Wikipedia

2024 Indonesian local election law protests

The 2024 Indonesian local election law protests, also known as Emergency Alert for Indonesia (Indonesian: Peringatan Darurat Indonesia) or Indonesian Democratic Emergency (Indonesian: Indonesia Darurat Demokrasi),[28] are ongoing public and student-led demonstrations against the House of Representatives for drafting a bill on regional head elections (Pilkada) that contradicts the Constitutional Court's ruling and power, intended to regulate the 2024 Indonesian local elections.

2024 Indonesian local election law protests
Protestors in front of the Parliament gate
Protestors climb over a collapsed parliament fence
Protestors preparing to face tear gas
Student demonstrations in Senayan, Jakarta.
Date22–27 August 2024 (2024-08-22 – 2024-08-27)
Location
Indonesia (Demonstrations in Jakarta, Yogyakarta, Bandung, Padang, Surakarta, Surabaya, Semarang, Malang, Makassar, Tasikmalaya, Jambi, Bandar Lampung, Ambon, Bengkulu, Cirebon, Kendari, Palembang, Samarinda, Bekasi, Banjarmasin, Balikpapan, Palu, Gorontalo, Mataram, Kupang, Pekanbaru, Banda Aceh, Palangka Raya, Kediri, Bukittinggi, Langsa, Majene, Luwuk, Bogor, Lhokseumawe, Denpasar, Manokwari, Sorong, Pontianak, and Kuningan)
Caused by
Goals
  • Cancellation of the ratification of the fourth amendment to the Law on General Elections for Governors, Regents, and Mayors.
  • Implementation of the 2024 Regional Head General Election in accordance with Constitutional Court Decisions No. 60/PUU-XXII/2024 and No. 70/PPU-XXII/2024
MethodsDemonstration, internet activism, student activism, protest, protest art, sit-in, vandalism
Resulted inThe ratification of the bill by the House of Representatives cancelled[1]
Parties

Protesters and organisations:
(no centralised authority)

Lead figures

No centralised leadership
Political figures

Government

Casualties and losses

122 injured

460 arrested

  • 301 in the Parliament area[18]
  • 159 outside the Parliament[19][20]

14 injured

2 journalists injured[26][27]

The hashtags #KawalPutusanMK or #KawalKeputusanMK (Escort MK's Decision), #TolakPolitikDinasti (Reject Political Dynasty), and #TolakPilkadaAkal2an (Reject Manipulated Local Elections) became widely popular on social media. This online movement culminated in nationwide demonstrations on 22 August 2024, as people took to the streets to express their discontent.[29]

Background

edit

Laws of Indonesia and Indonesian Election Laws

edit

Major Indonesian rules come in different forms and follow a certain hierarchy as defined by Act No. 12 of 2011 (amended several times most recently with Act No. 13 of 2022). The power of each types of rules is in accordance with the hierarchy, and sitting at the top of the hierarchy is the Indonesian Constitution. While there exists other forms of rules beyond the ones in the hierarchy, such rules only have the force of binding if it is ordered by higher rules or established by an authority granted by other rules.[b] One type of major rules is Acts and one type of other rules is General Elections Commission Rules (Peraturan KPU).

Since 2017, elections for public offices in Indonesia are regulated by two separate Acts, both of which are continuously amended: Act No. 7 of 2017 (amended with Government Regulation in-lieu-of Act No. 1 of 2022, as ratified by Act No. 7 of 2023), known as General Election Law,[31] for the presidential and legislative elections (DPR, DPD, and DPRD); and Act No. 1 of 2015 (amended with Act No. 10 of 2016), known as Local Election Law,[32] for the regional heads (governors, mayors, and regents). Further provisions to implement the Acts are governed through various forms of rules, notably through General Election Commission Rules.

One way to amend rules in Indonesia is through a Supreme Court or Constitutional Court ruling. The Constitutional Court has the authority to test whether an Act violates the Indonesian Constitution, while the authority to test whether any forms of rules under Acts violate certain Acts is granted to the Supreme Court.[c]

October 2023 Constitutional Court ruling

edit

On 16 October 2023, in response to the case number 90/PUU-XXI/2023 filed by a student and a self-acclaimed fan of Gibran Rakabuming Raka (President Joko Widodo's son) named Almas Tsaqibbirru, the Constitutional Court amended the General Election Law (Act No. 7 of 2017) to allow people under the minimum age of 40 years old to stand for the presidency or vice-presidency as long as they are currently or have previously held a public office that is elected through elections, including regional head elections. This allowed the 36-year-old Gibran, who at the time was the Mayor of Surakarta, to take part in the 2024 presidential election as a vice presidential candidate just 3 days before the registration period started.[33] The ruling attracted criticism because the then Chief Justice Anwar Usman is President Widodo's brother-in-law and Gibran's uncle.[34]

On November 2023, The Constitutional Court Ethics Council (MKMK) ruled that Anwar Usman had committed serious ethical violations during his handling of the October 2023 case. Due to his actions, the court ordered his removal from the Chief Justice position. However, the court rejected the request to carry out an assessment on, cancel, correct, or review the controversial ruling.[35]

Gibran himself later became the running-mate of Defence Minister Prabowo Subianto and together they won the 2024 election becoming the president and vice president-elect.[36]

May 2024 Supreme Court ruling

edit

On May 29 2024, responding to the petition number 23 P/HUM/2024 from the Garuda Party, the Supreme Court decided to amend Article 4 Section 1 of the General Elections Commission Rules (PKPU) No. 9 of 2020 on the Nominations for the Election of Governor and Deputy Governor, Regent and Deputy Regent and/or Mayor and Deputy mayor. The court stated that the provision is not in accordance with the Local Election Law (Act No. 1 of 2015) as revised by Act No. 10 of 2016, and changed the age requirement for governor and vice governor candidates from 30 years old calculated during the determination of the candidate pair to 30 years old calculated during the inauguration. This ruling once again benefitted President Widodo's son, this time Kaesang Pangarep. Before the ruling, Kaesang was unqualified for the governorship or vice-governorship as he would still be 29 years old on September 22, the candidate pair determination date, and will only turn 30 on December 25. Thus, moving the calculation to the inauguration date will allow him to reach 30 before the calculation date and make him qualified for the registration.[37][38]

August 2024 Constitutional Court rulings and the Local election law revision controversy

edit
 
Undang-Undang Republik Indonesia Nomor 10 Tahun 2016

On August 20 2024, the Constitutional Court read their decisions on several cases, two of which are cases number 60/PUU-XXII/2024 and 70/PUU-XXII/2024.

The Constitutional Court's position is the ultimate arbiter of a regulation's conflict with the Basic Law.[39] The House of Representatives (DPR) refused to implement the Constitutional Court's decision by stipulating that the age limit for regional head candidates would only take effect after the inauguration of the 2024 election winners, in accordance with the May 2024 Supreme Court's decision on case No. 23 P/HUM/2024. This interpretation contradicts the Constitutional Court's decision on case No. 70/PUU-XXII/2024, which stipulates that the age limit for regional head candidates takes effect at the time of determining the candidates.[40]

The House of Representatives also only partially followed the Constitutional Court's decision on case number 60/PUU-XXII/2024 regarding the removal of the party seat requirement in the Regional House of Representatives to nominate regional head candidates. The drafted Rancangan Undang-Undang (RUU) PIlkada (Regional Head Election Bill) only applies the removal to parties that did not have seats.[41] On the other hand, the DPR immediately approved when General Elections Commission implemented the October 2023 Constitutional Court's decision on case number 90/PUU-XXI/2023 into KPU regulations related to relaxing the age requirements in the 2024 Indonesian presidential election.[42]

This action was then formulated into the Regional Head Election Bill in a relatively short period of time.[43] The proposal is widely considered to only benefit certain candidates who are related to the Widodo family,[44] perceived as the shift of Indonesian democracy into a state of "monarchy" and nepotism.[45] The buzz around this topic caused the hashtag #KawalPutusanMK and Indonesia Emergency Alert to emerge as one of the trending topics on social media X.[46]

Party reactions

edit

Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P) was the only faction to openly oppose this move by the Badan Legislasi (Baleg) of DPR (Legislation Committee of the House of Representatives). PDI-P has attempted to stop the bill by rejecting its proposal during the Legislation Committee meeting and being absent for the plenary meeting so that the meeting did not meet the quorum. The meeting to pass the Regional Head Election Bill would then be postponed, and ultimately cancelled.[47]

Meanwhile, National Awakening Party (PKB) exhibited ambiguity regarding the Regional Head Election Bill. This was evident from a statement by Muhaimin Iskandar, the Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives, who claimed to be unaware of the agenda for drafting the bill.[48] Additionally, Luqman Hakim from the PKB faction did not attend the plenary session.[49] However, despite these mixed signals, the PKB faction, in general, supported the bill.[50]

Gelora Party has also taken an ambiguous stance on this issue. Although initially favorable towards the bill, the party's position became uncertain after Fahri Hamzah, a prominent party figure, expressed his disappointment with the Constitutional Court's decision, which he believed went against the party's demands. Gelora Party considered suing the Constitutional Court, aiming to secure the right for parties without seats in the House of Representatives to nominate their own regional leaders.[51]

Kaesang and Erina's lifestyle

edit

Although not directly related, Kaesang Pangarep and his wife, Erina Gudono, drew condemnation from Indonesian netizens because of their luxury travels at the time when the demonstrations occurred.[52] Kaesang and his wife allegedly took the luxury private jet Gulfstream G650 from Jakarta to Los Angeles for holiday before taking Erina to Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, for her Master's studies.[53] An investigation by The Straits Times revealed that the plane was formerly delivered to Singaporean based company, Garena, on July 15, 2021, before it was bought by the Bank of Utah’s trust on 29 December 2022. Garena's parent company, SEA Ltd did not comment by request for more information.[54] Garena was one of the main sponsors to the Persis Solo football club, which is co-owned by Kaesang Pangarep.[55]

