Wikipedia

User:BilledMammal/ARBPIA discussion statistics

This review provides a list of editors who have made:

  1. 20+ comments
  2. In 4+ discussions[a]

It excludes discussions:

  1. With five or less participants[b]
  2. That concluded prior to 2022

The intent is that the vast majority of listings should constitute bludgeoning or otherwise disruptive behavior that discourages uninvolved editors from participating. A manual review confirms that this is the case, although it is important to note that some exceptions do exist.

This review is limited to the these pages. This list contains:

The intent was to create a representative sample of discussions, without risking cherrypicking by creating a custom list of discussions. While this does mean some discussions were excluded the overall impact should be minimal.

It is likely that fourteen editors bludgeoned four or more discussions between 2022 and now:

Editor # discussions bludgeoned List of discussions
Selfstudier (talk · contribs) 37
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 2#Requested move 3 May 2024 2024 83 (out of 544 by 71 editors) 21
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 439#RFC: The Anti-Defamation League 2024 66 (out of 820 by 119 editors) 16.5
Replies
Talk:Israel#Sovereignty over east jerusalem in lead 2024 61 (out of 214 by 14 editors) 22
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 40#Requested move 23 January 2024 2024 58 (out of 524 by 125 editors) 25.5
Replies
Talk:Zionism/Archive 24#Colonial project? 2024 51 (out of 429 by 40 editors) 18
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 93#2nd lead paragraph 2023 49 (out of 298 by 15 editors) 34
Replies
Talk:Sexual and gender-based violence in the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel/Archive 3#Requested move 19 February 2024 2024 39 (out of 210 by 49 editors) 18
Replies
Talk:South Africa's genocide case against Israel/Archive 4#Meaning of the new provisional measure 2024 38 (out of 100 by 6 editors) 33
Replies
Talk:Status of territories occupied by Israel in 1967#Annexation 2022 37 (out of 108 by 6 editors) 65
Replies
Talk:Al-Aqsa Mosque/Archive 6#Requested move 30 May 2022 2022 36 (out of 311 by 26 editors) 28.5
Replies
Talk:2024 Nuseirat rescue operation/Archive 2#Requested move 9 June 2024 2024 34 (out of 135 by 45 editors) 24.5
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 445#Al Jazeera - factual errors 2024 31 (out of 245 by 41 editors) 23
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 100#Request for Comment on apartheid charges 2023 31 (out of 199 by 35 editors) 23
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 97#RfC: Should the lead paragraphs include the sentence "Israel's treatment of the Palestinians within the occupied territories has drawn accusations that it is guilty of the crime of apartheid"? 2023 29 (out of 167 by 48 editors) 49
Replies
Talk:Weaponization of antisemitism/Archive 6#Requested move 21 April 2024 2024 29 (out of 97 by 23 editors) 17
Replies
Talk:Arab citizens of Israel#RFC 2024 29 (out of 100 by 28 editors) 38
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 365#David Price writing in Counterpunch in Edward Said 2022 28 (out of 152 by 25 editors) 37
Replies
Talk:Palestinians#Indigineity 2024 27 (out of 82 by 14 editors) 19
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 41#RfC on genocide accusation in lead 2024 27 (out of 214 by 75 editors) 41
Replies
Talk:January 2023 Jenin incursion#Requested move 1 February 2023 2023 26 (out of 102 by 25 editors) 28
Replies
Talk:Israeli apartheid/Archive 44#Deletion of wikilink 2024 25 (out of 75 by 26 editors) 29
Replies
Talk:Israeli apartheid/Archive 43#Splitting proposal 2022 25 (out of 74 by 13 editors) 34
Replies
Talk:Racial conceptions of Jewish identity in Zionism#Requested move 13 October 2023 2023 24 (out of 155 by 23 editors) 13.5
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 43#UN changes reported casualty figures 2024 24 (out of 97 by 14 editors) 20
Replies
Talk:State of Palestine/Archive 17#RFC about de jure 2022 24 (out of 75 by 21 editors) 51
Replies
Talk:Palestinian citizens of Israel#Requested move 26 November 2021 2022 24 (out of 94 by 12 editors) 29
Replies
Talk:UNRWA and Israel/Archive 3#POV tag 2024 23 (out of 68 by 7 editors) 55
Replies
Talk:Weaponization of antisemitism/Archive 8#Dueness of Livingstone formulation material 2024 23 (out of 53 by 6 editors) 53
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 436#Middle East Monitor 2024 23 (out of 191 by 20 editors) 17
Replies
Talk:Weaponization of antisemitism/Archive 3#Cartoons 2024 23 (out of 65 by 8 editors) 25
Replies
Talk:Gaza Strip famine/Archive 1#Requested move 24 April 2024 2024 22 (out of 103 by 29 editors) 17.5
Replies
Talk:Al-Shifa Hospital siege/Archive 1#Requested move 15 November 2023 2023 22 (out of 74 by 20 editors) 28.5
