Talk:Macedonia (Roman province)

Latest comment: 1 year ago by 2601:406:8400:1EA0:49F5:E8DA:3B9D:4725 in topic Early geography of the Roman province of Macedonia


Untitled

edit

Okay, I don't know (or don't remember, having read it before) when the province of Macedonia was divided into Macedonia Prima and Macedonia Salutaris. Internet sources say anywhere from the 3rd Century AD, the Fourth Century AD, or the Fifth Century AD. And Macedonia Salutaris seems to have been reorganized and renamed Macedonia Secunda at some (later) point. ---Alexander 007 11:44, 19 August 2005 (UTC)Reply

Some anonymous users are vandalizing the page for political reasons. The vandalism is focused on Andriscus of Macedon's ancient identity: The original phrase: "... defeated Andriscus of Macedon, the last greek King of Macedon ..." sometimes is vandalized by people of FYROM and changes into the following phrase"... defeated Andriscus of Macedon, the last Macedonian King of Macedon ...". The fact is that the original phrase is neutral and already describes him as a Macedonian (phrase: Andriscus of Macedon, King of Macedonians), while the vandalized version uses the word "Macedonian" 3 times repeately (Andriscus of Macedon, Macedonian King of Macedon), is a tactic with hidden political aspects (by giving him modern ethnic-Macedonian identity). Historically, the modern day Ethnic-Macedonian (Slav Macedonian) identity is absolutely separated and different than the identity of the ancient Macedonians, who where a Greek tribe, like ancient Spartans, ancient Epirots, ancient Corinthians, ancient Athenians, ancient Laecedemonians, etc.

Early geography of the Roman province of Macedonia

edit

I would like to know where in the sources it is stated that Moesia, Dardania and Pannonia early on were part of the province of Macedonia as is stated by this article Aeolic order (talk) 17:47, 22 March 2022 (UTC)Reply

As the article's in-text references indicate, you can read about this at length in Papazoglou, F. (1979). "Quelques aspects de l'histoire de la province de Macédoine". ANRW. ii.7.1: 302–369. and Vanderspoel, John (2010). "Provincia Macedonia". In Roisman, Joseph; Worthington, Ian (eds.). A companion to ancient Macedonia. Chichester, West Sussex, U.K.: Blackwell Publishing. pp. 251–275. ISBN 978-1-405-17936-2.. They collect the (large) number of literary and epigraphic references. Furius (talk) 19:35, 22 March 2022 (UTC)Reply

You just copy-pasted these from the bibliography of the entire article. I want references to the exact thing I am asking. Aeolic order (talk) 21:40, 22 March 2022 (UTC)Reply

Yeah, and I want this page gone because it dismisses my lineage and the current fact that ITS ITS OWN DAMN COUNTRY NOW. Jesus you people are something else. 2601:406:8400:1EA0:49F5:E8DA:3B9D:4725 (talk) 21:02, 30 May 2023 (UTC)Reply