Erina also shared Instagram stories of her luxury travels in the United States, which included the purchase of a lobster roll that cost an estimated Rp400,000[56] and a baby stroller costing Rp21 million.[54] These raised the ire of netizens,[52] leading to Erina being compared with Marie Antoinette.[57] With many netizens requoting the words of "let them eat cake!" attributed to her[58][59] and comparing the lobster roll that Kaesang gave to his wife with the salary of some honorary teachers, which is equivalent to or less than Rp400,000.[60] Indonesian netizens proceeded to send mass emails to the University of Pennsylvania, imploring them to revoke Erina's partial scholarship.[61] Indonesian netizens were then quick to find out where the two were staying in the United States after another two portraits taken by Erina Gudono were found to closely match the interiors of the Four Seasons Hotel at Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas and the Four Seasons Beverly Wilshire Hotel in Los Angeles before heading to "Philly."[62] With the cheapest room at Mandalay Bay costing Rp29.96 million per night and at Beverly Wilshire around Rp16 million per night, Suara estimated that just the amount spent on one night at Beverly Wilshire could have been enough to pay the salaries of at least 40 honorary teachers in Indonesia.[63] Erina herself was once considered as a candidate to be the Regent of Sleman.[64]

A video surfaced showing Kaesang and Erina disembarking from a private jet in Surakarta, confirmed the type of aircraft they were using being a Gulfstream G650. The footage also captured the group moving a large number of shopping items from the United States and loading them into a Toyota Alphard that had been parked on the apron. The video sparked outrage among netizens, who were angered by the fact that the items seemed to bypass inspection, immigration, and customs procedures. Nirwala Dwi Heriyanto, the Director of Communication and User Guidance of Customs Services at the Directorate General of Customs and Excise (Bea Cukai), stated that all items must undergo customs checks, with no exemptions for private planes except on domestic flights. He also mentioned that an investigation into the matter was underway.[65][66][67] In response to the criticisms from netizens regarding the flight, Silfester Matutina, Deputy General Manager of the Prabowo-Gibran National Campaign Team, defended Kaesang's use of the private jet by stating that "Many people also use private jets."[68]

Indonesian emergency warning

edit
 
A fictional blue Emergency Alert System (EAS) screen, conceptualized by the EAS Indonesia Concept Youtube channel, was widely circulated prior to and during the protests

‘Peringatan Darurat’ (English: Emergency Alert) is an internet meme that became the impetus for the Regional Head Election Bill rally on 22 August 2024. This phenomenon is in the form of uploaded images, screenshots, and short videos with a dark blue background with the Garuda Pancasila symbol and white emergency warning text, which resembles Emergency Alert Systems used in several countries. The meme became known as the Blue Garuda. The image comes from the short film with the analog horror genre entitled ‘EAS Indonesia Concept (24/10/1991), ANM-021 (Mesem) - First Encounter’ uploaded by the EAS Indonesia Concept YouTube channel.[69][70] The short film features an air raid siren and a jingle taken from a 1970s Soviet Georgian television as its signature sound effect.

This phenomenon was initiated by the upload of the meme on X by the @BudiBukanIntel account on Wednesday (21/08) at 08.12 WIB.[71][72] This post was a response to the post by the @PJalawira account as a joke, to an image with the hypothetical story of the occupation of government offices by the military due to an "ongoing constitutional crisis". This discussion occurred during the Legislation Committee meeting which was discussing the Regional Head Election Bill, considered to be a violation of the constitution.[70] Subsequently, this ‘emergency warning’ image was widely used by social media users as a symbol of protest against the DPR for violating the constitution. Public figures such as Najwa Shihab, Bivitri Susanti [id], Joko Anwar, and Pandji Pragiwaksono also shared the ‘emergency alert’ image on various social media channels. Community accounts, NGOs, campuses, and mass group accounts also used this image to gather, consolidate, and provide support for protests on the ground.[73][74][75][76] Garuda Biru's post was later amplified by artists by releasing graphic art with a dark blue background.[77][78] The public referred to the dark blue color in the "Emergency Warning" meme as "resistance blue" (Indonesian: biru perlawanan). Later, this symbol was juxtaposed with the light blue color used by the Advanced Indonesia Coalition and the Prabowo-Gibran 2024 Campaign that referred by the public as "oligarch blue" (Indonesian: biru oligarki).[79][80][81]

Garuda Biru was also used by musicians when they performed on stage at various music festivals, such as Hindia, Kunto Aji, Danilla Riyadi, BAALE, Reality Club, Feel Koplo, as well as Juicy Luicy, and Adrian Khalif.[82][83][84]

Issues

edit

In general, the main issue raised during the demonstrations is were criticisms of the DPR regarding the plan to ratify the new Local Elections Bill, because it defies the Constitutional Court's decision. However, other issues were also raised, varying at each demonstration points and location, such as:

Protests

edit

Political protest

edit

The spread of the "Peringatan Darurat" message was used as a rallying call for demonstrations at several points across Indonesia. Among many other Indonesian cities, these protests were mostly initiated by university students in their respective provinces, with the protests turning violent and several protests ending up with students occupying local government buildings.[87][88]

Protest in Jakarta

edit
 
A miniature of guillotine, with the face of Jokowi resting below, at the protest. Plastered with Anti-Jokowi papers. One reads, "At least be ashamed!"

On 22 August 2024, a demonstration in front of the House of Representatives was attended by thousands of people, which led to 3,200 officers being deployed for security.[89] A similar demonstration also took place in front of the Constitutional Court Building.[90] At 14:20 WIB, the crowd broke down the right gate of the House of Representatives Building.[91] Coincidentally, the 828th Thursday Action (Indonesian: Aksi Kamisan ke-828) in front of the Istana Negara also became a mass gathering point.[92] This protest carried a replica of the guillotine knife that symbolises resistance to monarchy, first seen in the French revolution.[93] This protest was not only attended by masses of workers and students, but also by celebrities such as film activists Joko Anwar and Reza Rahadian;[94] solo comedians such as Arie Kriting, Mamat Alkatiri, Abdur Arsyad, Ananta Rispo, Rigen Rakelna,[95] and Bintang Emon.[96] Several figures such as Halida Hatta (daughter of President Hatta), Tom Lembong (former Indonesian Minister of Trade), Mudji Sutrisno [id], also attended the protest.

Habiburrokhman (wearing white shirt) announcing the cancellation of the bill revision. Habiburrokhman was constantly thrown with water bottles while standing at the command truck.

At noon, at 2:20 PM., the crowd tore down the right gate of the House of Representatives,[97] followed by the collapse of the rear gate by another group of protesters on 5:30 PM.[98] One of the members of the House of Representatives, Habiburokhman, was hit by a bottle thrown by the protesters.[99] The protest lasted into the night and police were recorded as beating, using tear gas, and firing water cannons to deal with the crowd. [100][101] Tempo, Narasi, and IDN journalists were mistreated for trying to cover protesters being beaten by the authorities and were asked to delete their video footage.[102][103][104] The director of Lokataru, Delpedro Marhaen, was also mistreated and arrested.[105]

By around 6 PM, as most of the initial protesters, who were university students, had left the area, a second group composed of high school students arrived, clad with wooden spears and masks, and clashed with the police. The second crowd also damaged two bus stops in front of the building.[106]

Another demonstration was held on 23 August 2024, centred at the KPU RI Building.[107]

Protest in Java

edit

While in Bandung, the protest was held in front of the West Java DPRD building.[108] At 17:30, the DPRD Building fence was torn down and the demonstration turned violent.[109] One journalist was mistreated because he was accused of being an intel[110] and one student lost an eyeball due to stone throwing from the security forces.[111] In Tasikmalaya, the demonstration was characterised by the burning of several facilities in the Tasikmalaya City DPRD building.[112] In Bogor, the protest was held at Tugu Kujang.[113] In Cirebon, one student and one policeman were injured during a demonstration in front of the Cirebon City DPRD Building.[114]

In Yogyakarta, the protest was attended by thousands of people, clad with black clothing and masks in attempt to emulate the sucesses and symbolism of the 2019 Hong Kong Protestors, starting at the Abu Bakar Ali Parking Lot, walking to the Zero Kilometer Point of Yogyakarta City, and stopping in front of the Yogyakartan DPRD Building.[115]

In Semarang, the protest in front of the Central Java Regional House of Representatives (DPRD Jawa Tengah) Building ended in disorder after the masses forced to enter by attempting to collapse the building's entrance gate, with the police retaliating to disperse thousands of masses with the use of tear gas and water cannons.[116][117][118] 26 protesters were injured, with 18 of those protesters hospitalized.[119]

In Surabaya, the demonstration was held in front of the Heroes Monument.[120] In Surakarta, the demonstration was held in front of the City Hall Building.[121] Some students symbolized their protests in walking backwards. According to the coordinator of the Student Executive Body of Greater Surakarta, Rozin Afianto said that the reverse walk as a symbolism for a "Backward Indonesia Cabinet".[122] In Malang, thousands of protesters took to the streets, around the Tugu Malang Roundabout area, turning traffic in the city to a standstill.[123]

Protest in Sumatra

edit

In Padang, a demonstration was held in front of the West Sumatra DPRD Building.[124] In Bukittinggi, a rally in front of the Bukittinggi City DPRD Building was held by hundreds of people on 23 August 2024 under heavy rain.[125] In Lampung, a rally was held the night before, wearing Money Heist costumes.[126] In South Sumatra, a rally was held at Simpang Lima by hundreds of students wearing masks of politicians such as Joko Widodo, Bahlil Lahadalia, Yusril Ihza Mahendra, Prabowo Subianto, and Bobby Nasution. The protest also included a coffin.[127] In Jambi, thousands of students marched from Bank Indonesia junction to the parliament building in Telanai.[128] The protest ended in chaos after demonstrators were beaten by police. Three people fainted and four were injured.[129] A demonstration in Bengkulu was marred by the mistreatment of students by DPRD security officers when they tried to disperse the crowd. A video of a security guard stomping on a student caused widespread anger.[130] A similar protest took place at the Aceh DPRA, Banda Aceh, which was attended by thousands of students.[131] This protest ended in chaos and five people were arrested.[132] Another demonstration in a different city in aceh also took place, in front of the Lhokseumawe DPRK led to thousands of students clashing with the authorities.[133]