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 105#RfC: mention apartheid in the lead? 2024 21 (out of 164 by 40 editors) 32
Replies
Talk:Weaponization of antisemitism/Archive 5#Adding POV and POV LEDE tags 2024 21 (out of 76 by 12 editors) 20
Replies
Talk:Anti-Defamation League#Pro-Israel advocacy in lead 2024 21 (out of 105 by 15 editors) 24
Replies
Talk:1948 Palestinian expulsion and flight/Archive 18#Requested move 8 September 2022 2022 21 (out of 114 by 26 editors) 24
Replies
Talk:Jerusalem/Archive 28#Should the infobox contain this flag and emblem? 2022 20 (out of 143 by 51 editors) 27.5
Replies
Nableezy (talk · contribs) 20
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 32#Hamas denial of sexual violence in lede 2023 93 (out of 246 by 18 editors) 39
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 87#Condensing international rankings fluff in lead 2022 46 (out of 148 by 13 editors) 34.5
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 93#2nd lead paragraph 2023 41 (out of 298 by 15 editors) 43
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 435#Books by Norman Finkelstein 2024 39 (out of 252 by 29 editors) 24
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 365#David Price writing in Counterpunch in Edward Said 2022 36 (out of 152 by 25 editors) 39.5
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 84#Golan Heights? 2022 34 (out of 124 by 17 editors) 55
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 434#Al Jazeera reliability 2024 33 (out of 176 by 33 editors) 37
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 367#Deprecation RfC: CounterPunch 2022 31 (out of 191 by 62 editors) 70
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 436#Middle East Monitor 2024 31 (out of 191 by 20 editors) 48
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 363#Rerun Counterpunch RFC? 2022 30 (out of 78 by 17 editors) 60
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 40#Requested move 23 January 2024 2024 29 (out of 524 by 125 editors) 36
Replies
Talk:Alice Walker/Archive 2#Antisemitism in section heading 2022 28 (out of 67 by 15 editors) 35
Replies
Talk:2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel/Archive 4#"Hamas and allies victory" 2023 27 (out of 82 by 12 editors) 30
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 96#3rd lead paragraph (March 25) 2023 27 (out of 106 by 10 editors) 40
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 26#Expansion to war crimes section 2023 26 (out of 65 by 13 editors) 39
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 439#RFC: The Anti-Defamation League 2024 25 (out of 820 by 119 editors) 26
Replies
Talk:Al-Ahli Arab Hospital explosion/Archive 6#Forensic Architecture reliability 2023 22 (out of 84 by 18 editors) 49.5
Replies
Talk:Falafel/Archive 5#COATRACK and UNDUE? 2023 22 (out of 51 by 7 editors) 39.5
Replies
Talk:1948 Palestinian expulsion and flight/Archive 18#Requested move 8 September 2022 2022 21 (out of 114 by 26 editors) 78
Replies
Talk:The Washington Institute for Near East Policy#pro-Israel 2023 20 (out of 54 by 7 editors) 32.5
Replies
Iskandar323 (talk · contribs) 19
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 439#RFC: The Anti-Defamation League 2024 68 (out of 820 by 119 editors) 42.5
Replies
Talk:Al-Aqsa Mosque/Archive 6#Requested move 30 May 2022 2022 43 (out of 311 by 26 editors) 29
Replies
Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 2#Requested move 3 May 2024 2024 42 (out of 544 by 71 editors) 34.5
Replies
Talk:Palestinian genocide accusation#Requested move 21 July 2024 2024 35 (out of 199 by 57 editors) 42
Replies
Talk:Ascalon#Requested move 20 July 2024 2024 32 (out of 111 by 20 editors) 68
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 93#2nd lead paragraph 2023 30 (out of 298 by 15 editors) 29
Replies
Talk:Al-Shifa ambulance airstrike#RfC: Should the first mention of the Gaza Health Ministry disclose that the same is a subagency of Hamas? 2023 29 (out of 173 by 31 editors) 30
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 438#Jewish Chronicle 2024 25 (out of 117 by 20 editors) 62
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 107#Lead: paragraph on culture 2024 24 (out of 285 by 16 editors) 35.5
Replies
Talk:Flour massacre/Archive 1#Requested move 29 February 2024 2024 23 (out of 400 by 114 editors) 20
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 434#Al Jazeera reliability 2024 23 (out of 176 by 33 editors) 44
Replies
Talk:Weaponization of antisemitism/Archive 4#Renaming the article 2024 23 (out of 79 by 12 editors) 38
Replies
Talk:1948 Palestinian expulsion and flight/Archive 18#Requested move 8 September 2022 2022 22 (out of 114 by 26 editors) 45
Replies
Talk:1989 Tel Aviv–Jerusalem bus attack#Requested move 29 August 2024 2024 21 (out of 53 by 12 editors) 36
