| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Jumped the gun |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Jumped the gun
|
| Disqualified Contestants |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Disqualified Contestants
|
| Table |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Table
|
| vfd of idol contestant article |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#vfd of idol contestant article
|
| Individual season articles? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Individual season articles?
|
| Move to delete |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Move to delete
|
| Questions from Germany |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Questions from Germany
|
| American Idol 5 to be delayed until March or April 2006? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#American Idol 5 to be delayed until March or April 2006?
|
| Criticisms |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Criticisms
|
| Idol is sacrilege |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Idol is sacrilege
|
| Peer review for article on contestant |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Peer review for article on contestant
|
| Navigation? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Navigation?
|
| American Idol viewers in Mexico |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#American Idol viewers in Mexico
|
| Karaoke? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Karaoke?
|
| Eh? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Eh?
|
| onlyidol website rip-off |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#onlyidol website rip-off
|
| Splitting the seasons |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Splitting the seasons
|
| William Hung |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#William Hung
|
| List of songs performed on American Idol |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#List of songs performed on American Idol
|
| American Idol trivia attribution notice |
9 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#American Idol trivia attribution notice
|
| "Controversy" section |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#"Controversy" section
|
| WikiProject American Idol (or WikiProject Idol series) |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#WikiProject American Idol (or WikiProject Idol series)
|
| WikiIdol |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#WikiIdol
|
| Isn't this a little mean? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Isn't this a little mean?
|
| Impossible to add links? |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Impossible to add links?
|
| Encyclopedia writing style |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Encyclopedia writing style
|
| Category:ITV television programmes |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Category:ITV television programmes
|
| Decade themes: decade or decade in music? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Decade themes: decade or decade in music?
|
| Time Zone Questions |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 1#Time Zone Questions
|
| Prize? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Prize?
|
| American Idol template |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#American Idol template
|
| Season 5 (current season) |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Season 5 (current season)
|
| Most vandalized page |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Most vandalized page
|
| Uncited claim about Mandisa Hundley in the Controversy section |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Uncited claim about Mandisa Hundley in the Controversy section
|
| Semi-Protected |
6 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Semi-Protected
|
| Bottom 3/2 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Bottom 3/2
|
| Article removed from Wikipedia:Good articles |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Article removed from Wikipedia:Good articles
|
| Season 6 template |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Season 6 template
|
| Instruments |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Instruments
|
| Guest Judges |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Guest Judges
|
| Idol Ranks section |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Idol Ranks section
|
| Wordiness |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Wordiness
|
| Contestant navigation templates... help needed |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Contestant navigation templates... help needed
|
| Origins of contestant fan base names |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Origins of contestant fan base names
|
| Title Card |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Title Card
|
| Encyclopedic value of reality show participants |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Encyclopedic value of reality show participants
|
| how do you reconcile these two statements: |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#how do you reconcile these two statements:
|
| Use of templates for elimination histories |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Use of templates for elimination histories
|
| Moving the seasons |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#Moving the seasons
|
| recent edit |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 2#recent edit
|
| List of band songs |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#List of band songs
|
| ABBA for season six? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#ABBA for season six?
|
| Justin Timberlake - Season 1 runner up?! |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Justin Timberlake - Season 1 runner up?!
|
| William Hung Sales? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#William Hung Sales?
|
| facts |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#facts
|
| BLP concerns and tone |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#BLP concerns and tone
|
| Season 6 in the UK |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Season 6 in the UK
|
| Victoria Beckham a Judge? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Victoria Beckham a Judge?
|
| Season synopsis and post AI career bios are way too long |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Season synopsis and post AI career bios are way too long
|
| International networks broadcasting American Idol |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#International networks broadcasting American Idol
|
| Taylor Hicks top selling alumni |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Taylor Hicks top selling alumni
|
| Restore List of American Idol contestants? |
8 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Restore List of American Idol contestants?
|
| American Idol Sponsorship |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#American Idol Sponsorship
|
| Corey Clark Sales |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Corey Clark Sales
|
| Ryan Starr and Kat McPhee Gold? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Ryan Starr and Kat McPhee Gold?
