimentation and not for profit, and U2 3D will not be released in 2D format, either to theaters or to home video."
- Command responsibility used by the TimesDaily to explain the doctrine to its readers.[1]
- Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo was cited in an Op-Ed piece by Andrew Swerlik of The Emory Wheel - "For those of you curious about just how the above is actually proper English, the best place to go would be Wikipedia, which actually has an article on the sentence that includes diagrams, pictures of buffalo and an mp3 file of somebody reading the entire article out loud, “Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo”’s and all." [2]
- Odell, Michael "This much I know" The Observer Magazine February 3, 2008
- "I looked myself up on Wikipedia once and I was interested to learn that I had once dated Viv Albertine of The Slits. This is fascinating but untrue. I've never met her. I wish I had."
- Wales, Matt. "Dead Space Preview." IGN. February 7, 2008. link
- "According to Wikipedia, 'in physiology, dead space is air that is inhaled by the body in breathing, but does not partake in gas exchange.'"
- Wignall, Mark, Another Jamaican shining - in the South Pacific] The Jamaica Observer, 10 February, 2008[[3]
- "There are few places which invoke the word 'exotic' quite like the Kingdom of Tonga. It is the only archipelago (Archipelago) in the Pacific Ocean (Pacific_Ocean) never to have been formally colonised. It lies south of Samoa (Samoa) and east of Fiji (Fiji) and is about a third of the way between New Zealand (New Zealand) and Hawaii (Hawaii)...According to Wikipedia, 'Women and men have equal access to education and health care, and are fairly equal in employment, but women are discriminated against in land holding, electoral politics, and government ministries. However, in Tongan tradition, women enjoy a higher social status than men, a cultural trait that is unique among the insular societies of the Pacific."
- Alexander Ovechkin was cited by Zinser, Lynn. "From Russia With Verve: It’s Ovechkin." The New York Times. 13 February, 2008. [4]
- "[Ovechkin's] falling-down-and-shooting backward goal as a rookie is an endless loop on his Wikipedia entry."
- The parody newspaper The Onion discussed Heath Ledger's wikipedia page in "Area Man Honored To Be One Who Added Death Date To Heath Ledger's Wikipedia Page." [5]
- - "Blake Yardley, 34, told reporters Monday that he felt extremely humbled to have been the individual who, amidst the chaos and sadness of actor Heath Ledger's recent untimely passing, had the foresight and due reverence to add the death date to the star's Wikipedia page."
- Hyde, Marina. "Lost in showbiz: Is this what Steve [Irwin] would have wanted?"." The Guardian. 29 February 2008 [6]
- In fact, visit Steve's Wikipedia page and there is an entire section entitled "Backlash against stingrays". "In the weeks following Irwin's death," this states, "at least 10 stingrays were found dead and mutilated, with their tails cut off, on the beaches of Queensland, prompting speculation that they had been killed by fans of Irwin as an act of revenge."
- Dick, Thom. "EMS Dirty Secret" EMS Magazine. February 2008. [7]
- "An addiction is a recurring complusion to engage in some specific activity, despire harmful consequences to an individual's health, mental state or social life."
March
edit- Howley, Kerry. "Artifact: The World Needs Citations." Reason Magazine. March 2008. [8]
- "Nothing conveys Wikipedia’s openness to revision quite like “[citation needed],” the bracketed phrase sprinkled throughout its pixellated scrolls."
- Spencer, Robert. "Wikipedia and Robert Spencer." Jihad Watch. March 6, 2008. [9]
- "my Wikipedia bio ... is relentlessly biased, and the negative spin is thoroughgoing."
- Showtime Penn & Teller: Bullshit! episode "Breast Hysteria".
- references article Topfreedom, displaying the Wikipedia page.[10]
- Farber, Dan (2008-03-15). "Proof of six degrees of separation", Cnet News. Accessed November 20, 2008.
- References Six degrees of separation, and uses lead Image (Image:Six_degrees_of_separation.png).
April
edit- Gonzales, J.R. "The joke's on Miss Ima." Houston Chronicle. April 1 2008[11]
- Seems the folks at Wikipedia are having a little fun at Ima Hogg's expense this April Fools' Day.
- Soria, Chester. "Wikipedia remembers Ima Hogg". Houstonist.com. April 1, 2008 . [12]
- Anybody who is worth their salt about Houston history knows Ima Hogg. You don't even need to be a Bayou City scholar in order to know of Ms. Hogg. Case in point, Wikipedia is shining a spotlight on the notoriously named philanthropist as its featured article of the day.
- McCarthy, Caroline. "Wikipedia fudges the truth for April Fools' Day". News.com. April 1, 2008. [13]
- Whoever wrote the fake Ima Hogg bio might want to think about pursuing a career in screenwriting. It sounds more amusing than any of the movies I've seen recently...