Replies
Talk:Genocide of indigenous peoples/Archive 7#RFC: Palestinian genocide accusations 2024 21 (out of 203 by 37 editors) 42
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 434#Is it time to re-evaluate the ADL? 2024 21 (out of 125 by 31 editors) 40
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 95#Permanently tagged article, and WP:BRD? 2023 21 (out of 142 by 14 editors) 40
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 85#Condensing overblown history in the lead 2022 20 (out of 71 by 9 editors) 25
Replies
Talk:2018–2019 Gaza border protests#Requested move 24 March 2024 2024 20 (out of 79 by 15 editors) 40.5
Replies
FortunateSons (talk · contribs) 9
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 439#RFC: The Anti-Defamation League 2024 76 (out of 820 by 119 editors) 35
Replies
Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 2#Requested move 3 May 2024 2024 53 (out of 544 by 71 editors) 40
Replies
Talk:South Africa's genocide case against Israel/Archive 4#Meaning of the new provisional measure 2024 45 (out of 100 by 6 editors) 32
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 104#Combined Version #3 2024 42 (out of 122 by 7 editors) 44.5
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 436#Middle East Monitor 2024 31 (out of 191 by 20 editors) 26
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 425#Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor 2024 30 (out of 120 by 19 editors) 59
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 429#Is NGO Monitor a reliable (but obviously not unbiased) source regarding statements about NGOs and the BLP associated with them? 2024 28 (out of 106 by 30 editors) 59.5
Replies
Talk:Flour massacre/Archive 1#Requested move 29 February 2024 2024 26 (out of 400 by 114 editors) 32
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 103#Mention of Apartheid in Lead 2024 20 (out of 66 by 8 editors) 41.5
Replies
Levivich (talk · contribs) 9
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Zionism/Archive 24#Colonial project? 2024 74 (out of 429 by 40 editors) 50
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 93#2nd lead paragraph 2023 70 (out of 298 by 15 editors) 50
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 435#Books by Norman Finkelstein 2024 30 (out of 252 by 29 editors) 69
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 439#RFC: The Anti-Defamation League 2024 27 (out of 820 by 119 editors) 38
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 96#3rd lead paragraph (March 25) 2023 25 (out of 106 by 10 editors) 25
Replies
Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 2#Requested move 3 May 2024 2024 22 (out of 544 by 71 editors) 62.5
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 95#Permanently tagged article, and WP:BRD? 2023 22 (out of 142 by 14 editors) 66
Replies
Talk:Arab citizens of Israel#RFC 2024 21 (out of 100 by 28 editors) 37
Replies
Talk:Israel#Sovereignty over east jerusalem in lead 2024 20 (out of 214 by 14 editors) 32
Replies
Andrevan (talk · contribs) 7
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Racial conceptions of Jewish identity in Zionism/Archive 6#Requested move 3 September 2023 2023 34 (out of 141 by 17 editors) 93.5
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 418#Are Hamas and Gaza ministry numbers reliable? 2023 30 (out of 101 by 20 editors) 22
Replies
Talk:Zionism#NPOV balance issue in lead 2024 29 (out of 69 by 9 editors) 36
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 32#Hamas denial of sexual violence in lede 2023 29 (out of 246 by 18 editors) 28
Replies
Talk:Zionism#Where to start this article 2024 27 (out of 70 by 11 editors) 42
Replies
Talk:Racial conceptions of Jewish identity in Zionism#Requested move 13 October 2023 2023 25 (out of 155 by 23 editors) 50
Replies
Talk:Al-Ahli Arab Hospital explosion/Archive 5#Time to start saying it was a Palestinian rocket? 2023 22 (out of 78 by 25 editors) 16.5
Replies
Nishidani (talk · contribs) 7
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Zionism/Archive 24#Colonial project? 2024 45 (out of 429 by 40 editors) 102
Replies
Talk:Racial conceptions of Jewish identity in Zionism/Archive 5#Title 2023 32 (out of 164 by 15 editors) 121.5
Replies
Talk:Racial conceptions of Jewish identity in Zionism/Archive 6#Requested move 3 September 2023 2023 30 (out of 141 by 17 editors) 100
Replies
Talk:Samaritans/Archive 2#Land of Israel or Palestine (region) 2022 29 (out of 81 by 9 editors) 157
Replies
Talk:Anti-Zionism/Archive 14#Recent eviscerations 2022 28 (out of 49 by 6 editors) 154
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 367#Deprecation RfC: CounterPunch 2022 24 (out of 191 by 62 editors) 129.5