Protest in Sulawesi

edit

In Makassar, a protest of thousands of people took to the streets to protest the ratification of the Pilkada Bill.[134] There was a tyre burning protest in this demonstration.[135] The demonstration was forcibly disbanded after it was discovered that First Lady, Iriana Jokowi, was going to pass through the road that was being used for demonstrations.[136] On 26 August, in retaliation toward student protests, a counter protest by surrounding residents in AP Pettarani street, destroyed UNM facilities.[137] In Kendari, thousands of people consisting of students and journalists demonstrated in front of the Southeast Sulawesi DPRD building.[138] The protest in Palu was carried out on 23 August 2024 in front of the Central Sulawesi DPRD Building.[139] In Luwuk, the protesters, most of whom were students from Tompotika University, held a long march from their campus to the Banggai Regency DPRD office.[140]

In Majene, demonstrators consisting of students managed to broke into the Majene Regency DPRD office and destroyed all the facilities inside. They forced their way into the plenary session room and into the council leadership. Several students were reported injured after the riots.[141]

Protest in Nusa Tenggara and Bali

edit

In Kupang, a sit-in demonstration took place in front of the NTT KPU office.[142] In Mataram, the protest ended in chaos after thousands of students in front of the West Nusa Tenggara DPRD Building refused to be dispersed by the police. Forced dispersal was then carried out with tear gas and water cannons.[143]

In Denpasar, the protest was carried out on 23 August 2024 followed by student representatives from various universities in Bali, external student organisations, NGOs in Bali, Non-government organizations in Bali (as the party that assisted from a legal perspective), to the general public.[144]

Protest in Maluku and Papua

edit

In Ambon, the protest ended in chaos as protesters began to break the glass windows of the building, after the request of the protest masses who were members of the Pattimura Student Alliance to meet DPRD members from the Advanced Indonesia Plus coalition party was rejected because none of the DPRD members came.[145] In Manokwari, the protest was carried out in front of the West Papua DPRD Building.[146] A similar demonstration was held in Sorong, precisely Taman Sorong, by carrying out a silent protest.[147]

Protest in Kalimantan

edit

In Banjarmasin, thousands of people from various campus elements occupied the South Kalimantan DPRD in a demonstration.[148][149] While in Samarinda, thousands of people gathered in front of the East Kalimantan DPRD Building to demand the cancellation of the Pilkada Bill and the acceleration of the passing of the Asset Forfeiture Bill.[150] Although their representatives have met DPRD members, the mediation failed and the protests became increasingly violent, as a result, two policemen were injured due to Molotov cocktails.[24] The protest in Balikpapan at the Balikpapan DPRD building turned violent after students pushed each other with the police.[151] A number of students took part in the democracy emergency protest at the West Kalimantan Provincial DPRD in Pontianak, West Kalimantan, on Friday 23 August 2024.[152] In Palangkaraya, the protest of hundreds of students ended in chaos, after the desire to present the Chairman of the Central Kalimantan DPRD was not fulfilled. The masses rejected the proposed conditions, namely that only representatives are allowed to enter the DPR building and have their aspirations heard.[153] In Tarakan, the protest coincided with the inauguration of the elected city parliament members in the 2024 Indonesian general election.[154] This protest later also turned violent, resulting in 11 police and one student injured.[155]

Police brutality

edit
 
Police and protestors clash at the House of Representatives building. Visible; non-armed protesters getting hit by a baton and an officer slamming his riot shield to protestors in the background.

The police were widely criticised for excessive actions in dealing with protesters, including beatings, the use of tear gas and water cannons, to even kidnappings.[156][157] One of them was the police brutality against protesters in Palu, where a student suffered a torn ear.[14] A total of 20 people were named as suspects in the vandalism of the DPR RI building fence.[158] On the other hand, a number of parties such as Haidar Alwi from the Haidar Alwi Institute appreciated the security measures taken during the demonstration,[159] where he is known as a Jokowi loyalist and pro-government.[160]

According to the Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation, in Jakarta, the police have started to hunt down students. 11 demonstrators had been confirmed to have been arrested by the police, and one person was publicly doxed without cause by the police. In addition to also received 26 reports with actions in the form of violence, doxing and kidnappings. Whilst also receiving information that hundreds of demonstrators were arrested while on route to the location of the demonstration. The organization has long since advocated for the protestors and urged Indonesian Police to stop committing violence.[161]

Additionally, the Indonesian Army, specifically Kodam Jayakarta, was also involved in violence against protestors.[162]

Online activism

edit

As a form of protest against Joko Widodo's political dynasty, some social media users and demonstrators called Jokowi by his birth name, "Mulyono", which was changed in a ruwatan [jv] ceremony to cleanse diseases according to the Javanese tradition.[163] This action is comparable to deadnaming and is believed by some netizens to be a taboo that can bring bad luck to the owner of the birth name superstitiously.[164][165] Some netizens and demonstrators also insulted Joko Widodo with the male pregnancy (mpreg) meme through digital[166] and printed[167] protest arts which was previously a trending topic on Twitter to mock patriarchal men behavior through their fragile masculinity.[168]

On 22 August 2024 while the protests was taking place, businessman and celebrity Raffi Ahmad went to accompany Gibran Rakabuming Raka, the vice president-elect and eldest son of President Joko Widodo, to West Bandung.[169] Later in the evening, via social media Instagram, Raffi Ahmad uploaded a screenshot containing the statement of the Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives regarding the cancellation of the ratification of the Pilkada Bill, which was also affixed with the Prabowo-Gibran 2024 Campaign logo. This upload drew criticism from the public because it was considered to be just an order and did not really care about the aspirations of the community regarding the rejection of the Pilkada Bill. This was based on his attitude which contrasted with several other celebrities who attended the protests. Then on 23 August 2024, Raffi Ahmad uploaded a statement of his political stance supporting the decision of the Constitutional Court.[170] This again drew criticism and was followed by a boycott call against him, Nagita Slavina, and RANS Entertainment. The boycott call was based on his closeness to the government and his support during the 2024 Indonesian election campaign for the Prabowo-Gibran pair, a candidate who is considered the successor to Joko Widodo's political dynasty.[171] Other Prabowo-Gibran supporting celebrities such as Gading Marten, Atta Halilintar, and Kiky Saputri were also targeted by the boycott.[172][173] In response to the boycott call, Pandji Pragiwaksono asked the public not to politicise the issue and embrace those who want to join despite coming from different camps.[173]

Social media users highlighted the absence of Kiky Saputri, who is known for commenting on national political issues, amidst the presence of several solo comedians at the rally. Through X social media, Kiky Saputri said that she was unable to attend the rally due to work reasons and still supported the rally. She stated that even though she did not attend the rally, she would ‘fight through the inside track’ by communicating directly to the relevant parties.[174] This later received comments from netizens who felt that Kiky Saputri did not have enough influence to be able to convey aspirations personally and her closeness to figures in the government only occurred because she was employed with her status as an internet celebrity.[175] Kiky Saputri also said that she was of the view that the Constitutional Court's decision could not be contested, as when the Constitutional Court issued Constitutional Court Decision No. 90/PUU-XXI/2023 which made Gibran Rakabuming Raka able to run as a vice presidential candidate even though he had not met the minimum age limit to participate in the 2024 elections.[176]

Social media users throwing harsh criticisms on Kaesang's lifestyle also results in insults being thrown to Erina Gudono mostly regarding to her personal hygiene.[177][178] Rumors regarding to her personal hygiene arose from a picture of her standing next to a student who tried to cover his nose.[179] As Erina will start her masters degree in University of Pennsylvania, social media users throw criticisms at her learning about social justice, calling her insensitive and hypocrite, stating that the 5th principle of the Pancasila has been violated by Jokowi's perceived actions to backslide democracy.[180] Due to personal criticisms and insults thrown at her, many also questioned Erina's mental health facing such issues.[181] Some users also congratulated Kaesang's ex-girlfriends for not marrying him as Kaesang and Erina became a target of insult by the public due to their hedonistic lifestyle.[182]

Impact

edit

Political

edit
 
Tape art displaying the words, "The DPR are lackeys of Jokowi" (DPR Kacung Jokowi)

Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) reversed its position on the bill and instead supported its cancellation "in accordance to the people's voice and demands".[183] Similarly, PKB issued a statement of gratitude for the cancellation of the bill, signalling that people's aspirations are still being heard.[184] Democratic Party published a press release on behalf of the party's faction in DPR, stating it would not proceed with the bill.[185] Sufmi Dasco from Gerindra Party stated that the decision of the Constitutional Court (MK) will still be implemented, but the drafted Regional Head Election Bill can be implemented in the next election period.

Former Ministry of Law and Human Rights Hamid Awaludin reported Prabowo Subianto's anger on the sudden maneuvers to change the local election law.[186] Gerindra indirectly either denied or confirm that Prabowo was very furious,[187] but then announced that Prabowo wants to prioritize democracy and obeying laws and regulations.[188]

With the Constitutional Court's ruling upheld, regional parliament threshold of 20% in the 2024 Indonesian local elections has been nullified and more parties are able to field their own candidate pairings in the election.[189] In the roundup of the election candidacies, the Advanced Indonesia Coalition had managed to assemble a grand coalition supporting candidates such as in Jakarta, West Java, Central Java, East Java, and North Sumatra, along with several cities and regencies across Indonesia and Gerindra politician Ahmad Muzani opened up that there are indications that parties will abandon the coalition in favor of their own candidates.[189] PKB chairman Muhaimin Iskandar states that his party will not always be endorsing candidates from the Advanced Indonesia Coalition.[190] The ruling also opens up PDI-P chances to nominate their own candidates albeit in a lower treshold[191] and potentially breaking the coalition up in some parts of Indonesia.[189] According to Aditya Permana of the Algoritma Research and Consulting, this ruling aims to widen the candidate field and to minimize the possibility to run against an empty ballot box.[189]