- Walsh, Scott "Teen swim star in bully claims" Herald Sun. April 6 2008 [14]
- The bullying allegations against Seebohm - daughter of Glenelg 300-game Hall of Fame SANFL player John Seebohm - came to light after an entry appeared on information-sharing website Wikipedia
- As it happens, a Google search for “Heritage Foundation” produces millions of links. The first two go directly to the think tank’s own website. The third, however, leads to Wikipedia, the popular online encyclopedia. This winter, Wagner was surfing around Wikipedia to see what it said about her employer. Soon she found herself reading the entry for Heritage president Edwin Feulner. “It was full of errors,” she says...“The author was obviously hostile to us,” she says. “It wasn’t even remotely neutral.”
- Anybody who searches the Internet for information about candidates can’t avoid bumping into Wikipedia. On a Google search for “John McCain,” the Wikipedia entry comes in second — just below McCain’s presidential-campaign website and just above his Senate-office website.
- McCain’s entry is locked, which means that ordinary users of Wikipedia can’t change its content. The same is true for a handful of other entries, including those on President Bush, Hillary Clinton, and Barack Obama.
- In the current issue of Education Next, Michael Petrelli of the Fordham Foundation complains that Wikipedia’s entry on school vouchers contains an abundance of negative commentary...Shortly after Petrelli published this observation, a Wikipedian added it to the school-voucher entry... “I guess it means that Wikipedia seems to be self-correcting,” says Petrelli.
- If Wikipedia’s openness is its primary strength, it’s also the website’s greatest vulnerability. In 2005, John Seigenthaler, a former journalist and Department of Justice official, learned just how far the mischief can go.
- In 2006, the Lowell (Mass.) Sun revealed that the staff of former Democratic representative Marty Meehan had removed a reference to the congressman’s broken term-limit pledge. Other members of Congress have had their entries whitewashed by their employees, including Democratic senator Dianne Feinstein of California (a mention of a campaign-finance fine was expunged) and Republican senator Norm Coleman of Minnesota (who apparently didn’t want anybody to know he was a “liberal Democrat” in college).
- The burnishing was bipartisan. Yet loads of entries carry an ideological slant. Leslie Graves of the Wisconsin-based Lucy Burns Institute tracks Wikipedia coverage. “Negative information about liberals is buried, but with conservatives it’s featured prominently,” she says. “Just look at the entry for Eliot Spitzer.”...By contrast, the entry for Republican senator David Vitter of Louisiana points out in its first paragraph that he was identified last year as the client of a Washington, D.C., escort service. Sex scandals involving Republicans Larry Craig and Mark Foley also receive much more emphasis than Spitzer’s fall from grace. (Because Wikipedia entries are constantly updated, they may change over time; the descriptions provided here are accurate as of late March.)
- “On Wikipedia, we got our brains beat out.” Whereas the entry on George Allen came to read like a compendium of opposition research, the one on Allen’s Democratic opponent, Jim Webb, didn’t suffer the same kind of treatment. “His profile was glowing,” says Henke.
- On the web, a different story could be unfolding — and if conservatives don’t catch up, the Wikipedia entry for “United States general elections, 2008” may include results that no amount of clever editing will rub away.
- Note: Wikipedia editor Pete (talk), who was interviewed for this story, blogged about it.
- McCarthy, Noelle. "Is Bard of New Lynn ready to seize the day". New Zealand Herald. April 12 2008 [15]
- A quick Wikipedia reveals one Alfred Domett, 4th Premier of NZ (1811-1887) and proud author of not one but three volumes of poetry....
- Rennie, John and Steve Mirsky. Scientific American. "Six Things in Expelled That Ben Stein Doesn't Want You to Know...", 2008 April 16. Page 2. [16]
- (More detailed descriptions of the Sternberg case can be found on Ed Brayton's blog Dispatches from the Culture Wars and on Wikipedia.)
- Laurent, Samuel (April 21, 2008). "L'étrange histoire du «phénomène Jin Jing»". Le Figaro (in French). Retrieved 2008-04-21.
Créée juste après les incidents des Paris, une longue fiche Wikipedia en anglais est disponible sur elle.
- Whitesides, Loretta Hidalgo. "Obama Picks Up New Space/Tech Endorsements" Wired.com. 25 April 2008
- "A long list of people endorsing Obama can be found on Wikipedia, which also hosts a list for Clinton."
- Sainsbury, Michael. "Uni chief lifted Islam text from Wikipedia. The Australian. April 26, 2008.
- In September, Professor O'Connor expressed concern about Wikipedia and web-based research. ... Professor O'Connor denies that by lifting sentences from Wikipedia he has breached his university's guidelines on plagiarism.