|
| JPL Record Sales |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#JPL Record Sales
|
| Rehearsal Tapings |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Rehearsal Tapings
|
| Top Selling Albums by Idol Alumni |
14 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Top Selling Albums by Idol Alumni
|
| Idol Gives Back is nominated for deletion |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Idol Gives Back is nominated for deletion
|
| Updates |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Updates
|
| Melinda? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Melinda?
|
| Purpose of the show is incorrect |
7 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Purpose of the show is incorrect
|
| Ratings |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Ratings
|
| Prize |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Prize
|
| Clay Aiken's Debut CD is Certified Triple Platinum |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Clay Aiken's Debut CD is Certified Triple Platinum
|
| Ayla Brown sales |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Ayla Brown sales
|
| Top Selling Albums by Idol Alumni |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Top Selling Albums by Idol Alumni 2
|
| Mandisa Sales |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Mandisa Sales
|
| Reality TV star noteability guidelines |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Reality TV star noteability guidelines
|
| RIAA Certification for Clarkson's Albums |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#RIAA Certification for Clarkson's Albums
|
| Jasmine Trias US Album Sales |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Jasmine Trias US Album Sales
|
| Consensus for Thankful and My December's RIAA certification |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Consensus for Thankful and My December's RIAA certification
|
| Top-selling American Idol alumni |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Top-selling American Idol alumni
|
| Academy Awards?? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Academy Awards??
|
| Major award–winning American Idol alumni |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Major award–winning American Idol alumni
|
| Please tell me what is up with everyone singing5 notes for every true note written? |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Please tell me what is up with everyone singing5 notes for every true note written?
|
| Very long article |
10 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Very long article
|
| Idol viewership |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Idol viewership
|
| Order of contestants until they are eliminated |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Order of contestants until they are eliminated
|
| External Links cleanup |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#External Links cleanup
|
| Episode Count |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Episode Count
|
| Removed Summary Opinion |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Removed Summary Opinion
|
| Kristen Holt |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Kristen Holt
|
| Paula Abdul |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Paula Abdul
|
| Billy Joel? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Billy Joel?
|
| Why? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Why?
|
| April 30th Results |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#April 30th Results
|
| Lock This Page! |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Lock This Page!
|
| Winner of Idol 2008 |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Winner of Idol 2008
|
| Album sales |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Album sales
|
| Major award–winning American Idol alumni |
6 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Major award–winning American Idol alumni 2
|
| Tables |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Tables
|
| Rewrite - input requested |
5 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Rewrite - input requested
|
| CTV |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#CTV
|
| Restructuring question |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Restructuring question
|
| Media sponsorship section question |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Media sponsorship section question
|
| In each city? In which city? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#In each city? In which city?
|
| seperate article American Idol seasons |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#seperate article American Idol seasons
|
| Current event, infobox, ratings box, oh my! |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Current event, infobox, ratings box, oh my!
|
| List of Winning Songs from Songwriter Competition |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#List of Winning Songs from Songwriter Competition
|
| Selection process |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Selection process
|
| ratings confusion |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#ratings confusion
|
| New table |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#New table
|
| Confused |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Confused
|
| elimination chart |
6 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#elimination chart
|
| semi final chart |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#semi final chart
|
| colors on main page charts |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#colors on main page charts
|
| Semi-Protected |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Semi-Protected
|
| Adam Lambert |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Adam Lambert
|
| Simon Cowell ... creator? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Simon Cowell ... creator?
|
| Contestant table |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Contestant table
|
| Victoria Beckham |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Victoria Beckham
|
| Bottom group numberings |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Bottom group numberings
|
| New Judge |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#New Judge
|
| American Idol Auditions |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#American Idol Auditions
|
| Season table |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#Season table
|
| American South |
32 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 3#American South
|
| References Needed |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#References Needed
|
| season 10 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#season 10
|
| Season 9 |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Season 9
|
| Prize details |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Prize details
|
| Homophobia. |
7 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Homophobia.
|
| Cost to vote |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Cost to vote
|
| Main article too long |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Main article too long
|
| Another Judge? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Another Judge?