On 24 August 2024, Gerindra announced that they will recommend Vice Governor Taj Yasin Maimoen to stand for reelection as Ahmad Luthfi's running mate instead of Kaesang Pangarep.[192] Kaesang was reportedly gearing up to run as Ahmad Luthfi's partner in the 2024 Central Java gubernatorial election a few days before the protests occurred.[193] Even after the protests has begun and the House of Representatives reversed the bill, the lawyer in Jakarta High Court states that Kaesang has prepared 3 documents required for him to stand as a candidate, which are a certificate stating that he had never been a defendant, a certificate stating that his voting rights on the voters list had not been revoked and a certificate stating that he had no debts, which gave skepticisms on whether or not the House of Representatives is really serious on repealing their draft bill on local elections.[194] Kaesang later suspended his preparations according to the PSI administration team.[195] PSI further backpedaled by stating that Kaesang had no interest in running in the 2024 Pilkada since the beginning and that he "preferred to concentrate on business and taking care of his family."[196] Despite the setback, the media still report that Kaesang could have run for mayor or regent due to the lower minimum age requirement of 25 instead of 30 for governorship.[197][198]

Individually, politician Wanda Hamidah announced her resignation from Golkar. She stated that the decision was taken because she "does not want to be on the wrong side of history" and that she loves her country "too much".[199]

Economic

edit

As protests took place, the IDX Composite (IHSG) fell to 7,497.[200] The rupiah currency weakened to 15,615.00 IDR per 1 United States dollar (USD),[201] and exchange rate into the euro currency spiked to 17,460.00 IDR per 1 euro (EUR).[citation needed] Chairman of the Indonesian Hotel and Restaurant Association, Hariyadi B Sukamdani, is more concerned about the cause of this action. He feels that political intervention in the legal sphere can have an impact on legal certainty issues that can trigger greater effects if not handled properly and neutrally.[202] After the House of Representatives decided to upheld the Constitutional Court's ruling, the rupiah strengthened to 15,492 per 1 USD.[203]

Reactions

edit

Domestic reactions

edit

Executive government

edit
President Joko Widodo's statement on the Constitutional Court's decision in a mock up interview organized by the Presidential Secretariat, 21 August 2024.[204]

Jokowi was criticized for making a statement that this was only part of the "checks and balances" function of the Constitutional Court and the House of Representatives, even though the position of the Constitutional Court's decision is final and binding, and is considered the highest in testing between laws and the Constitution. Thus, it is unconstitutional for the House of Representatives to create a new bill to circumvent the decision.[205][206][207] On 22 August 2024, at 17:44, a new statement was then made by the head of the Presidential Communication Office, Hasan Nasbi, that the government has complied with the Constitutional Court's decision.[208] Meanwhile, the Minister of Home Affairs stated that he was still waiting for the discussion of the Regional Head Election Bill by the Legislation Committee.[209]

On 23 August 2024, Jokowi in reaction to the wave of protest demanding the government to upheld the Constitutional Court's ruling told the media that he will not issue a government regulations in-lieu-of Acts (Perppu) regarding to local elections after the House of Representatives decided not to ratify the drafted bill and praised the protesters for delivering their aspirations.[210] However, he refused to comment on the failure to pass the bill into law because the quorum is not present, stating that it was the legislative branch's area to respond.[210]

Legislative

edit

Speaker of the House of Representatives Puan Maharani thanked the demonstrators for their aspirations on the issue and asked the demonstrators to work together to keep the House of Representatives accountable for their acts.[211] Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives Sufmi Dasco Ahmad who preside the meeting session on the bill states that the drafted bill will not pass and the registration for the election will be done based on the Constitutional Court's ruling.[212] Member of Regional Representative Council from Central Kalimantan Agustin Teras Nanang praised the Constitutional Court's ruling, stating that the ruling could reduce the arrogance of political parties in gathering the people's aspiration as well as reducing the high political cost that may have to be incurred by candidates during the election.[213]

However, due to Kaesang's reportedly preparing documents required to stand as a candidate and public distrust of the House of Representatives, skepticism arises on whether the House of Representatives is truly serious in repealing the drafted bill.[194] Herdiansyah Hamzah of the Constitutional and Administrative Law Society (CALS) state that the protesters must continue to voice their aspirations as he believed that the failure is a way to 'test the waters' and when public pressure waned, the House of Representatives could try again and make sure the bill will pass into law.[210]

General Election Commission

edit

The General Elections Commission (KPU) stated that it would still follow the Constitutional Court's decision, but after consulting with the DPR, regarding the rules that had changed because previously it referred to the interpretation of the Supreme Court.[214] On 24 August 2024, a draft of the KPU decision was circulated referring to the MK decision. The KPU confirmed that the information was correct.[215]

Social media

edit

International reactions

edit

Foreign news coverage

edit

Reuters covered the protests with the headline "Protests across Indonesia as parliament delays changes to election law",[216] highlighting the dismissive attitude by Jokowi who stated that the role of the Constitutional Court and the House of Representatives in this event was part of "checks and balances". A similar negative highlight was given by the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) in a story titled "Election law changes spark mass protests in Indonesia".[217] The BBC reported that the revision of the law was an attempt to scuttle Anies Baswedan, as well as pave the way for Kaesang, who does not meet the minimum age requirement for elections.

South Korea's national media, Yonhap, reported a similar story, suggesting that the DPR's action was aimed at smoothing Kaesang's path in the 2024 Regional Head Election.[218] Meanwhile, Channel News Asia published a story titled "Thousands protest Indonesian parliament's move to subvert court ruling, pave way for Jokowi's son to contest in local elections", which highlighted Jokowi's tendency to pave the way for his children after Gibran was also allowed to run in the presidential election after the Constitutional Court, under the leadership of his brother-in-law, Anwar Usman, changed the rules regarding the age limit.[219]

Malaysian media The Star reported that the demonstrations disrupted the Indonesian economy.[220] Voice of America reported that the influence of this demonstration had spread to various cities in Indonesia.[221] Aljazeera highlighted the strangeness of the sudden ratification process of the bill and it appeared to smoothen Jokowi's steps in building dynastic politics.[222]

Individuals

edit

International journalist Mario Nawfal in Twitter tweeted his own recap on the several publications from foreign news source regarding the protests. He stated that this demonstration occurred because the DPR gave Kaesang the opportunity to take part in the regional elections by circumventing the age limit.[223]

South Korean musician Jae Park gave his support to the protesters. He said he is aware his stances can affect his chances to perform in a concert at Indonesia but he can't be silent witnessing what has transpired.[224]

Criticism

edit

Asset Confiscation Bill

edit

Several social media accounts criticized the demonstration because it did not involve demands for the acceleration of the ratification of the Asset Confiscation Bill.[225] Later, this narrative was also amplified by Joko Widodo by demanding the House of Representatives to accelerate the ratification of Asset Consfiscation Bill.[226] In several regional demonstrations, such demands had actually been made, such as those in Palangka Raya,[227] Kediri,[228] Subang,[229] Padang,[230] Buleleng,[231] and Balikpapan.[232] However, Tempo's Fact Check site also stated that this criticism was misleading because this issue was actually part of the demands of the demonstration, including those in Jakarta.[233] Some netizens also criticized this narrative as whataboutism that can divert the focus of the main issue.[234]

Counter-narrative

edit

In the aftermath of the demonstrations in Jakarta, some social media accounts defending the government (known as 'Buzzers' in Indonesia and comparable to Wumaos or Vatniks) attempted to counter the criticisms by posting sanitized versions of the Indonesian emergency warning image, accompanied by the phrase "Indonesia Baik-Baik Saja" (Indonesia is fine). This effort was aimed at downplaying the severity of the situation and reassuring the public.[235]

Additionally, there were reports of attempts to financially incentivize individuals to spread messages supporting the DPR's decision. Offers were made to pit Anies Baswedan's supporters against PDI-P supporters, but these offers were rejected by the wider public. Similarly, efforts to financially reward individuals for portraying the DPR's decision as being widely accepted also faced rejection by counter-posts and artworks in social media. The DPR denied any involvement in these financial offers.[236]

edit

In Jakarta

edit
  •  
    Protestors enter the grounds of the House of Representatives after the right gate was broken down during a demonstration on the regional election bill
  •  
    Situation at the Gates of the DPR Building as protestors defaced and set a fire pit to the entrance
  •  
    Workers and students directly confronts the police at the perimeter of the DPR Building
  •  
    An injured protestor getting checked by medical personnel
  •  
    Graffiti on crowd control barriers to the JIRR tollway.
  •  
    Situation in front of the DPR gates at 12:52 PM
  •  
    University of Indonesia student holds a sign that reads, 'Info Loker for Gibran & Kaesang,' referencing the ease with which the two secured their positions.
  •  
    A middle-class worker calling for the office workers of SCBD to protest together.[237] He holds the sign, "Even Soeharto got scared! #WeDeserveBetter"
  •  
    Head of BEM UI, Verrel Uziel, coordinating with other university students. Later becoming viral for his speeches.[238]

In Medan

edit
  •  
    A protestor stands in the middle of a sit in protest in Medan
  •  
    Protestors blockade the front gate of the North Sumatra DPRD Building
  •  
    Students from the University of North Sumatra waiting patiently in a sit-in protest
  •  
    A Medan Police officer taking a picture during protests
  •  
    A university students speaks his aspirations through a megaphone
  •  
    Activists clad in black in Medan
  •  
    Students gather around a makeshift fire in the middle of an intersection near the North Sumatra DPRD
  •  
    Chairman of the North Sumatra DPRD, Sutarto, also joined in the sit-in protest[43]

See also

edit
 
Wikimedia Commons has media related to 2024 Indonesian local election law protests.

