| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Criterion 1 |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Criterion 1
|
| 50 Rule |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#50 Rule
|
| Something from books notability |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Something from books notability
|
| Released films criteria |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Released films criteria
|
| 200 Commercial Theaters? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#200 Commercial Theaters?
|
| What about Straight-To-DVD Releases??? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#What about Straight-To-DVD Releases???
|
| Wouldn't TV Movies fail these new guidelines, too? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Wouldn't TV Movies fail these new guidelines, too?
|
| Pointless. |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Pointless.
|
| Certainty |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Certainty
|
| Objection |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Objection
|
| Tagged as Historical |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Tagged as Historical
|
| Some other article that covers the issue then |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Some other article that covers the issue then
|
| Time to update |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Time to update
|
| We Appear To Have No Standards |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#We Appear To Have No Standards
|
| My suggested criteria for released films - please discuss |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#My suggested criteria for released films - please discuss
|
| Heavily Edited Guideline Proposal |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Heavily Edited Guideline Proposal
|
| Question to all editors (including zadignose) |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Question to all editors (including zadignose)
|
| Notability of actors |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Notability of actors
|
| Tagging |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Tagging
|
| RFC |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#RFC
|
| m:voting is evil |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#m:voting is evil
|
| Here's a thought |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Here's a thought
|
| AfD (Second) |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#AfD (Second)
|
| Options |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Options
|
| Merge |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Merge
|
| WP:3O |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#WP:3O
|
| Guideline |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Guideline
|
| Who supports this and why? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Who supports this and why?
|
| Template:pnc nominated for deletion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Template:pnc nominated for deletion
|
| Historical |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Historical
|
| Plug the loopholes |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Plug the loopholes
|
| New approach |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#New approach
|
| Edit for style and brevity |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Edit for style and brevity
|
| Accept as Guideline |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Accept as Guideline
|
| Revise "Future films, incomplete films, and undistributed films" criteria |
52 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Revise "Future films, incomplete films, and undistributed films" criteria
|
| Add "highly-viewed" and "nominated for a major award" as criteria |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Add "highly-viewed" and "nominated for a major award" as criteria
|
| Emphasize that this is a guideline not a rule |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Emphasize that this is a guideline not a rule
|
| Advice requested |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Advice requested
|
| Proposal |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Proposal
|
| Major awards |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Major awards
|
| Raiders of the Lost Ark |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Raiders of the Lost Ark
|
| Big picture problem with this guideline |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Big picture problem with this guideline
|
| Complaint. Too many shortcuts. Circular referencing |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Complaint. Too many shortcuts. Circular referencing
|
| WP:FLAG-MOVIE |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#WP:FLAG-MOVIE
|
| Some clarification |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Some clarification
|
| Incoming |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Incoming
|
| Old v. Contempory films |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Old v. Contempory films
|
| Problems with (mis)interpretation of "general principles" |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Problems with (mis)interpretation of "general principles"
|
| Noteability of TV Episodes |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Noteability of TV Episodes
|
| Box office ranking |
36 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Box office ranking
|
| What makes future films notable |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#What makes future films notable
|
| Documentary, program, or retrospective |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Documentary, program, or retrospective
|
| Assistance... |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Assistance...
|
| Unacceptable behaviour |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 1#Unacceptable behaviour
|
| Nff |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Nff
|
| (Un-)Reliable Site: Movie-censorship.com |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#(Un-)Reliable Site: Movie-censorship.com
|
| Direct-to-video |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Direct-to-video
|
| Regional Films |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Regional Films
|
| Notability from awards |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Notability from awards
|
| Merging of a future film article |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Merging of a future film article
|
| Low and No-Budget Films |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Low and No-Budget Films
|
| A General Rule |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#A General Rule
|
| Suggested deletion of section: Wikipedia:Notability (films)#Other evidence of notability |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Suggested deletion of section: Wikipedia:Notability (films)#Other evidence of notability
|
| remakes |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#remakes
|
| mentioning future films in other articles? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#mentioning future films in other articles?
|
| uniqueness of film section seems to invite OR |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#uniqueness of film section seems to invite OR
|
| Automate archiving? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Automate archiving?
|
| Re-release defined |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Re-release defined
|
| Never Sleep Again: The Elm Street Legacy |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Never Sleep Again: The Elm Street Legacy
|
| To clarify... |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#To clarify...
|
| Notability of upcoming animated films |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Notability of upcoming animated films
|
| Proposed ammendment to WP:NFF |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Proposed ammendment to WP:NFF
|
| Redirect this page to WP:GNG? |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Redirect this page to WP:GNG?
|
| WP:Requests for comment - Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X-Men: First Class (film project) |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#WP:Requests for comment - Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X-Men: First Class (film project)
|
| Wikipedia not news |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Wikipedia not news
|
| Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Most Hated Family in America |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Most Hated Family in America
|
| Hallmark Hall of Fame: Front of the Class |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Hallmark Hall of Fame: Front of the Class
|
| Worth Adding? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Worth Adding?
