Wonnerup massacre

Wonnerup (Western Australia)

The Wonnerup massacre, also known as the Wonnerup "Minninup" massacre, was the killing of dozens of Wardandi Noongar people by European settlers in the vicinity of Wonnerup, Western Australia in February 1841.^[1] The massacre on Wardandi-Doonan land in the south-west of Western Australia took place after Gaywal/Gaywaar, a Wardandi Man, speared and killed George Layman, a settler at Wonnerup on 21 February 1841. The leaders of the punitive massacre were Layman's neighbours John Bussell and Captain John Molloy, resident magistrate of the district. Settlers from the Wonnerup, Capel, Busselton and Augusta area joined them to commit "one of the most bloodthirsty deeds ever committed by Englishmen".^[2]

Causes of conflict

The causes of conflict between colonial settlers and Wardandi Noongar people are many. One incident that caused a great deal of resentment between Gaywal and the settlers in the Busselton area was the treatment of Gaywal's son-in-law Nungundung. In February 1840 Nungundung and friends Duncock and Gerback killed Henry Campbell, a settler labourer living on the Collie River, because Campbell had badly beat Duncock. Henry Bull found this out after arresting the three young Wardandi men and questioning them.^[3] Academic Jessica White has said that this was because Campbell raped one of Gaywal's daughters^[4] but another source says that Gerback had committed this rape.^[5]The resident magistrate of the Leschenault district, Henry Bull flogged Nungundung, Duncock and Gerback for Campbell's death and let them go. Bussell was incensed at this lenient treatment and when he came across Nungundung in December 1840, he had him arrested, detained him for a while at his house Cattle Chosen and then sent him up to Perth for further punishment. There was much resentment at this arbitrary treatment of Nundundung amongst the Wardandi people after this incident and several threats were made to various settlers in the Busselton district during the following months.

Death of George Layman

On 21 February 1841 eighteen Wardandi people, including Gaywal, Milligan, and Gaywal's/Gaywar's son Woberdung were working for George Layman, helping with the threshing of wheat. White settler labourers who were also helping with the work were Martin Welch and John Dawson. Mary Bryan was working as a servant in the Layman cottage with Mrs Layman.

Indebong (known by setters as Dr Milligan)^[6] and Gaywal (also known as Gaywar and "Quibean" in various sources of the time) had an argument over the damper they were given as payment at the end of the day. The Aboriginal workers were standing around a fire outside the Layman cottage at this point. Indebong went to the cottage to complain to George Layman that Gaywal had taken his share of damper and that he had nothing for his work.^[7] Layman then came out of the cottage and told Gaywal to give the damper to Milligan, grabbing Gaywal's beard in the process, a great insult in Noongar culture.^[8] Gaywal then stepped back said "George!" and speared Layman, who ran into his cottage, calling for a gun, then laid down on the floor and died within ten minutes.^[9] Young Robert Heppingstone, son of Mary Bryan, later said that he also saw Wobudung throw a spear that went between Layman's legs.^[10] All the Noongar workers then ran away.

Oral history of the Waadandi Doonan people says that the conflict between Gaywal and Layman was over a Wardandi woman:

[Gaywal] wanted her back because that was his girl. That's the story they told, but the story was that he had a [Wardandi woman] there, and apparently, Mr Layman wouldn't let her go back … or something like that. That's what they said, but that was told to me by my grandmother...^[11]

Heppingstone was sent on horse to alert the Bussell family and Molloy of Layman's death. They were at the Bussell's house having a prayer meeting at the time as it was a Sunday. Milligan also went to the Bussell's house to report on what had happened.

First punitive expedition

On 23 February Dr Green came to ascertain the cause of Layman's death. Bussell and Molloy prepared warrants. They also prevailed on Bun-ni, a Noongar constable, to help, by holding him at the Bussell residence "until a conviction that he was true and zealous induced us to liberate him".^[12] Two young Noongar boys, described as spies, were caught at Wonnerup and told settlers that Gaywal had been speared in the thigh at Mollakup. The Bussells and Molloy went out at midnight towards Mollakup with Bun-ni as guide. The party comprised 13 people. After a day and a night, hiding in the sandhills and tracking a group of Noongar people, the settlers killed seven Noongar people and captured thirteen women and children. Gaywal was not part of the group of people killed or captured.^[12] Bun-ni was then sent out to kill Gaywal and came back reporting that he had done this, but this was not so.

On 26 February Fanny Bussell noted in her diary: "In the evening John, Capt. Molloy and Mr. Northy returned. Capt. Molloy drank tea here. 7 natives killed. Gaywal supposed to be wounded."^[13]

Although John Garrett Bussell and Captain John Molloy reported that five (not seven) people were killed, in fact a larger massacre occurred. Warren Bert Kimberly wrote an account of it in 1897 after talking to colonial settlers and Noongar survivors who remembered what happened. Kimberly stated that Molloy gave orders that no women or children were to be killed. The majority of Noongar people were now hiding around Lake Minninup. Then:

Native after native was shot, and the survivors, knowing that orders had been given not to shoot the women, crouched on their knees, covered their bodies with their bokas, and cried, ‘Me yokah’ (woman). The white men had no mercy. The black men were killed by dozens, and their corpses lined the route of march of the avengers.^[14]

Oral history of the Waadandi Doonan people also says:

The first mob was caught, was just the other side of the Capel River (Mollakup). When I was a little boy we found some skulls up there. One of them had a bullet in it, it had gone through the forehead and just sticking out the back. There was quite a few with holes knocked in them in the skulls and the next mob they caught was at Muddy Lake (Mininup) that’s this side of Bunbury and then they chased the other right through Australind somewhere around Australind area they caught up they killed some more there and the rest got away.^[15]