Student protests in Indonesia

Other protests


Notes

edit
  1. ^
    • On August 22 protest: 26 casualties[10]
    • On August 26 protest: 33 casualties[11]
  2. ^ According to article 7, article 8, and explanation of article 8 of the Act No. 7 of 2011 on the Creation of Rules[30]
  3. ^ According to article 9 section 1 and article 9 section 2 of the Act No. 7 of 2011 on the Creation of Rules[30]

References

edit
 
Wikisource has original text related to this article:
  1. ^ "DPR Resmi Batalkan RUU Pilkada". CNN Indonesia. 22 August 2024. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  2. ^ "Pelajar STM Ikut Demo di DPR, Polisi Langsung Tembakkan "Water Cannon"". Kompas (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  3. ^ "FSGI Sebut Anak STM Punya Hak Melakukan Demonstrasi, Jangan Ditangkapi". JPNN.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  4. ^ "Pelajar STM Ikut Demo di DPR, Geruduk Gedung Bawa Bambu, Polisi Langsung Tembakkan Water Cannon". Tribunnews (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  5. ^ "Singgung Revisi UU Pilkada, Megawati: Akali Putusan MK Pelanggaran Konstitusi". tempo.co. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  6. ^ "Anies Baswedan Unggah Peringatan Darurat: Kembalikan Demokrasi Indonesia" dari situs NTV News
  7. ^ Wijaya, Lani Diana (22 August 2024). "Tim Advokasi Untuk Demokrasi Catat 20 Demonstran Tolak RUU Pilkada Ditangkap, 3 Orang Luka". Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  8. ^ Kompas.com (23 August 2024). "Presiden BEM UI Alami Luka 11 Jahitan Diduga Akibat Kekerasan Aparat saat Demo di DPR" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  9. ^ Kompas.com (23 August 2024). "7 Polisi dan 14 Demonstran Terluka Saat Demo Ricuh di Depan Gedung DPR RI" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  10. ^ "Mahasiswa Korban Kericuhan Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada di Semarang Makin Bertambah". Metrotvnews. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  11. ^ Annizar, Baihaqi (27 August 2024). Situmorang, Anggun P (ed.). "Demo di Semarang Ricuh, 33 Orang Dibawa ke RS dan 27 Ditangkap" [Protests in Semarang Turns Chaotic, 33 People Taken to Hospital and 27 Arrested]. Tirto (in Indonesian). Retrieved 27 August 2024.
  12. ^ "Demo di Bandung, Mata Mahasiswa Terluka Kena Lemparan dan Gas Air Mata". CNN Indonesia (in Indonesian). 23 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  13. ^ Rahmayanti, Dini Putri (22 August 2024). "Aksi Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada di Bandung Ricuh, Korban Berjatuhan" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  14. ^ a b c "5 Mahasiswa Luka saat Demo Ricuh di Palu, 1 Korban Sobek di Telinga". Detik (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  15. ^ "Ricuh Demo di Gedung DPRD Jambi, Sejumlah Mahasiswa Terluka". 23 August 2024.
  16. ^ Yulianto, Eki (23 August 2024). "Seorang Polisi dan Mahasiswa Terluka dalam Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada di DPRD Kota Cirebon". tribunjabar. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  17. ^ "Tak Hanya Aparat, Mahasiswa Juga Jadi Korban Luka - luka Imbas Demo di DPRD Riau". cakaplah. 23 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  18. ^ Al Farisi, Baharudin (23 August 2024). "Polda Metro Tangkap 301 Pedemo di Gedung DPR RI". kompas. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  19. ^ "Polisi Menangkap 159 Siswa yang Hendak Ikut Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada". jpnn. 22 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  20. ^ "20 Orang Dilaporkan Ditangkap saat Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada di DPR". CNN Indonesia. 22 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  21. ^ "7 Polisi Terluka Saat Amankan Demo di Depan DPR, Kepala-Kaki Robek". detiknews. 23 August 2024. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  22. ^ Yulianto, Eki (23 August 2024). "Seorang Polisi dan Mahasiswa Terluka dalam Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada di DPRD Kota Cirebon". tribunjabar. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  23. ^ "Tak Hanya Aparat, Mahasiswa Juga Jadi Korban Luka - luka Imbas Demo di DPRD Riau". cakaplah. 23 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  24. ^ a b "Kerusuhan Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada, Polresta Samarinda Selidiki Demonstran Pembawa Sajam". mediakaltim.com. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  25. ^ "Habiburokhman terkena lemparan botol saat menemui massa aksi RUU Pilkada". antarajabar. 22 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  26. ^ Yudha Saputra, Eka (22 August 2024). "Jurnalis Tempo Dipukul dan Ditendang oleh Diduga Aparat saat Liput Demo Kawal Putusan MK di DPR". tempo. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  27. ^ Bebey, Aksara (22 August 2024). "Jurnalis di Bandung Diduga Dianiaya saat Liput Aksi Menolak Revisi UU Pilkada". merdeka. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  28. ^ Putri, Sri Cahyani. "Para Dosen UGM Yogyakarta Serukan Indonesia Darurat Demokrasi, Ini Tuntutannya". Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  29. ^ Redaksi, Tim. "Demo Darurat Indonesia: Ribuan Buruh & Mahasiswa Kepung Gedung DPR RI" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  30. ^ a b "Undang-Undang Nomor 12 Tahun 2011 tentang Pembentukan Peraturan Perundang-Undangan" [Act No. 12 of 2011 on Creation of Rules] (PDF) (in Indonesian). Lembaran Negara Republik Indonesia. Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 August 2024. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  31. ^ Prasetia, Andhika (21 August 2017). "Mendagri: UU Pemilu Berlaku Mulai 16 Agustus" [Minister of Internal Affairs: General Election Law Enters into Force from August 16]. Detik (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  32. ^ "DPR sahkan Perppu Pilkada jadi UU" [HoR ratifies Government Regulations in-lieu-of Acts into Acts]. BBC Indonesia (in Indonesian). 20 January 2015. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  33. ^ "Jadwal Lengkap Pendaftaran Capres-cawapres 19-25 Oktober" [Complete Schedule for the 19-25 October President-Vice President Candidates Registration]. CNN Indonesia (in Indonesian). 13 October 2023. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  34. ^ "Putusan MK bolehkan capres-cawapres di bawah 40 tahun, asalkan pernah atau sedang jadi pejabat negara" [Constitutional Court Ruling allows President-Vice Prez Candidates under the age of 40, so long as they ever or is currently holding a public office]. BBC Indonesia (in Indonesian). 16 October 2023. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  35. ^ Belia, Brigitta (27 November 2023). "MKMK Putuskan Anwar Usman Langgar Etik Berat, Diberhentikan dari Ketua MK!" [MKMK Rules Anwar Usman Committed Serious Ethical Violations, Dismissed as Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court!]. Detik (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  36. ^ Mantalean, Vitorio; Prabowo, Dani (24 April 2024). "KPU Resmi Tetapkan Prabowo-Gibran Presiden dan Wapres Terpilih 2024-2029" [KPU Officially Declares Prabowo-Gibran the President-Vice President Elects for 2024-2029]. Kompas (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  37. ^ "MA Ubah Aturan Batas Usia, Kaesang Berpeluang Maju Pilgub 2024" [Changing Minimum Age Requirement, Kaesang has the Chance to Run for the 2024 Gubernatorial Elections]. CNN Indonesia (in Indonesian). 30 May 2024. Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  38. ^ "MA Perintahkan KPU Cabut Aturan Batas Usia Calon Kepala Daerah" [Supreme Court Orders KPU to Revoke the Minimum Age Rules for the Regional Heads Candidates]. CNN Indonesia (in Indonesian). 30 May 2024. Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  39. ^ Article 24C, Section 1 of the Constitution of Indonesia (1945)
  40. ^ "Poin-poin Putusan MK soal Syarat dan Usia Calon Kepala Daerah". CNN Indonesia. 22 August 2024. Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  41. ^ Naufal, Muhammad (21 August 2024). "DPR Hanya Akomodir Parpol Tanpa Kursi, Partai Parlemen Tetap 20%" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  42. ^ "DPR Setujui RUU Pilkada Anulir Putisan MK No 60 dan 70, PDIP Sindir Beda Perlakuan saat Putusan No 90" [HoR Accepts the Local Election Bill to Overturn the Supreme Court's Decisions No. 60 and 70, PDI-P Criticizes the Treatment Difference with Decision No. 90]. Tempo (in Indonesian). 22 August 2024. Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  43. ^ a b Aditya, Nicholas Ryan; Ihsanuddin (21 August 2024). "DPR Setujui RUU Pilkada untuk Anulir Putusan MK, Hanya PDI-P yang Menolak" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  44. ^ Mantalean, Vitorio; Ihsanuddin (21 August 2024). "DPR Manut MA dan Tolak MK soal Usia Cagub, Angin Segar untuk Kaesang" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  45. ^ Afianto, Rian (21 August 2024). "Early Warning System Menjelma Jadi Tanda Bahaya, "Peringatan Darurat" Berubah Jadi Gerakan Massa Melawan Monarki". Jawa Pos. Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  46. ^ rca (21 August 2024). "Kawal Putusan MK dan Tolak Pilkada Akal-akalan Trending Topic di X" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  47. ^ "Tak Penuhi Kuorum, Rapat Paripurna UU Pilkada Hanya Dihadiri 89 Orang". Kompas. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  48. ^ "Cak Imin Mengaku Tidak Tahu Ada Rapat Baleg DPR Bahas RUU Pilkada". Antara News. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  49. ^ "Suara Fraksi PKB di DPR Terbelah Sikapi Revisi UU Pilkada". Katadata. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  50. ^ "Beda Sikap dengan Fraksi, Anggota DPR dari PKB Ini Tolak Pengesahan RUU Pilkada". Sindonews. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  51. ^ Suryarandika, Rizky (21 August 2024). "Fahri Hamzah Ngeluh dan Protes ke MK, Putusan Soal Pilkada di Luar Permohonan". Republika Online (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  52. ^ a b Apridawaty, Titi Sutinah (23 August 2024). "Erini Gudono Jadi Perbincangan Hangat Warganet di Tengah Demo RUU Pilkada". Sindonews.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  53. ^ "Netizen Murka Erina Gudono - Kaesang Foya-foya ke AS di Saat Rakyat Demo, Diduga Naik Jet Pribadi". Tempo.co (in Indonesian). 22 August 2024. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  54. ^ a b Hamzah, Aqil (26 August 2024). "Jokowi's younger son disqualified from November elections, draws flak for US trip amid protests". The Straits Times. ISSN 0585-3923. Retrieved 27 August 2024.