|
| Formatting |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Formatting
|
| Judges changes |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Judges changes
|
| New info about 19 Entertainment |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#New info about 19 Entertainment
|
| Proposal for major rewrite |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Proposal for major rewrite
|
| steven tyler is here!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#steven tyler is here!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
| Major rewriting to commence |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Major rewriting to commence
|
| Major rewriting - Part 2 |
6 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Major rewriting - Part 2
|
| Major rewriting - Part 3 |
5 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Major rewriting - Part 3
|
| Objection to rewrites |
4 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Objection to rewrites
|
| Rewrite |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Rewrite
|
| New Tables |
8 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#New Tables
|
| Choose your tables |
9 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Choose your tables
|
| Deleting tables |
6 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Deleting tables
|
| Proposal to create a new page for Idol alums in film, TV, and theater |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Proposal to create a new page for Idol alums in film, TV, and theater
|
| Controversies |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Controversies
|
| AfD of article interest |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#AfD of article interest
|
| New film, TV and theater page created, the music theater section will be deleted. |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#New film, TV and theater page created, the music theater section will be deleted.
|
| Picture Format |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Picture Format
|
| Season 11 |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Season 11
|
| million dollar record deal / first option to sign contestants - source? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#million dollar record deal / first option to sign contestants - source?
|
| Hiatus? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Hiatus?
|
| Spain broadcast American Idol |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Spain broadcast American Idol
|
| judges/presenters |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#judges/presenters
|
| Ryan Seacrest |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Ryan Seacrest
|
| Reducing article size |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Reducing article size
|
| Infobox needs changing |
7 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Infobox needs changing
|
| Ordering in infobox |
9 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Ordering in infobox
|
| Panelist awards |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Panelist awards
|
| Vandal Alert |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Vandal Alert
|
| To be (present) or not to be (present) |
7 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#To be (present) or not to be (present)
|
| power voting? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#power voting?
|
| Season 12 |
5 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Season 12
|
| J. Lo season 12 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#J. Lo season 12
|
| Judges for 2012? |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 4#Judges for 2012?
|
| Number of consecutive years as the #1 show? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Number of consecutive years as the #1 show?
|
| Alumni in the lead section |
10 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Alumni in the lead section
|
| Please stop keep adding names to lead section |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Please stop keep adding names to lead section
|
| page structure |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#page structure
|
| 7 consecutive #1 in TV ratings |
10 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#7 consecutive #1 in TV ratings
|
| Impact on TV |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Impact on TV
|
| Is this reliable? |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Is this reliable?
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 17 February 2014 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 17 February 2014
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 17 February 2014 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 17 February 2014 2
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 21 February 2014 |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 21 February 2014 2
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 23 February 2014 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 23 February 2014
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 23 February 2014 |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 23 February 2014 2
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 23 March 2014 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 23 March 2014
|
| Infobox photo |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Infobox photo
|
| Name of program |
7 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Name of program
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 27 March 2014 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 27 March 2014
|
| Ratings section |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Ratings section
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 3 May 2014 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 3 May 2014
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 4 May 2014 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 4 May 2014
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#External links modified
|
| "Goodnight America... for now" |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#"Goodnight America... for now"
|
| Proposing new Judges timeline |
6 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Proposing new Judges timeline
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#External links modified 2
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#External links modified 3
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#External links modified 4
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#External links modified 5
|
| Update the Judges Timeline |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Update the Judges Timeline
|
| Season count after revival |
3 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Season count after revival
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 25 June 2018 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 25 June 2018
|
| Table |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Table
|
| 720p or 1080i? |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#720p or 1080i?
|
| Color Templates for Results |
5 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Color Templates for Results
|
| Article for Season 19 |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Article for Season 19
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
|
| Off Broadway Musical |
17 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Off Broadway Musical
|
| Tables |
1 |
Talk:American Idol/Archive 5#Tables
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 22 March 2023 |
2 |
Talk:American Idol#Semi-protected edit request on 22 March 2023
|
| A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for speedy deletion |
1 |
Talk:American Idol#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for speedy deletion
|
| Seeking help with a sidebar for winners |
1 |
Talk:American Idol#Seeking help with a sidebar for winners
|
| Infobox change |
9 |
Talk:American Idol#Infobox change
|