Second and third punitive expeditions

The Bussells and other settlers then returned home. At that time Symmons, the Protector of Aborigines arrived and apparently was roundly abused by the settlers. The Noongar prisoners told the Bussells and Molloy that Gaywal was retreating westward. A small party led by Vernon Bussell and three other settlers went to Mollakup, and took a group of Wardandi people hostage. On 27 February Vernon sent a message saying "bring ammunition we have none".^[16] Charles Bussell was sent out with weapons and reinforcements from Cattle Chosen, and Alfred Pickmore Bussell set out with another group of settlers from Wonnerup. When Alfred Bussell's party met Vernon's party, the Wardandi hostages ran away in fear and two Wardandi men were shot.^[17] John Garrett Bussell and his brothers then went out in a third punitive expedition, heading south to find Gaywal. They returned two days later saying that Bun-ni was not co-operating, so they would wait for Wardandi people to give Gaywal up.^[18]

Death of Gaywal

On 7 March, Gaywal was killed by Lieutenant Northey's servant Kelly. He was at the forefront of a party that had gone out to continue the hunt for Gaywal. Later on, Molloy set up a trap for Woberdung and his brother Kenny on the boat of Captain Plaskett. They were then taken to Rottnest Island to be incarcerated.^[19] In January 2019, a statue of Gaywal was unveiled in Busselton; the fifth sculpture created by artist Greg James and showcased by the City of Busselton on Queen Street for the Settlement Art Project.^[20]

Cover-up of events

This massacre was later "systematically downplayed" by settlers despite large numbers of Noongar people being unaccounted for after the event. A descendant of John Dawson has stated that something dreadful occurred "which seriously affected the moral of the whole community".^[21] Governor John Hutt was in charge of the Swan River Colony at the time and the settler community closed ranks against further enquiry. Molloy's typed up letterbook from February 1841 contains no recorded letters, although he and John Garrett Bussell did submit two reports to the colonial secretary, stating that, overall, eight Wardandi people were killed in the three punitive events. Fanny Bussell's diary of that period in February is missing four pages, although this has been attributed by Edward Shann to wanting to conceal the argument with Symmons that occurred at the time.^[22]

References

^ "Colonial Frontier Massacres in Australia, 1788-1930". Centre For 21st Century Humanities, University of Newcastle (Australia). Retrieved 2 January 2021.
^ Kimberley, Warren Burt. "History of West Australia by, published in 1897, chapter 13, page 116". Retrieved 2 January 2021.
^ Letter from Henry Bull to Colonial Secretary, SROWA CSR Vol 85 Folio 79, 1840, State Library of Western Australia
^ White, Jessica. "'Paper Talk': Testimony and Forgetting in South West Western Australia, Home Journal of the Association for the Study of Australian Literature, Vol 17, No 1 (2017). p. 6". Retrieved 31 October 2020.
^ Jennings, Rodger (1983). Busselton - outstation on the Vasse. Shire of Busselton. p. 185
^ ""Magistrate's Court Bunbury May 10, 1850," Inquirer (Perth, WA : 1840 - 1855), Wednesday 29 May 1850, page 3".
^ Deposition of John Dawson signed by JG Bussell and J Molloy 23 Feb 1841, CSR Vol 100, Battye Library.
^ White, Jessica. "'Paper Talk': Testimony and Forgetting in South West Western Australia, Home Journal of the Association for the Study of Australian Literature, Vol 17, No 1 (2017). p. 2". Retrieved 31 October 2020.
^ Deposition of Anne Bryan signed by JG Bussell and J Molloy CSR 1841 02 23 Vol 100 128, Battye Library.
^ Depositions of Alfred Green and John Heppingstone signed by JG Bussell and J Molloy 841 02 24 CSR Vol 100 129, Battye Library.
^ "Interview with Phyllis Ronan 1987-Transcription-SLWA OH2522/2 Interviewed by Margaret Tickle." State Library of Western Australia, 1987.
^ ^a ^b Report by J Molloy and J Bussell 27 Feb 1841, CSR Vol 101 93-4, Battye Library.
^ Edward Shann. "Cattle Chosen, Chapter 8, Wild Justice".
^ Kimberley, Warren Burt. "History of West Australia by, published in 1897, chapter 13, page 116". Retrieved 31 October 2020.
^ Collard, Len (1994). A Nyungar Interpretation of Ellensbrook and Wonnerup Homesteads. East Perth: Heritage Council of Western Australia, 1994, p. 61. Heritage Council of Western Australia.
^ Molloy and J Bussell report to CSO 10 March 1841, CSR Vol 101 99, Battye Library.
^ Molloy and J Bussell report to CSO 10 March 1841, CSR Vol 101 99, Battye Library.
^ Molloy and J Bussell report to CSO 10 March 1841, CSR Vol 101 99, Battye Library.
^ Letter from JG Bussell to Colonial Secretary 25th March 1841, CSR Vol 100, 106 Battye Library.
^ "Sculpture showcase". The West Australian. 25 January 2019. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
^ Hardwick, Gil. "'The Irish R. M.: Capt. John Molloy of the Vasse (Paper in: The Irish in Western Australia. Reece, Bob (ed.).)'; Studies in Western Australian history, (2000) 20 1, pp.1-20, pp. 11,12".
^ Edward Shann. "Cattle Chosen, Chapter 7, Relations with the Natives".