- http://ftalphaville.ft.com/blog/2008/04/28/12650/warren-buffett-chews-gum-and-identifies-value-at-the-same-time/ link to Wrigley Company
May
edit- Lost' Dueling Analysis: Cabin Fever
- " I zeroed in "The Book of Laws." Found it this morning on Wikipedia. It's a text of the Baha'i faith -- and I could swear Baha'i has surfaced on "Lost" before, though I can't recall where just now. But here's a little more about Baha'i..."
June
edit- Roberts, David. "Officials say Wikipedia flyover rumours a hoax." The Northern Echo. 10 June 2008.
- "Local councillors have taken a number of calls from concerned residents in Cockerton, Darlington, after an update on the Wikipedia website said a flyover linking the centre of Darlington to the A1(M) would be built over the village."
- Power, John. "Japanese names." The Indexer Volume 26, No. 2. June 2008. Available at EBSCOHost.
- p. C-4-8. "A Net search under ‘Japanese names’ will uncover a small number of articles which will supplement the information in this article. One of them is an excellent article in Wikipedia, although it may be directed more at people who can read Japanese."
July
edit- Dongen, Susan Van. "Everything is Illuminated: Fireflies will light up the night at Terhune Orchards' Firefly Festival. Princeton Packet. July 2, 2008.
- "As far as she knows, fireflies are neither detrimental nor beneficial to plants. However, an item in Wikipedia states that the adult diet may consist of slugs and snails, so gardeners should be delighted with their presence."
- Judging the Torture Presidency of George W. Bush - Building a case for a prosecution that likely won't happen by Nat Hentoff, July 2nd, 2008, cites the following from command responsibility:
- codified for the first time as an international doctrine in the 1977 Additional Protocol to the 1949 Geneva Conventions:
- The fact that a breach of the Conventions . . . was committed by a subordinate does not absolve his superiors from . . . responsibility . . . if they knew, or had information which should have enabled them to conclude, in the circumstances at the time, that [the subordinate] was committing or about to commit such a breach and if they did not take all feasible measures within their power to prevent or repress the breach.
August
edit- Fox, Stuart. "Great College Pranks: A gallery of famous collegiate capers." Used Image:Burdell's Store.jpg. Popsci.com. August 11, 2008. http://www.popsci.com/entertainment-%2526-gaming/gallery/2008-08/great-college-pranks
- Cawthorne, Andrew. "Mystery torch guard becomes Chinese sex symbol."(Article about Second right brother) Reuters. August 12, 2008. link
- "'They praised him for his 360-degree handsome look, well-built body in perfect proportion, refined and exemplary postures, smile and courtesy to torch bearers, his pals and audience, and 'determination to safeguard the Olympic spirit," reads his entry in the Wikipedia web database."
- Altavilla, John. "Delaware Coach Says Delle Donne Online Posting Untrue." (Article about Elena Delle Donne). The Hartford Courant. August 13, 2008. http://www.courant.com/sports/college/husky/women/hcu-ucdelledonne-0813,0,4382065.story
- "UConn women's basketball fans waiting for prized recruit Elena Delle Donne to announce whether she will return to campus for the start of her freshman season were likely surprised to read the last line of the player's biography on the search site Wikipedia."
- Adamski, Katrina. "Chroming horror hits home" North Shore Times. August 22, 2008. Cites wikipedia's inhalant article in a side box about "Who does it?"
- Buchanan, Levi. "Top 10 Best-Selling Atari 2600 Games." IGN. August 26, 2008. link
- Although the article does not explicitly references it, it heavily uses information from the Atari section of the list of best-selling video games, down to game names and amount of sales, along with information taken from the articles of every game.
September
edit- Elmer-DeWitt, Philip. "Can Steve Jobs save the iPod?" (Uses model tables from iPod). Fortune. September 4, 2008.link
- "Survival expert Grylls admits his TV rival Ray Mears is the real tough guy" (Several lines copy-and-pasted from Ray Mears - uncredited). The Daily Mail. September 18, 2008.link
- Ormiston, Susan. "Wiki Wars" (Discusses edit wars which occur on Wikipedia during election campaigns.) The National, CBC Television, 25 September 2008. link
- Brown, Alex. "Italy eyes Gower, warts'n'all". Rugby Heaven (Fairfax Media), September 29. "[Italy coach Nick] Mallett initially turned to Wikipedia to research [NRL player Craig] Gower, and was aghast to note the majority of the Australian's profile fell under the sub-category, "Controversy", detailing his numerous brushes with officialdom in Australia."[17]
- The wikipedia page of Tomato (firmware) was cited in "Episode 71 - Free $500 Router Upgrade (For your junk $50 Router!)", Systm - Revision3, in the show notes of the episode.