  55. ^ "Pesawat Jet Pribadi yang Dipakai Kaesang Pangarep dan Erina Diduga Milik Garena Penerbit Free Fire". Bangkapos.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 27 August 2024.
  56. ^ Novita, Mila (22 August 2024). "Fakta tentang Lobster Roll, Roti Viral Erina Gudono yang Harganya Rp400 Ribu". Tempo (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  57. ^ "Erina Gudono Disebut Mirip Marie Antoinette, Permaisuri Prancis yang Hidup Mewah".
  58. ^ "Marie Antoinette: Siapa Ratu Prancis yang dibandingkan dengan Erina Gudono?". BBC News Indonesia (in Indonesian). 25 August 2024. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  59. ^ Afifa, Laila (22 August 2024). "Marie Antoinette and the Famous 'Let Them Eat Cake', Who was She?". Tempo. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  60. ^ "Unggahan Roti Rp400 Ribu Lebih Mahal Dibanding Gaji Guru Honorer Jadi Sorotan". Tvonenews.com (in Indonesian). 27 August 2024. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  61. ^ Hayati, Istiqomatul (23 August 2024). "Warganet Kirim Surat Massal untuk Cabut Beasiswa Erina Gudono di University of Pennsylvania". Tempo (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  62. ^ Santoso, Bangun (25 August 2024). "Usai Jet Pribadi, Netizen Kini Bongkar Tempat Erina Gudono Diduga Menginap Di AS: Hotel Mewah Tarif Selangit". suara.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  63. ^ Nabilla, Farah (25 August 2024). "Mewahnya Hotel Diduga Tempat Menginap Erina Gudono di Amerika, Sewa Semalam Bisa buat Gaji 40 Guru Honorer". suara.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  64. ^ "Nilai Erina Gudono Tak Layak Jadi Calon Bupati Sleman, Pengamat: Dia Model, Bukan Pejabat Publik". Kompas (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  65. ^ "Bea Cukai Buka Suara soal Viral Kaesang-Erina Turun Pesawat Langsung Naik Mobil". kumparan (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  66. ^ Indraini, Anisa. "Kata Bea Cukai soal Kaesang-Erina Turun dari Pesawat Langsung Naik Mobil". detiksumut (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  67. ^ Umiyani, Atikah (26 August 2024). "Viral Video Diduga Kaesang-Erina Turun dari Pesawat Jet Bawa Belanjaan ke Mobil, Ini Tanggapan Bea Cukai".
  68. ^ "TKN Bela Gaya Hedon Kaesang-Erina: Masyarakat juga Banyak yang Pakai Private Jet". KOMPAS.tv (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  69. ^ EAS Indonesia Concept (24/10/1991), ANM-021 (Mesem) - First Encounter. 24 October 2022. Retrieved 23 August 2024 – via YouTube.
  70. ^ a b "Demo hari ini: Mengapa Garuda Pancasila digunakan dalam 'peringatan darurat Indonesia' dan demonstrasi di DPR?". BBC News Indonesia (in Indonesian). 22 August 2024. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  71. ^ @BudiBukanintel (21 August 2024). "Goes hard" (Tweet). Archived from the original on 23 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024 – via Twitter.
  72. ^ @BudiBukanIntel (21 August 2024). "Image" (Tweet). Archived from the original on 23 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024 – via Twitter.
  73. ^ "Peringatan Darurat Indonesia di Media Sosial, Apa Artinya?". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  74. ^ "Asal-Usul 'Peringatan Darurat' Berlatar Orde Baru 1991, Ini Fakta Sebenarnya". Bisnis. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  75. ^ "Terungkap Pelopor Garuda Biru Peringatan Darurat, Diduga Awalnya Canda". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  76. ^ Mubarok, Abdul Malik (21 August 2024). "Nyalakan Peringatan Darurat, Mahasiswa UI Tutup Lambang Makara Kampus". SINDOnews Metro (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  77. ^ "Instagram". www.instagram.com. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  78. ^ "Instagram". www.instagram.com. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  79. ^ "X". www.x.com. Retrieved 27 August 2024.
  80. ^ "X". www.x.com. Retrieved 27 August 2024.
  81. ^ "X". www.x.com. Retrieved 27 August 2024.
  82. ^ Riantrisnanto, Ruly (23 August 2024). "Kunto Aji Konser Pakai Backdrop Peringatan Darurat Garuda Biru, Semua Respect". liputan6.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  83. ^ Zulfikar, Raden (23 August 2024). "Musisi Menggunakan Materi Visual "Peringatan Darurat" di Panggung, Penyalahgunaan Simbol Negara?". KOMPASIANA (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  84. ^ Vincentius Mario (25 August 2024). Caroline Pramantie (ed.). "Daftar Musisi yang Kampanyekan "Peringatan Darurat" saat Manggung". Kumparan (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  85. ^ Demo, BEM SI di Patung Kuda Bentrok dengan Polisi. Massa Masih BErtahan. dari situs CNN Indonesia
  86. ^ Menyesatkan, Narasi yang Mengatakan Mahasiswa Gelar Aksi Kawal Putusan MK Tapi Tidak Demo RUU Perampasan Aset dari situs cekfakta tempo
  87. ^ "Ribuan Buruh Kepung DPR Besok: Sampai Kiamat Kami Akan Perang". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  88. ^ "Demo Peringatan Darurat di Bandung dan Jogja Digelar Besok, Ini Lokasinya". Kompas. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  89. ^ "Jelang Demo Darurat Indonesia, 3200 Aparat Dikerahkan Amankan Jakarta". CNBC Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  90. ^ "Imbas Aksi Demo di Depan Gedung MK, Jalan Medan Merdeka Ditutup". Pojoksatu. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  91. ^ "Massa Unjuk Rasa Tolak Revisi RUU Pilkada Jebol Pagar DPR". Viva. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  92. ^ Achmad, Nirmala Maulana; Rastika, Icha (22 August 2024). "Aksi Kamisan Ke-828, Sumarsih Minta Aktivis 98 di DPR Pertahankan Reformasi". KOMPAS.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  93. ^ Luthfiana, Hisyam (22 August 2024). "Mengenal Guillotine, Simbol Anti Monarki dari Prancis yang Dibawa saat Aksi Kawal Putusan MK". Tempo (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  94. ^ JATI, RHAMA PURNA (22 August 2024). "Joko Anwar, Reza Rahadian, Arie Kriting Membaur Kawal "Peringatan Darurat" di DPR". kompas.id (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  95. ^ Hamdi, Imam (22 August 2024). "Komika Rigen Rakelna Ikut Unjuk Rasa Revisi UU Pilkada: Pejabat Mulai Melawak, Saatnya Komedian yang Melawan". Tempo. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  96. ^ "Bintang Emon Ikut Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada: Kalau Belum Umur 30 Tahun Jangan Nyalon Dulu ya Dek". Tribunjabar.id (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  97. ^ Nugraha, Bayu (22 August 2024). "Massa Unjuk Rasa Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada Jebol Pagar DPR". Viva.co.id (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  98. ^ Nugroho, M. Rosseno Aji (22 August 2024). "Gerbang Belakang Roboh, Massa Demo Coba Masuk Gedung DPR" [Rear Gate Collapses, Protesters Attempt to Enter the HoR Building]. CNBC Indonesia (in Indonesian). Archived from the original on 25 August 2024. Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  99. ^ Temui Massa Aksi, Anggota DPR Habiburokhman Dilempari Botol. dari situs CNNIndonesia
  100. ^ "Aparat Kepolisian Terekam Lakukan Kekerasan pada Demonstran saat Demo di Area Dalam Gedung DPR RI". Tribun Video (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  101. ^ Syahrial, Rizky; Carina, Jessi (22 August 2024). "Ricuh, Polisi Tembakkan "Water Cannon" dan Gas Air Mata ke Massa Demo di DPR". Kompas.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  102. ^ Sani, Ahmad Faiz Ibnu (22 August 2024). "Jurnalis Tempo Dipukul dan Ditendang oleh Diduga Aparat saat Liput Demo Kawal Putusan MK di DPR". Tempo (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  103. ^ Al Farisi, Bachruddin; Farisa, Fitra Chusna (23 August 2024). "Diintimidasi Polisi Saat Meliput Demo, Jurnalis Narasi: Ini Halangi Kebebasan Pers". KOMPAS.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  104. ^ Tmmy (21 August 2024). "Jurnalis IDN Times Diintimidasi saat Merekam Penganiayaan Polisi". IDN Times (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  105. ^ Direktur Lokataru, Delpedro Marhaen Ditangkap Saat Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada. dari situs kumparan
  106. ^ "Massa Berseragam SMA Datangi Gedung DPR, 2 Halte Seketika Hancur Diserang". Okezone.com (in Indonesian). 22 August 2024. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  107. ^ Mahasiswa Kembali Gelar Demo di Depan Gedung DPR. dari situs tempo