|
| Future "film projects" |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Future "film projects"
|
| Some comments on WP:GNG and WP:CRYSTAL and their relation to WP:NFF |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Some comments on WP:GNG and WP:CRYSTAL and their relation to WP:NFF
|
| Film Threat |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Film Threat
|
| Partial rewrite |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Partial rewrite
|
| Guideline adjustment |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Guideline adjustment
|
| Notability of Indian language films |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Notability of Indian language films
|
| Ridiculous guideline on upcoming films |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Ridiculous guideline on upcoming films
|
| IMDB |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#IMDB
|
| Film series |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Film series
|
| Notability of Verax |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Notability of Verax
|
| Untitled projects |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Untitled projects
|
| Comment |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Comment
|
| Multiple DVD releases? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Multiple DVD releases?
|
| Wikipedia:Notability (television shows) |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Wikipedia:Notability (television shows)
|
| RfC: Can reviews through Film Threat's paid "Submission for Review system" be considered an independent source for determining notability? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#RfC: Can reviews through Film Threat's paid "Submission for Review system" be considered an independent source for determining notability?
|
| Director's cuts |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Director's cuts
|
| Notability Should be Expanded to Allow More Room for Niche Independent Films |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Notability Should be Expanded to Allow More Room for Niche Independent Films
|
| AfD for Leatherface |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#AfD for Leatherface
|
| RFC: Link the word “production” in NFF |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#RFC: Link the word “production” in NFF
|
| Box office results |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Box office results
|
| NFF doesn't make sense |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#NFF doesn't make sense
|
| Films in Principal Photography |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Films in Principal Photography
|
| RfC to amend this and related guidelines |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#RfC to amend this and related guidelines
|
| Casting About |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Casting About
|
| Notability of Second Glance (film) |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Notability of Second Glance (film)
|
| Simmba |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Simmba
|
| More on NFF |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#More on NFF
|
| Netflix? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Netflix?
|
| Other evidence of notability |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Other evidence of notability
|
| John Wick: Chapter 4 article discussion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#John Wick: Chapter 4 article discussion
|
| Golden Raspberrys |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#Golden Raspberrys
|
| A Soldier's Revenge |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 2#A Soldier's Revenge
|
| Niche films |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Niche films
|
| Future Film Comments |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Future Film Comments
|
| SNGs and GNG |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#SNGs and GNG
|
| Draft and notability |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Draft and notability
|
| Reviews |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Reviews
|
| Editing and revising the notability requirements |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Editing and revising the notability requirements
|
| RfC notice for establishing Wikipedia:Notability (television) as a guideline |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#RfC notice for establishing Wikipedia:Notability (television) as a guideline
|
| Films in Production (yet again) |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Films in Production (yet again)
|
| The Way Forward (NFF) |
43 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#The Way Forward (NFF)
|
| Excellent edit reverted for discussion |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Excellent edit reverted for discussion
|
| Treatment of not-notable films |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Treatment of not-notable films
|
| Language for Options 2 and 3 |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Language for Options 2 and 3
|
| Epidemic of upcoming film articles |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Epidemic of upcoming film articles
|
| RFC on Future Films |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#RFC on Future Films
|
| RfC: Should we replace the NFF policy with new text? |
47 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#RfC: Should we replace the NFF policy with new text?
|
| Ongoing RM discussion at Talk:The Noble Family |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Ongoing RM discussion at Talk:The Noble Family
|
| Post RfC. New text for the NFF notability sub-sub-guideline |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)/Archive 3#Post RfC. New text for the NFF notability sub-sub-guideline
|
| What is a "nationally-known critic"? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#What is a "nationally-known critic"?
|
| "Nationally-known critic" as it relates to films of India |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#"Nationally-known critic" as it relates to films of India
|
| Inherited Notability from Cast |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#Inherited Notability from Cast
|
| Proposing addition of more language regarding pre-release notability to NFF section |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#Proposing addition of more language regarding pre-release notability to NFF section
|
| MOS questions |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#MOS questions
|
| What about mentioning future films in BLP articles? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#What about mentioning future films in BLP articles?
|
| Notability on the basis of awards |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#Notability on the basis of awards
|
| Clarification on notability of films currently filming/in post-prod |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#Clarification on notability of films currently filming/in post-prod
|
| New section: Character articles NFILMCHAR |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#New section: Character articles NFILMCHAR
|
| Is ProductionList.com a reliable source for principal photography commencing? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#Is ProductionList.com a reliable source for principal photography commencing?
|
| Enforce WP:NFF; or delete it? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (films)#Enforce WP:NFF; or delete it?
|