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 97#RfC: Should the lead paragraphs include the sentence "Israel's treatment of the Palestinians within the occupied territories has drawn accusations that it is guilty of the crime of apartheid"? 2023 21 (out of 167 by 48 editors) 171
Replies
BilledMammal (talk · contribs) 6
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 434#Al Jazeera reliability 2024 36 (out of 176 by 33 editors) 50.5
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 445#Al Jazeera - factual errors 2024 32 (out of 245 by 41 editors) 71.5
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 40#Requested move 23 January 2024 2024 30 (out of 524 by 125 editors) 59.5
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 436#Middle East Monitor 2024 28 (out of 191 by 20 editors) 40
Replies
Talk:Al-Shifa Hospital siege/Archive 1#Requested move 15 November 2023 2023 21 (out of 74 by 20 editors) 53
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 36#Rockets falling short 2024 21 (out of 78 by 12 editors) 47
Replies
Vegan416 (talk · contribs) 5
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 439#RFC: The Anti-Defamation League 2024 76 (out of 820 by 119 editors) 54
Replies
Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 2#Requested move 3 May 2024 2024 56 (out of 544 by 71 editors) 39
Replies
Talk:Zionism/Archive 24#Colonial project? 2024 46 (out of 429 by 40 editors) 58
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 435#Books by Norman Finkelstein 2024 36 (out of 252 by 29 editors) 53
Replies
Talk:Genocide of indigenous peoples/Archive 7#RFC: Palestinian genocide accusations 2024 21 (out of 203 by 37 editors) 50
Replies
Onceinawhile (talk · contribs) 5
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Al-Aqsa Mosque/Archive 6#Requested move 30 May 2022 2022 64 (out of 311 by 26 editors) 52
Replies
Talk:Status of territories occupied by Israel in 1967#Annexation 2022 34 (out of 108 by 6 editors) 81
Replies
Talk:Zionism/Archive 21#Question 2023 24 (out of 96 by 10 editors) 83
Replies
Talk:Racial conceptions of Jewish identity in Zionism/Archive 5#Title 2023 21 (out of 164 by 15 editors) 54
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 93#2nd lead paragraph 2023 20 (out of 298 by 15 editors) 57
Replies
Kowal2701 (talk · contribs) 5
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 107#Lead: paragraph on culture 2024 75 (out of 285 by 16 editors) 38
Replies
Talk:Israel/Archive 105#RfC: mention apartheid in the lead? 2024 35 (out of 164 by 40 editors) 24
Replies
Talk:2024 Iranian strikes against Israel/Archive 1#RfC "Result" 2024 25 (out of 93 by 29 editors) 21
Replies
Talk:Israel#RFC: How should the Nakba described? 2024 23 (out of 87 by 25 editors) 49.5
Replies
Talk:Nakba/Archive 5#wording in lede 2024 20 (out of 40 by 6 editors) 21
Replies
NoCal100 (talk · contribs) (×9) 5
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Zionism/Archive 24#Colonial project? 2024 47 (out of 429 by 40 editors) 50
Replies
Talk:2024 Nuseirat rescue operation/Archive 1#POV title 2024 30 (out of 99 by 21 editors) 32.5
Replies
Talk:2024 Nuseirat rescue operation/Archive 2#Requested move 9 June 2024 2024 25 (out of 135 by 45 editors) 27
Replies
Talk:Al Bureij killings#Requested move 19 June 2022 2023 24 (out of 65 by 13 editors) 40
Replies
Talk:Jerusalem/Archive 27#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 17 August 2022 2022 20 (out of 76 by 8 editors) 31.5
Replies
M.Bitton (talk · contribs) 5
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Genocide of indigenous peoples/Archive 7#RFC: Palestinian genocide accusations 2024 33 (out of 203 by 37 editors) 19
Replies
Talk:List of Islamist terrorist attacks/Archive 9#Should Operation Al-Aqsa Flood by Hamas included in the list of Islamist Terrorist attacks? 2023 27 (out of 276 by 55 editors) 31
Replies
Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 436#Middle East Monitor 2024 27 (out of 191 by 20 editors) 26
Replies
Talk:2024 Nuseirat rescue operation#Proposed merge of Nuseirat refugee camp massacre into 2024 Nuseirat rescue operation 2024 24 (out of 178 by 70 editors) 29.5
Replies
Talk:Arabs/Archive 14#RfC about arabs being ethnolinguistic group 2023 23 (out of 80 by 14 editors) 29
Replies
Coretheapple (talk · contribs) 4
Discussions
Discussion Year # comments Median # of words Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 32#Hamas denial of sexual violence in lede 2023 47 (out of 246 by 18 editors) 42
Replies
Talk:Anti-Defamation League#Pro-Israel advocacy in lead 2024 39 (out of 105 by 15 editors) 50
Replies
Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 40#Requested move 23 January 2024 2024 27 (out of 524 by 125 editors) 48
Replies
Talk:Sexual and gender-based violence in the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel/Archive 3#Requested move 19 February 2024 2024 21 (out of 210 by 49 editors) 34
Replies