  108. ^ Ridwan, Muhammad Fauzi (22 August 2024). "Mahasiswa dari Berbagai Kampus di Bandung Gelar Aksi Turun ke Jalan". Republika Online (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  109. ^ Maulud, Mochammad Iqbal (22 August 2024). "Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada di Bandung Rusuh, Pagar DPRD Jabar Roboh". Pikiran Rakyat. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  110. ^ Bebey, Aksara (22 August 2024). "Jurnalis di Bandung Diduga Dianiaya saat Liput Aksi Menolak Revisi UU Pilkada". merdeka.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  111. ^ Mata kiri mahasiswa UNNIBA korban bentrok demo DPRD Jabar alami kebutaan. dari situs detik
  112. ^ Demo Mahasiswa Tolak RUU Pilkada 2024 di Tasikmalaya Ricuh, Sejumlah Fasilitas Gedung DPRD Rusak. dari inews
  113. ^ Mahasiswa Demo di Tugu Kujang Bogor, Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada. dari situs kompas
  114. ^ Seorang Polisi dan Mahasiswa Terluka dalam Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada di DPRD Kota Cirebon. dari situs tribunnews
  115. ^ Asih, Restu Wahyuning (22 August 2024). "Merinding, Ribuan Massa Berkaos Hitam Gelar Aksi Indonesia Darurat Demokrasi di Malioboro". Bisnis.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  116. ^ "Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada di Semarang Rusuh, Pagar DPRD Jateng Dirobohkan". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  117. ^ Annizar, Baihaqi (22 August 2024). "Demo di Semarang Ricuh, Ribuan Mahasiswa Ditembaki Gas Air Mata". Tirto (in Indonesian). Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  118. ^ "Mahasiswa Korban Kericuhan Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada di Semarang Makin Bertambah". Metro TV News. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  119. ^ Rosa, Maya Citra (23 August 2024). "26 Mahasiswa di Semarang Terluka akibat Ricuh Aksi Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada". KOMPAS.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  120. ^ Kurniawan, Dian (22 August 2024). "Mahasiswa, Nakes hingga Guru Honorer Datangi Tugu Pahlawan Surabaya Gelar Aksi Indonesia Darurat". liputan6.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  121. ^ syd/kid (22 August 2024). "Ratusan Aparat Gabungan Siaga Jaga 'Demo Darurat' di Depan Balkot Solo". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  122. ^ "Demo Mahasiswa di Solo, Jokowi Asal dari Segala Permasalahan ini". cnnindonesia.com. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  123. ^ Ribuan Demonstran di Malang Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada Lumpuhkan Lalu Lintas Kota dari situs berita sindonews
  124. ^ Putra, Perdana; Arief, Teuku Muhammad Valdy (22 August 2024). "Demonstran Berdatangan ke Gedung DPRD Sumbar, Jalan S Parman Macet Total". KOMPAS.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  125. ^ Diguyur Hujan Deras, Inilah Tuntutan Massa Aksi Demo di Bukittinggi dari situs berita Viva
  126. ^ Munthe, Ardi (22 August 2024). "Peringatan Darurat Indonesia, Pemuda Lampung Demo Pakai Kostum Money Heist Tuntut DPR Bubar". Liputan6.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  127. ^ Inge, Nefri (22 August 2024). "Topeng Prabowo Subianto hingga Bobby Nasution Warnai Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada di Palembang". Liputan6.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  128. ^ Di Jambi, Ribuan Massa Mahasiswa Gelar Aksi Demo di Gedung DPRD Jambi Menuntut Pembatalan Revisi UU Pilkada. dari situs jambiekspress
  129. ^ Ricuh, Demo di Gedung DPRD Jambi, Sejumlah Mahasiswa Terluka. dari situs merdeka
  130. ^ Viral Video Mahasiswa Diinjak Saat Demo Tolak UU Pilkada di Bengkulu. Bukan Polisi, Ini Sosoknya. dari situs TribunNews
  131. ^ Ribuan mahasiswa Aceh geruduk kantor DPRA, tolak RUU Pilkada. dari situs antara
  132. ^ Polisi Tangkap Lima Mahasiswa Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada di DPR Aceh. dari situs atjehwatch
  133. ^ Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada, Ribuan Mahasiswa Bentrok dengan Aparat. dari situs RRI
  134. ^ Noer, Mohammad (22 August 2024). "Ribuan Mahasiswa di Makassar Tolak Rencana Revisi UU Pilkada". tvOnenews (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  135. ^ Mashudi, L. M. (22 August 2024). "Aksi Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada, Mahasiswa di Makassar Bakar Ban". detikcom (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  136. ^ Massa Demo Revisi UU Pilkada di Makassar Dipaksa Bubar, Iriana Jokowi Mau Lewat dari situs berita komparan
  137. ^ M, Darsil Yahya (27 August 2024). "Kampus UNM Rusak Parah akibat Bentrokan Warga dan Mahasiswa di Makassar". KOMPAS.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  138. ^ Mahasiswa dan Jurnalis di Kendari Gelar Aksi Tuntut Revisi RUU Pilkada Pasca Putusan MK. dari situs teras
  139. ^ Marzuki, Basri (23 August 2024). "Unjuk Rasa Mahasiswa Kawal Putusan MK di Palu". CARITAU.COM (in Indonesian). Antara. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  140. ^ "Mengawal Putusan MK, Mahasiswa Banggai Demo di Tengah Guyuran Hujan". Banggai News (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  141. ^ "Duduki Kantor DPRD Majene, Massa Pedemo Rusak dan Pecahkan Fasilitas". CNN Indonesia (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  142. ^ Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada, Mahasiswa Aksi Duduk di Depan KPU. dari situs berita detik
  143. ^ Unjuk Rasa Kawal Putusan MK di Mataram Ricuh, Massa Dibubarkan Paksa Gunakan Gas Air Mata. dari situs berita kompas
  144. ^ Andryanto, S. Dian (24 August 2024). "BEM Unud dan Aliansi Bali Menggugat: KPU Segera Tetapkan PKPU Berdasar Putusan MK". Tempo. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  145. ^ Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada di Ambon Ricuh, Massa Lempari Kaca Gedung DPRD. dari situs berita CNNIndpnesia
  146. ^ Mahasiswa dari Berbagai Organisasi di Manokwari Ikut Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada. dari situs berita Kompas
  147. ^ Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada, Koalisi Masyarakat Sipil dan AJI Gelar Aksi Bisu di Taman Sorong dari situs kompas
  148. ^ Tolak RUU Pilkada, Mahasiswa di Banjarmasin Duduki DPRD Kalsel. dari situs berita kompas
  149. ^ Ribuan Massa di Kalsel Gelar Aksi Unjuk Rasa Tolak RUU Pilkada dari situs tribunnews
  150. ^ Ribuan Mahasiswa Kaltim Geruduk Gadung DPRD Tuntut Pembatalan RUU Pilkada dan Perampasan Aset dari situs berita mediakaltim
  151. ^ Massa Tolak TUU Pilkada di Balikpapan Diwarnai Aksi Saling Dorong dari situs antara
  152. ^ "Aksi kawal putusan MK di DPRD Kalbar". antarafoto.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  153. ^ Aksi Ricuh Aliansi Rakyat di DPRD Kalteng Protes Revisi UU Pilkada 2024, Minta Ketua DPRD Hadir. dari situs tribunnews
  154. ^ "Ratusan Mahasiswa Datangi Tempat Pelantikan Anggota DPRD Tarakan 2024-2029, Ini Seruan Aksinya". Tribunkaltara.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  155. ^ Kurniawan, Muhammad Budi. "Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada di Tarakan Ricuh, 11 Polisi-1 Mahasiswa Luka". detiksulsel (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  156. ^ Amnesty International Soroti Kekerasan Polisi ke Massa Demo Penolakan RUU Pilkada. dari situs merdeka
  157. ^ Naswandi. "Ngeri! Oknum Diduga Polisi Ancam Lakukan Penculikan Peserta dalam Demo Kawal Putusan MK". Pikiran Rakyat (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  158. ^ Polisi Tetapkan 19 Pendemo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada Jadi Tersangka. dari situs CNN Indonesia
  159. ^ Polri Diapresiasi Saat Bertugas Amankan Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada. dari situs merdeka
  160. ^ "Haidar Alwi: Hak Angket Bisa Timbulkan Protes dari Rakyat". Sin Po (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  161. ^ "Hentikan Brutalitas Aparat Kepolisian Terhadap Massa Aksi "Indonesia Darurat Demokrasi" dan Lepaskan Kawan Kami!". YLBHI. 22 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  162. ^ "FOTO: Aksi Brutal Aparat Bubarkan Demo Peringatan Darurat Indonesia". CNN Indonesia. 23 August 2024. Retrieved 8 September 2024.
  163. ^ "Menelisik Nama Joko Widodo yang Dulunya Bernama Mulyono". Tempo (in Indonesian). 26 August 2024. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  164. ^ "X". www.x.com. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  165. ^ "X". www.x.com. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  166. ^ "X". www.x.com. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  167. ^ "X". www.x.com. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  168. ^ "Trending Twitter Mpreg adalah Ironi ketika Perempuan Melawan Patriarki". Opinia (in Indonesian). 20 August 2024. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  169. ^ Tionardus, Melvina; Setiawan, Tri Susanto (22 August 2024). "Raffi Ahmad Jadi Sorotan Dampingi Gibran di Saat Ada Demo Tolak Revisi UU Pilkada". Kompas.com (in Indonesian). Archived from the original on 31 August 2024. Retrieved 31 August 2024.
  170. ^ Ginanjar, Raden Putri Alpadillah (23 August 2024). "Buka Suara Soal Putusan MK, Raffi Ahmad: Kawal dengan Cara Masing-masing". Tempo. Archived from the original on 31 August 2024. Retrieved 31 August 2024.
  171. ^ Riandi, Ady Prawira; Pangerang, Andy Muttya Keteng (26 August 2024). "Terancam Diboikot Netizen, Raffi Ahmad: Badai Pasti Berlalu". Kompas.com. Archived from the original on 29 August 2024. Retrieved 31 August 2024.
  172. ^ Satriawan, Ardianto [@adrisatriawan] (24 August 2024). "Infokan siapa saja influencer, artis, media, klub bola, dan brand pendukung rezim" (Tweet). Retrieved 25 August 2024 – via Twitter.