October
edit- Fatsis, Stefan. "NHL Season Opens In Europe" (Said that he learned that the Stockholm Globe Arena was "...the largest hemispherical building in the world and ... represents the Sun in the Sweden Solar System..." from Wikipedia.) National Public Radio October 3, 2008.
- Gopal, Prashant. "Towns that could be hit hardest by the financial crisis" (In accompanying slide show, uses a cropped version of this image to represent Summit, New Jersey). Business Week, via msn.com, October 12, 2008
- Simmons, Glenn Franco. "Wikipedia Has Awesome Page About 49ers" (Explains how the details provided in San Francisco 49ers turned a former managing editor from advising others to avoid Wikipedia to a former managing editor praising the content in the San Francisco 49ers article.) Bleacher Report. October 11, 2008.
- Ross, Michael E. "Oh, Lord, Kumbaya: How an innocent campfire song got warped by the cynicism of our times." (Cites Kumbaya on origins of that song). The Root, October 13, 2008.
- Gilbert, Katie. "Browse the Beaver State: Web encyclopedia aims to be the go-to site for all things Oregon." Willamette Week, October 1, 2008. Article about the Oregon Encyclopedia compares it to Wikipedia; reporter did not contact local wiki community, article closes with a quote implying that Wikipedia editors do not care about bias.
November
edit- Ebert, Roger (2008-11-6)."Your flag decal won't get you into heaven any more", Chicago Sun Times. Accessed November 19, 2008.
- Film critic Roger Ebert quotes Wikipedia article on Lee Greenwood, and uses images appearing in his article as well as the Ben Snowden article.
- Lomax, John Nova. "Wikipedia's Secret Life Of Wayne Dolcefino." Houston Press. November 13, 2008. Article discusses obvious vandalism of Wayne Dolcefino article beginning on November 11, 2008 [18] and removed on November 14, 2008 [19].
- Mikel, Amy (November 19, 2008). "A Scientology Christmas Pageant?". Chicagoist. Gothamist LLC. Retrieved 2008-11-19.
- Links to the Reception section of the article A Very Merry Unauthorized Children's Scientology Pageant to show that the play "has had steadily good reception" since its 2003 debut.
- Stanley, Charles (2008-11-24). "Wikipedia debuts Worthy Streator biography". Life & Times Section. Streator Times-Press News. p. B-1. Retrieved 2008-11-24. Links to the article of Worthy S. Streator, informing readers of the history of the city's namesake. --
- Lester, Paul (2008-11-12). "New Band of the Day - No 429: Black Tide". The Guardian. Retrieved 2010-06-11.
- "Black Metal, according to Wikipedia, "often employs fast tempos, shrieked vocals, highly distorted guitars played with tremolo picking, double-kick drumming, and unconventional song structure"."
December
edit- Ebert, Roger (December 3, 2008), "Roger Ebert's Journal: Win Ben Stein's mind", Chicago Sun-Times, retrieved 2009-06-08
- "Still, in July 1891 at Monte Carlo, the same man broke the 100,000 franc bank at a roulette table three times. Wikipedia reports, 'A man named Charles Wells won 23 times out of 30 successive spins of the wheel...Despite hiring private detectives the Casino never discovered Wells's system. Wells later admitted it was just a lucky streak. His system was the high-risk martingale, doubling the stake to make up losses.'"
- "Best selling video game franchises". WSYR-TV. 2008-12-09. Retrieved 2008-12-26.
- Although they mention their source as Yahoo!, the original Yahoo! list copied most of the information from the list of best-selling video games (which was eventually divided into two articles). -- ReyBrujo (talk) 04:22, 27 December 2008 (UTC)
- Berg, Ted (December 12, 2008). "Will the Mets look Far East for talent?". SportsNet New York. Retrieved 2009-03-19.
- "The explanation on Wikipedia is as good as anything I'd be able to come up with, so I'll copy it here: 'When a player under contract with a Nippon Professional Baseball team wishes to play in Major League Baseball, he must notify his current team's management and request that they make him available for posting during the next posting period (Nov. 1-March 1). If the team consents, the player (including any other NPB players wishing to be posted) is presented to the MLB Commissioner. The Commissioner then notifies all MLB teams of the posted player and holds a four-day-long silent auction during which interested MLB teams submit sealed bids (in USD) to the Commissioner's Office. After the allotted four days have passed, the Commissioner closes the bidding process and notifies the posted player's NPB team of the highest bid amount but not who the bidding team is. The NPB team then has four days to either accept or reject the nonnegotiable bid amount.'"
- Headlam, Bruce (December 10, 2008), "The Films Are for Him. Got That?", The New York Times, retrieved March 18, 2015
- 'Despite what you might have read on Wikipedia, Mr. Eastwood is not a vegan, and he looked slightly aghast when told exactly what a vegan is. “I never look at the Internet for just that reason,” he said.'