Additional analysis

edit

I am willing to rerun this analysis with different configurations at any editors request. The options include:

  • A different or expanded list of discussions
  • A different number of comments considered bludgeoning
  • A different date range
  • A different number of discussions bludgeoned required for inclusion

Clarifications

edit
  • This analysis counts the number of comments that an editor made in a discussion by looking for an editors signature. It does not count the number of edits.
  • This analysis counts every comment made within the discussion
  • This analysis lists all editors who bludgeoned at least four discussions within the reviewed pages. Editors who bludgeoned less than four are not listed.
  • The word count is limited to prose. While the method of producing this value is highly accurate, some errors may occur.
  • Sockpuppets are grouped under the master's name:
    • Master's that bludgeoned are listed in red, with the number of accounts used in parenthesis next to their name
    • Replies to sockpuppets are listed in red. The impact of these replies is minimal.
  • The intent of this isn’t to get specific editors into trouble. This is a common issue in the topic area, and it can’t be resolved with targeted sanctions - instead, broad remedies are required.

Notes

edit
  1. ^ Chosen as under the original analysis, that was the number required to include myself in the list
  2. ^ Chosen as discussions with few participants are less likely to be bludgeoning. See this discussion
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:BilledMammal/ARBPIA_discussion_statistics&oldid=1250817547"