  173. ^ a b Silvina, Shelia (23 August 2024). "Ramai Seruan Boikot Raffi Ahmad CS di X dengan Lontaran Narasi Tajam! Apa Salah Mereka? Apa Perlu Diboikot?". rbtv.co.id (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  174. ^ Ginanjar, Raden Putri Alpadillah (22 August 2024). "Banyak Komika Turun, Netizen Cari Kiky Saputri di Aksi Kawal Putusan MK". Tempo. Archived from the original on 31 August 2024. Retrieved 31 August 2024.
  175. ^ Meliana, Ruth; Nofiana, Fita (23 August 2024). "Kiky Saputri Dibilang Kepedean usai Ngerasa Jadi Ordal Rezim: Sis, Kamu Cuma Alat". Suara.com. Archived from the original on 31 August 2024. Retrieved 31 August 2024.
  176. ^ Rahman, Abdul (22 August 2024). "Sebut Putusan MK yang Tertinggi, Kiky Saputri Ungkit Kasus Kontroversial Gibran". Jawa Pos. Retrieved 31 August 2024.
  177. ^ "Erina Gudono Dituding Jorok, Kuku Kaki Hitam Kontras dengan Tas Dior". suara.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  178. ^ "Bau Badannya Diumbar Erina Gudono, Kebiasaan Mandi Kaesang Pangarep Kini Jadi Omongan". suara.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  179. ^ Buana, Gana (24 August 2024). "Awal Mula Bau Ketiak Erina Gudono Jadi Sorotan, Rupanya dari Foto Ini". mediaindonesia.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  180. ^ "Belajar tentang 'Social Justice' di Amerika, Erina Gudono Kena Kritik Netizen: Sila Kelima Aja Dilanggar Mertuanya!". suara.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  181. ^ Rais, Ayurahmi (23 August 2024). "Kondisi Mental Erina Gudono Menantu Presiden Jokowi, yang Dibully Netizen Karena Diduga Bau Ketiak".
  182. ^ Insertlive. "Disebut Beruntung Tak Jadi Nikah dengan Kaesang, Felicia Tissue Bilang Begini". hot-gossip (in Indonesian). Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  183. ^ Chawarazmi, Zamachsyari (22 August 2024). "Sempat Beri Vote Setuju di Baleg, PKS Kini Dukung Pembatalan Revisi RUU Pilkada". kumparan (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  184. ^ Waku, Fersianus (22 August 2024). "PKB Bersyukur DPR Batal Sahkan RUU Pilkada: Suara Rakyat Didengar". Tribunnews.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  185. ^ "Siaran Pers Fraksi Partai Demokrat DPR RI". Partai Demokrat. 23 August 2024. Archived from the original on 24 August 2024. Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  186. ^ Hamid Awaluddin: Prabowo Sangat Marah Ada Manuver Revisi UU Pilkada dari situs Kompas
  187. ^ Dasco soal Prabowo Marah Imbas Manuver RUU Pilkada: Siapa yang Dimarahi? dari situs inilah
  188. ^ Gerindra Buka Suara soal Isu Prabowo Marah Imbas Manuver RUU Pilkada. dari situs berita CNN Indonesia
  189. ^ a b c d RAHAYU, KURNIA YUNITA (23 August 2024). "Putusan MK Diterapkan, Apakah "KIM Plus" Tetap Solid?". kompas.id (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  190. ^ Al Fiqri, Achmad (25 August 2024). "Pascaputusan MK, Cak Imin Tegaskan PKB Tak Selalu Bersama KIM Plus di Pilkada 2024". SINDOnews Nasional (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  191. ^ "Gerilya KIM Plus di Jawa Terancam Putusan MK, PDIP Bisa Usung Sendiri". CNN Indonesia. 21 August 2024.
  192. ^ Gerindra Cs Batal Usung Kaesang di Pilgub Jateng hingga Respons Jokowi. dari situs CNBC Indonesia.
  193. ^ Gerindra Sebut KIM Plus Dukung Ahmad Luthfi-Kaesang di Pilkada Jateng. dari situs suarasurabaya
  194. ^ a b Kaesang Urus Surat Keterangan Belum Pernah Dipidana untuk Maju pada Pilkada Jateng 2024. dari situs kompas
  195. ^ PSI soal Kaesang Urus Surat Maju Pilkada: Inisiatif Staf, Sudah Dihentikan. dari situs kumparan
  196. ^ Hutabarat, Delvira (24 August 2024). "Sekjen PSI: Kaesang Sejak Awal Tidak Minat Maju Pilkada, Fokus Bisnis dan Keluarga". liputan6.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
  197. ^ Andryanto, S. Dian (25 August 2024). "Terganjal Putusan MK Kaesang Gagal Nyalon di Pilkada Jateng Tapi Masih Bisa Maju Wali Kota, Kenapa?". Tempo. Retrieved 29 August 2024.
  198. ^ "Kaesang Gagal Maju Di Pilgub, Masih Bisa Jadi Calon Bupati-Wali Kota". CNN Indonesia. 23 August 2024.
  199. ^ Aulia, Fauzaki (21 August 2024). "Wanda Hamidah Umumkan Keluar dari Golkar Melalui Postingan 'Peringatan Darurat Garuda Biru'". Padang Raya - Pikiran Rakyat Media Network. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  200. ^ "Demo "Peringatan Darurat", IHSG Dibuka Ambruk ke Level 7.497". Bisnis. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  201. ^ "Demo Peringatan Darurat Meluas, Rupiah Lanjut Melemah ke Rp 15.615/US$". CNBC Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  202. ^ Damiana. "Geramnya Bos Hotel, Ungkap Efek Ngeri di Balik Demo Darurat Indonesia". CNBC Indonesia (in Indonesian). Retrieved 24 August 2024.
  203. ^ Widyastuti, Rr Ariyani Yakti (25 August 2024). "Rupiah Menguat di 15.492 per Dolar AS Usai Demo Kawal Putusan MK, BI: Faktor Fundamental Ekonomi Lebih Kuat". Tempo. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  204. ^ "Siasat Pura-pura Wawancara Jokowi Demi Hindari Kritik di Akhir Jabatan". CNN Indonesia. 2 September 2024.
  205. ^ "Media Asing Soroti Pernyataan Jokowi Soal DPR vs Putusan MK". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  206. ^ "Jokowi Biarkan DPR Anulir Putusan MK Soal Ambang Batas Calon Kepala Daerah". Tempo. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  207. ^ "MKMK Siap Kawal Putusan Soal Pilkada. Putusan MK Final dan Mengikat". Kompas. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  208. ^ "Istana Tegaskan Akan Ikuti Putusan MK Soal Pencalonan Pilkada". Kompas. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  209. ^ Aditya, Nicholas Ryan; Ramadhan, Ardito (22 August 2024). "Menkumham Tunggu Sikap DPR soal Pengesahan Revisi UU Pilkada". KOMPAS.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  210. ^ a b c Andryanto, S. Dian (25 August 2024). "Tanggapan Sejumlah Tokoh Soal Aksi Demo Kawal Putusan MK, Jokowi: Sangat Baik". Tempo (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  211. ^ Khalida, Melalusa Susthira (22 August 2024). "Puan: Terima kasih aspirasi masyarakat atas putusan MK soal UU Pilkada". Antara (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  212. ^ Chairunnisa, Ninis (22 August 2024). "Wakil Ketua DPR Sufmi Dasco Pastikan Pilkada 2024 Ikuti Putusan MK". Tempo (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  213. ^ Hidayat, Muhammad Arif; Manurung, Jaya W (26 August 2024). "Senator RI: Putusan MK selamatkan demokrasi Indonesia". Antara News (in Indonesian). Retrieved 26 August 2024.
  214. ^ yla/kid (22 August 2024). "KPU Siapkan Draf PKPU Syarat Pencalonan Pilkada Mengacu Putusan MK". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  215. ^ KPU Benarkan Draf PKPU yang Beredar di Publik Merujuk Keputusan MK dari situs antara
  216. ^ "Protests across Indonesia as parliament delays change to election law". Reuters. 22 August 2024.
  217. ^ "Election law changes spark mass protests in Indonesia". BBC. 22 August 2024.
  218. ^ rds/bac (22 August 2024). "Soroti Demo Tolak UU Pilkada, Media Korsel Singgung Kaesang". CNN Indonesia. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  219. ^ "Thousands protest Indonesian parliament's move to subvert court ruling, pave way for Jokowi's son to contest in local elections". CNA. Retrieved 23 August 2024.
  220. ^ Indonesian Parliament adjourns as protests hit markets dari situs thestar.com.my
  221. ^ Indonesia cancels ratification of controversial election law amid protests. dari situs voanews.com
  222. ^ Indonesia scraps plan to change election law after thousands protest. dari situs aljazeera
  223. ^ PROTESTERS STORM PARLIAMENT OVER LAW THAT COULD CREATE A POLITICAL "DYNASTY". dari akun X @MarioNawfal
  224. ^ Peringatan Darurat Meluas ke Dunia, Musisi Jae Park Ikut Suarakan dan Ajak Kawal Putusan MK. dari situs tempo
  225. ^ Warganet Soroti Nasib RUU Perampasan Aset.. dari situs kompas
  226. ^ "Jokowi Minta DPR Segera Selesaikan RUU Perampasan Aset". Kompas (in Indonesian). 27 August 2024. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  227. ^ Ini Tuntutan Mahasiswa dalam Demo Penolakan RUU Pilkada. dari situs kalteng.co
  228. ^ Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada, Mahasiswa dan Masyarakat Sipil di Kediri Ricuh. dari situs berita jatimtimes
  229. ^ Aliansi Mahasiswa Subang Tuntut DPR Segera Sahkan RUU Perampasan Aset. dari situs lampusatu
  230. ^ Demonstran di Padang Ancam Berkemah Jika RUU Pilkada Tidak Dibatalkan dari situs metrotvnews
  231. ^ Ratusan Mahasiswa di Buleleng Turun ke Jalan, Ini Tuntutannya. dari situs balipost
  232. ^ Di Kaltim Aksi Demo Digelar di Sejumlah Kantor DPRD. dari situs liputan6
  233. ^ Menyesatkan, Narasi yang Mengatakan Mahasiswa Gelar Aksi Kawal Putusan MK Tapi Tidak Demo RUU Perampasan Aset dari situs cekfakta tempo
  234. ^ "Demo Kawal Putusan MK Diserang Propaganda Whataboutisme RUU Perampasan Aset". Harian Massa (in Indonesian). 24 August 2024. Retrieved 28 August 2024.
  235. ^ Upaya Buzzer Melakukan Kontra Narasi Peringatan Darurat. dari situs PR Indonesia
  236. ^ "Viral Tawaran Kerja Sama Media dan Influencer Amankan Pemberitaan RUU Pilkada, Ini Kata Sekjen DPR : Okezone News". news.okezone.com. Retrieved 27 August 2024.
  237. ^ @hrdbacot (22 August 2024). "Kelas menengah pekerja jaksel udah turun kejalan dan orasi "its time for you to freaking move"" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
  238. ^ Kurniawan, Endra (23 August 2024). "Profil Verrel Uziel, Presiden BEM UI yang Videonya Viral Siap Demo Tolak RUU Pilkada sampai Menang". Tribunnews.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 25 August 2024.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2024_Indonesian_local_election_law_protests&oldid=1245232791"